Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The same people, the same policies

Socialist Organiser no. 468, 30 November 1990 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 1,067 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

-Sign The National TO PETITION to the -QUEENAnti Common Market was a main leader of Labour's left in the 50s, and '70s, and burned-out Labour leader in the great revolutionary tradition of the common people.

To a considerable extent, the other left, Mary Robinson's left, is formed by way of one-sided polemical reaction to, and criticism of, the older populist Republican left. A sizeable chunk of the criticism is avowedly Marxist - from the Workers' Party, for example. The Provo revolt in the North has driven the southern establishment and its academics to subject to radical revision the old "Fianna Fail nationalism" from which the populist left draws much of its strength (promising to really achieve the common goals, instead of just talking about them). The patent bankruptcy of the populist left has driven many leftists in this direction. Understandably so.

It resembles the situation in the Russian Empire back in the 1890s when the old populist movement there was plainly bankrupt, and at the same time many people who had subscribed to its ideas wanted to make their peace with developing Russian capitalism. As Leon Trotsky put it:

Until the nineties the greater part of the Russian intelligentsia was stagnating in Populist theories with their rejection of capitalist development and idealisation of peasant communal ownership oj the land. And capitalism in the meantime was holding out to the intelligentsia the promise of all sorts of material blessings and political inluence. The sharp knife of Marxism was the instrument by which the bourgeois intelligentsia cut the Populist umbilical cord, and severed itself from a hated past. It was this that accounted for the swift and victorious spread of Marxism during the latter years of the last century.

As soon as Marxism had accomplished this, however, it began to irk this same intelligentsia. Its dialectics were convenient for demonstrating the progress of capitalist methods of development, but finding that it led to a revolutionary rejection of the whole capitalist system, they adjudged it an impediment and declared it out of date. At the turn of the century, at the time when I was in prison and exile, the Russian intelligentsia was going through a phase of widespread criticism oj Marxism. They accepted its historical justification of capitalism, but discarded its rejection of capitalism by revolutionary means. In this roundabout way the old Populist intelligentsia, with its archaic sympathies, was slowly being transformed into a liberal bourgeois intelligentsia. "

A fully-formed Irish working-class left has yet to emerge. It will fight for all that the "Robinson" left fights for — but for a lot more as well. It will settle accounts with the old "populist revolutionary" ideas, not, like so many in the "Robinson" left, in order to settle into a quiet life with the Irish and European bourgeoisie, but, like the revolutionary Russian Marxist critics of their populism — Plekhanov, Lenin, Trotsky and their comrades - the better to settle accounts with the Irish and international bourgeoisie.

A miner's diary •hatcher going just a cosmetic exercise. The Tories are stil in power. They will be carrying out the same sort of policies.

They bumped off Thatcher as a public relations exercise to try and win back disgruntled voters with a bit of plastic surgery to create a more acceptable face for Toryism.

Mysell, I think it's a complete sham. 1 think Labour has sadly missed the chance to mount a convincing attack on the government.

I find it funny that many Tories are upset about the voting procedure which allowed a sitting Prime Minister to be challenged and defeated, and now they're having a look at the rules. I seems to me ironic that we have very precise Tory legislation about the way we elect a trade union leader - and look at how they kill off and elect Prime Ministers!

movement? Of course they won't!

We hear funny noises from the Labour Party but before Kinnock and Hattersley go on about the rights and wrongs of the Tory leadership battle they should clean up their own act first.

The Labour Party should be showing the way forward towards an accountable democratic organisation. And romember that the Labour Party itself says that much of the Tory anti-union legislation will stay on the statute books.

The very widespread anti-Thatcher feeling was looked at very closely by the Tories and they decided to pull a flanker, ditch Thatcher and put somebody else in and then try to con everybody that they have changed.

Of course they haven't changed!

The Tories are now trying to ram home that Major is going to create a classless society. It's a load of bullshit but a lot of people will be pulled in by that. Labour should go on the offensive.

Paul Whetton is a member of Manton NUM he second annual Tommy Sheridan Past we mend bade healin tee last weekend, under the auspices of the All Britain Anti-Poll Tax Federation annual general meeting.

The charismatic Tommy sat, often alone, on the podium, orchestrating all the events of the day. He spoke to everything that came up, endlessly intervened, chaired the conference, and told all the supporters of Militant which way to vote.

There was one unexpectedly close vote, when Tommy forgot to tell people the line and most delegates abstained!

Needless to say, all supporters of Militant who stood for positions were elected. As a result we can look forward to another year of the campaign being stifled from the top. The SWP were very radical and revolutionary in their shouting, heckling and chanting, no doubt reflecting last week's "upturn" and decisive change in the balance of class forces. Apparently, now that things are rosy and on the up, national demonstrations don't need to be organised in advance - they can be spontaneous. With the SWP in the lead they can kick the Tories straight out. No elections, no nothing - OK!

As for a constructive discussion and debate about the realities and weaknesses of the strategy of mass non-payment alone, or concrete ideas about how to take the campaign to victory in the next year, not a lot was said.

Scan page 12

Organiser Tariq Ali's 'Redemption

----- pull-quotes -----

DO YOU WANT TO FROM BRUSSELS?

COMM ON League

WHETTONS WEEK

Why don't they adopt the legislation they've used against the trade union

mutant hero- turtle Tommy show EYE ON THE LEFT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 468

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →