Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Write 1o SO, PO Box London SE15 4NA…]

Socialist Organiser no. 468, 30 November 1990 · scan p. 14 · about 585 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Write 1o SO, PO Box London SE15 4NA •J Siddon is far too • soft on Ed McBain (SO 467). To claim that there are few jarring moments in the 87th Precinct novels strikes me as very odd.

Take McBain's sexism. Teddy Carella, the wife of the precinct chief, is the grossest example; literally a beautiful dumb (and deaf) woman, always sexually available to Carella, silent and servile.

The same applies to partWHAITHS-ON Saturday 1 December. 'The Left Agenda for 1991, , with Tony Benn and Ken Livingstone. Organised by Labour Left Liaison. London School of Economics, Houghton St, WC1. E3/E2/£1, 10.30am-5.00pm Saturday 1 December. 'Conference on Debt impact on Third World. Organised by Campaign for Non-Alignment. Red Rose Club, 129 Seven Sisters Road, London N7. E5/E2, 10.00am-5.30pm Saturday 1 December. Anti-war demonstration in Bridgewater (Tom King's constituency). Speakers include Campaign Against War in the Gulf and CARI Saturday 1 December.

Demonstration marking the third anniversary of the intifada. Assemble 12 noon, Malet St, Saturday 1 December. "Kurdistan: History and Culture: Conference ners of the precinct cops, those curiously available models and secretaries, whose abductions and jealousies provide problems for the men of the 87th.

Even the sole female cop is used in typically sex-specific roles, as bait for the mugger in "Fuzz' . And what about the tone of the earlier novels, such as Meyer's running joke about "instant pussy' in "The Mugger' and the descriptions of Byrnes in 'Cop Hater' as 'a man trapped in the labial folds of a society structure; just what does that mean?

It's true that there are blacks, hispanics, Jews and Irish cops in the precinct but that doesn't necessarily get McBain out of the woods. In "Jigsaw' Brown (very big, black, ironic) exhibits McBain's liberal, indıvıdual answers to racism (and a lot more besides) when he frightens a confession out of a southern white woman. Meyer Meyer's experience of anti-semitism becomes a running joke, repeated time and again, to explain his silly name.

organised by Kurdistan Solidarity Committee. Trade Union Centre, Brabant Road, London N22. £2.50/€1.50. 11.00am-7.30pm Saturday 1 December. World AIDS Day Act-Up Event. Tate Library, Brixton. 10.30am5.30pm Saturday 1-Sunday 2 December. Fighting for Workers Liberty' Socialist Organiser student weekend in Manchester. Details 071 639 7967 Sunday 2 December. Women Against War in the Gulf meeting. Conway Hall, Red Lion Square, London. 12.00 Sunday 2 December. Socialist Movement (Scotland) Forum and AGM. The Cowane Centre, Cowant St, Stirling. 12.00-4.00pm Sunday 2 December. Anti-Gulf war blockade of Ministry of Defence. MoD, Whitehall. 3.00pm Sunday 2 December. 'From Cold War to Gulf War. Socialist Society seminar. Speakers include John Palmer and Dan Smith, Polytechnic But all this is less important than the image of basically good cops with the occasional bad apple trying - oh so hard — in a tough world. The liberalism and the empirical approach of the cops is supposed to be th: key to success, even though crimes are often solved merely by chance.

The ideology of McBain's work is a response to the concrete jungle of capitalist America, to the throwing up of hands in despair. What we can do, what cops actually do is get on with the job. McBain ends up endorsing the 'we're not political, we're only doing our job' attitude to "law enforcement' Socialists should see through this. Mind you, I'm still addicted to McBain's stuff!

Jon Pike Glasgow

----- pull-quotes -----

WRITEBACK Vear 5.0., Lou've done it again Your recent artide on the with trice he Con

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 468

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →