Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Born out ot her time

Socialist Organiser no. 468, 30 November 1990 · scan p. 13 · about 997 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Belinda Weaver re Angel At My Table W My Table', • I couldn't latching An Angel At help feeling that Janet Frame, the writer on whose life the film is based, was born out of her time.

In the film, Kerry Fox, who plays Frame in her tormented twenties and thirties, has a sensitivity, a luminosity, that makes her sisters and their friends, with their 1940s hair and make-up seem dull and ordinary.

Frame, with her mop of unruly red hair, is a stand-out; she's not like anyone else. In small-town New Zealand, in the conventional 1940S, that made her a freak, an outcast.

Frame had a tragic early life. Her twin sister died within two weeks of her birth, and Frame was to lose two more sisters in drowning accidents. Her only brother suffered from recurrent epileptic fits; he was ostracised at school, and later unable to hold down a job.

Frame's family were poor, and cramped conditions at home forced intimacy on the girls; they shared a room and a bed whether they liked it or not. But Frame never really connected with her family. She loved them, and they were kind to her, but there was a huge chasm between their daily round and her yearning, poetic, imaginative nature.

Her family weren't villains. They were good, kindly people. But they couldn't understand her. They couldn't help her.

As a child, Frame had lost the only friend who counted, a girl who shared her romantic imagination. As she grew up, Frame became increasingly shy and withdrawn, retreating more and more into the world of books; she felt safe there.

Bright and gifted as she was, she made no successes after school; her shyness soon became overwhelming. Increasingly lonely and withdrawn, she came to be seen as an oddity, as someone on the brink of madness, someoné who needed help.

Watching the film, one is struck by Frame's longing to connect with people. Her shy surprise makes her face light up when anyone notices her or treats her kindly. But she lacks any kind of ease or social small talk. By the time she thinks out what to say, the person has moved on, leaving her more alone than before.

Frame was diagnosed as schizophrenic, and placed in a terrifying mental hospital, where she remained eight years, and where she was forced to submit to over 200 bouts of electric shock treatment, each, she says sadly, "equivalent in fear to an execution"

Only her writing talent saved her. All through her lonely life, Frame had written - poems and stories that were her connection with the world she could not otherwise reach. When her work won prizes, she was freed, and she determined to become a full-time writer.

She also travelled, she got away to a wider world.

With several books to her credit now, Frame is no longer unknown; she has made a success at the one truly important thing in her life.

Yet the film leaves us with no glib rosy ending. Frame at the end is certainly happier; she has the work and the recognition she wanted. But connections with people remain elusive. She is on her own at the end, writing alone, dancing alone; her writing is still her only connec tion to people.

That may have changed; Kerry Fox plays Janet Frame only takes us through part of Frame's life, the parts she wrote about in her autobiographical trilogy, "To the Is-land" "An angel at my table", , and "The envoy from Mirror City" . These deal more with her sufferings and struggles than with triumphs, though after so much sadness, her very survival must rank as a triumph.

Sad as the film is, it is well worth seeing, largely for Kerry Fox's performance as Janet, but also for the depiction of school and family life in remote New Zealand before and after the war. Apart from the middle section, it is not a film where much happens. Action is not the point; what the director, Jane Campion, is trying to get across are memories and feelings, states of mind and emotion.

Thomas oald Dahl, who died cancer last week at the age of 74, was a phenomenally successful author of books for children. He deserved his success. His children's books are truly remarkable.

The world of this writer's imaginary children is a world of magic and free-wheeling fantasy. But it is not a never-never world, because his child protagonists are not nevernever kids. They are real kids.

The world they inhabit is not the real world his readers live in, but it contains the real sorts of people his readers would know.

It depicts - heightened and exaggerated and, sometimes, idealised as in the father-son relationship in *Danny, the Champion the World' - the real relationship between children and adults. The relationships his readers would live every day of their lives.

His is a world in which children are weak and vulnerable and, unless they fight back and thereby hangs Dahl's tales - at the mercy of hostile, predatory and indifferent adults.

Dahl's genius as a writer for children lay in the fact that he never forgot the feel, or the pain, of being a small child at the mercy of those adults.

He never lost, his sense of grievance at his own ill-treatment as a boy, and told about it in the autebiographical "Boy'.

The heroes of his stories experience triumphs and happy endings, but you are never left with an Enid Blyton or Richmal Crompton feeling that the best of all possible worlds has thereby returned to its natural benign state at the end of the storv.

Dahl has been criticised because there are truly nasty things in his books. So there are. And so there are too in a child's world The young Dahl kept pace with the adult, and in his children's stories the adult waged a sort of literary guerrilla war on behalf of

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 468

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →