Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The demagogue's tale

Socialist Organiser no. 468, 30 November 1990 · scan pp. 12–13 · about 1,560 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Books This early 1969 Mandelite group characteristic m thoughtlessness They would get Sean Matgamna Ali's "Redemption' Tarig Ali still seeks, and gets, an audience on the left. He "read from" his novel 'Redemption' at the recent Socialist Movement conference to a tolerant friendly audience. That fact tells you a lot about some people in the Socialist Movement.

For a decade he was the best known British public representative of Ernest Mandel's version of Trotskyism, Tariq Ali is the scion of a family of rich Pakistani landlords. He is an upper-class Englishman by education and choice. His curriculum vitae Oxford University, 'President of the Union' etc etc — is identical to that of two of the three candidates in the present contest for leader of the Tory Party.

That sort of background is common to a disproportionate number of socialists.

It is stupid and repulsive when socialist groupings like Militant, for example, attempt to make such people into morally blackjacked second class citizens because of their background. That is the principle of aristocracy rather than the principle of democratic equality and common citizenship, except that it is the geneology of the worker which is prized.

If such people really come into the socialist movement they should be welcomed. One problem with them is that most come to teach when they should come as pupils, and they come too as ego-tripping wild-oats-sowing dilettantes.

Tariq Ali, though he stayed longer, is no exception. His family were Stalinists. In the late '60s he came over to Trotskyism during the great anti-Vietnam war movement. As one of the organisers, though in no way central to it, Tariq Ali, the posh upper class English gentleman with the darker skin, quickly became the focus of media coverage. of the anti-war movement. He is not known to have found this uncongenial. The evidence suggests that the media attention became the bread of life to him. cona joined the Mandelite Fourth Interna', probably for the wrong reasons. They were serious people, but woolly about Stalinism. It was only in 1969 that they decided, after 20 years, that the Chinese working class needed to make a revolution against Mao Tse Tung!

Ali remained a quasi-Stalinist and therefore, I guess, it was the group's mistakes he found most congenial. He was soft on Mao and wrote articles in praise of Kim Il Sung of North Korea. He saw the socialist revolution as an onward march of the Stalinist parties and the role of Trotskyism as The Fight hemational against In HIM Place of Strife are magazine cover, produced by the Tariq Ali joined, nicely catches their xture of naivety, pretentiousness, and unconscious British chauvinism. worse in the early '70s.

The demagogue that of mere left critic of this movement. The files of 'Black Dawrf', 'Red Mole' and 'Red Weekly', the Mandelite press of the time, are full of such notions. Tariq Ali was one of those people who had learned to talk - and write - before they'd learned to think.

He hardened up in the "70s. But the disappointment he displays in this novel at the collapse of Stalinism proves that at root he never ceased to view the Trotskyist movement as a mere appendage of Stalinism. He explicitly says as much here.

As late as the 1978 Stalinist-army coup in Afghanistan (which prepared the USSR's invasion 20 months later and the beginning of Russia's own 8 year long 'Vietnam War') he hailed progressive Stalinism in action. Taraki and Amin, he wrote approvingly in Socialist Challenge, had found in the party-army officer partnership which took power a new vehicle for socialist revolution.

He baulked, however, when his comrades -in their majority: there was a big minority -supported the Russian forces in Afghanistan. He lett the organisation, but remained on the Trotskisant left, and is still an Associate Editor of New Left Review.

"Redemption' is, I suppose, an attempt at a comic novel rather than a satire, though he may have intended satire. It chronicles the impact on the citizens of the Trotskyist archipelago of the collapse of Eastern European Stalinism last year. A number of organisations and individuals are presented in the thinnest of disguises as they respond to 'Ezra Einstein's' (Ernest Mandel's) call for a world congress of all the factions to discuss the future.

But there is little invention and no comic or satirical creativity in the book. He dredges through the long and sometimes richly eccentric ou year history of many organisations for grotesque stories and piles them up without artistic selection, like articles in a junk shop window.

The Moliner brothers, leaders of one of the French groups of the '30s, ran a debt collection agency in Paris. Here Tariq Ali has someone run a brothel. One of the clients is Posadas, an Argentine Trotskyist who went crazy in the '60s, advocating that the Russians start World War Ill. The younger Posadas arrives from Argentina with a parrot on his shoulder (a live one: the only dead parrot in 'Redemption' was sitting at Tariq Ali's word processor).

And the wit? Gerry Healy here is called Hood and the Healyites are - wait for it -the Hoodlums; the SWP's Tony Cliff is Rock

ue

and - prepare yourself for another uncontrollable giggle — the SWP is "The Rockers'. (Chanie Rosenberg, Tony Cliff's wife, is. guess who? Sugar Rock!)

Nearly all the leaders are Jews and the whole 60 year affair of "Trotskyism' is presented as a squabbling of comic and mainly obnoxious old Jews.

Smutty, smutty peculiar and would-be scatological sex does service in the book for wit. It is not grown up sex. Some of the women are presented sympathetically, but nevertheless there is a pathetically juvenile obsession with, and judgement by, penises, down to Gerry Healy being given a false one (made of iron, no less). The character who is Jack Barnes is put down, and shut up — and, I think, intended by the author to be humiliated — by his randy comrade wife lowering herself onto his face.... Weirdest of all is having the Ernest Mandel character — a "It is plain from the that Tariq Ali is no even a Trotskisant because he always Trotskyism as an appendage of Stalinism, and Stalinism is now collapsing. The Mandelite: should ask themselves what it was in their own movement which allowed him to do that."

70 year old man —lactate and breastfeed, (This is not so much a case of the phallic mothers as of a man suffering from the mammaries and fatheries of gender confusion). I was left wondering yet again at the awful things the upper classes do when they send their confused young sons to boarding school; I had the feeling you get when someone who doesn't interest you tells you about highly personal sexual obsessions fantasies.

As a comic novel it lacks a core, and despite rich real-life sources he can and does draw upon, the author runs out of steam quickly. The nearest it gets to anything like a satiric conception is having Ezra Einstein propose 'entry" into the Christian, Jewish and Muslim church hierarchies.

'Redemption' is an unrefined jumble of half-baked internal squibs and in-jokes, neither a true comic novel nor a satire.

It has no bite: it is a crude and clumsy, and half-hysterical poking of fun rather than satire, which has to be a creative reconceptualisation. Instead of the manic extrapolations that might produce a good comic novel we are served up a flat collection of stale old stories in a sauce of schoolboy 'sex' Even in his finale, Tariq Ali is not being inventive, just remembering. When he went back to Pakistan in the early '70s he made a great show of proclaiming himself a Muslim. Maybe that's the problem: everything Trotskyist has for decades been born into the world as twins, triplets and quadruplets. It is like a series of shadows. Every group has its own caricatural and satirical alter ego. For example: SO has Workers Power.

Tariq Ali's problem is that — despite his devastated disappointment at the failure of Stalinism — he still retains the viewpoint of a sub-section of the Mandel international: the politics have gone but the factional hatreds and spite remain. He is particularly vicious and stupid and unjust about the SWP (GB)

Charlie Van Gelderen, a veteran of 60 years in the Trotskyist movement, writes in Socialist Outlook that the explanation for Tariq Ali's political rubbishing of his longtime associates is that he is now quite famous as a TV producer and playwright. He wants to 'integrate' • Maybe. I don't know. For former comrades of Tariq Ali this sort of explanation - even if it is a big part of the truth, as it probably is — is a form of lying to themselves.

It is plain from the book that Tariq Ali is no longer even a Trotskisant because he always saw Trotskyism as an appendage of Stalinism, and Stalinism is now collapsing. The Mandelites should ask themselves what it was in their own movement which allowed him to do that.

Tariq Ali has something to teach the remaining Mandelites. It is not what he thinks he wants to teach them. But they'd do well to pay attention.

Scan page 13

ULTURAL FRONT Wiser Roald Dahl

----- pull-quotes -----

TENDONE PERMANENT REVODUTTON REACHES UK Why we marching

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 468

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →