Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Anatomy of the Irish left

Socialist Organiser no. 468, 30 November 1990 · scan p. 11 · about 974 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

In the run up to the Irish Presidential election a few weeks ago I watched and listened with very mixed feelings as a selection of youngish and young middle-aged Dublin intellectuals -journalists, book writers and the like -played talking heads to the cameras of the BBC's "Late Show'.

They were all reasonable and rational contemporary Europeans, all of them progressive and mildly left wing, all supporters of Mary Robinson, the independent left wing-backed candidate who eventually won the Presidency. But, as they talked about the Ireland they would like to see, they made me feel a gut hankering for the good old "Fianna Fail Nationalism" I grew up into.

There is not one left in Ireland, but two distinct and often antagonistic streams. The one represented by the President elect might be called the social-democratic left (in the modern sense of that label). Its representatives want change in Northern Ireland and many in the past have been concerned at the ill-treatment of Catholics there, but essentially they want to accept Northern Ireland and partition as given, fixed and permanent.

That is not what distinguishes them. All the southern parties accepted partition many decades ago and went on to build a Catholic state for the Catholic people of the south, grounded in Catholic moral and social doctrines. Even while they did this they built up a ferocious nationalistic ideology laying claim to the whole of Ireland, and weaving the fact of Northern Ireland's exclusion into the long story of Ireland's oppression by England, as the last unfinished episode. That was the official state ideology — "Fianna Fail nationalism"

The social-democratic left want to ditch all that ideology, but to change, not to accept the smaller Ireland ruled from Dublin.| They want to push back the power of the Catholic church, to prise its paws off people's minds and souls. They want to introduce such now-common European civil rights as divorce and abortion.

This is a very mild and tame left (our headline dubbing Mary Robinson a socialist was, suppose, a bit over-enthusiastic), detined by the aspiration to bring the 26 Counties into line with late twentieth century European bourgeois civilisation, and by the desire to put what Mary Robinson in her victory speech aptly described as "the faded flags of the Civil War" in a museum where they belong. (The two main political parties, Fianna Fail and Fine Gael, are the descendants of the two sides in the Civil War of 1922-23).

It plainly has working class support, but this is a middle class "liberal" left. In working-class anti-capitalist terms, it is not a left at all.

The two lefts: Top, Mary Robinson. Above: Martin McGuinness and Gerry Adams

IMMON EAGUE MARKE

The question of Britain and the EC may now fade, like Mrs Thatcher, into the background of shared anti-EC platforms with Tories. Michael Foot Yet this tepid left's attitudes and concerns are an irreplaceable part of the platform an Irish working class left needs to base itself on. They would be part of its minimum or democratic programme.

The other strand of the left does not share such ideas, or pushes them into the background until Ireland is united. This left is properly called the "populist left". And it is the revolutionary left in so far as such a thing has existed in Ireland.

t is a bankrupt left: the way the liberal left swept up the cities and the women's protest vote is the proof that it is bankrupt.

This second Irish left has at its core devotion to the traditional Catholic middle class chauvinist solution to the "national question" - the incorporation of the Protestants, against their will if necessary, and determination to achieve it instead of just talking about it.

Where it is not devoutly Catholic (and if you include the Gerry Adams wing of the Provos in it, it is heavily Catholic) it fears to disrupt "national unity" by offending Catholic sensibilities. While many of the Marxist-influenced individuals in the populist left are themselves for such basic civil rights as divorce and abortion, they subordinate those questions to nationalism. Thus, a few years back, when they won a majority at the depleted end of a Sinn Fein conference for "a woman's right to choose" abortion, they let themselves be persuaded the following year to have it rescinded in the interests of national unity: the national question first!

The core of it, though, is their commitment to, or moral selt-abasement in response to, the "armed struggle" as the way to wir the unitary state solution to the national question. Given the reality that one main obstacle to Irish unity is the compact, onemillion-strong Unionist bloc of Irish people in North East Ulster, this commitment warps and twists that left.

in the North, it is a communalist force: its most "left" wing (the IRSP spectrum) has even gone in for half-avowed sectarian killings of Protestants, not interested - despite occasional bits of lip-service to non-sectarian Wolfe Tone Republicanism — in reaching accommodation with the Protestant people of Ulster.

In the South it is a force concerned mainly with things outside the state. It accepts a community of nationalist identity with forces as tar to the right as Fianna Fail, the mair "state party" of the Irish bourgeoisie.

Yet this is the revolutionary left - the left which wins over those who want to overthrow the system, and appeals to the people who aren't quite so self-centred or so inclined to be "reasonable" and accommodating to the bourgeois world of capitalism, imperialism and wage slavery around them as the talking heads I saw on the "Late Show' are. It is the left which draws on and, I believe, frequently reduces to nonsense, the

----- pull-quotes -----

AGAINST THE TIDE

YOUR COUNTRY NEEDS YOUR SICN THE NATIONAL GOMMON MARKET PETITION MARK

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 468

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →