The case against PR
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Vladimir Derer Plan Johnson (Socialist Organiser 12.10.90) gives two reasons -both full of holes — for the swing of Labour Party opinion towards PR._ Firstly he uncritically accepts that "there is now a widespread recognition that the first past the post' system is grotesquely undemocratic". He claims that this is because the two major parties receive representation in parliament disproportionate to their popular vote and that minor parties receive derisory representation or none at all. According to Cde Johnson the "growing awareness" that there are better alternatives to the present British electoral system "other European countries do things differently" also contributed to PR's popularity, Secondly Cde Johnson attributes the swing to PR to Thatcher's ruthless exploitation of "the absence of checks to her parliamentary majofity" even though the Conservatives got no more than 42.2% of the popular vote.
The "ideological' arguments in favour of PR (about fairness etc) have been known to Labour Party members for decades. The constant moaning first of the Liberals, then of the SDP and now of the Liberal Democrats (by no means forgetting past lamentations of the CP) ensured this. It is difficult to believe that it was the cumulative effect of these that has at last awakened Labour's liberal conscience'. . The ruthlessness argument cuts both ways. If Thatcher was ruthless so could a Labour government be — if it had the guts. ] elsewhere — in the despair at Labour's he causes for the PR lobby's success lie seeming inability to end the continued rule of Thatcherism.
It is this which is loosening the ties which bind together the coalition that is the Labour Party. Some partners in this coalition are responding to Labour's present adversity by regressing to their original orientation. The experience of 6 years of a Labour government in the 1960s, followed by a relatively short spell of disastrous Conservative government, helped to unite the Party's industrial wing with Labour's rank and file and a large section of the Parliamentary Labour Party around a Left-wing programme. The prolonged rule of Thatcher had the opposite effect.
It has had a profound influence on the most important partner in the Labour Party coalition, namely the trade unions. Trade unions were created to defend the economic interests of particular sections of the working class. The nature of their organisation and ideology confines them to performing this task within the capitalist framework. Because of this when pursuing their interests in the political arena their inclination is to support the party whose ideology is a reformist one. Only once the limits of reformism become manifest can the labour movement's political wing effectively raise the question of a fundamental social transformation. The failure of socialists within the Labour Party to influence the policies of successive Labour governments have greatly strengthened those who seek to restrict the unions' role within the limits of the status quo. Labour electoral failures convinced many unions that they can no longer count on Labour getting elected. They have now concluded that PR might provide them with the opportunity to defend their members' interests through coalitions in which Labour will at least participate.
politicians who inhabit the Westminster periphery reason on similar ines, though for very different reasons.
Nevertheless most of | them are not Chartist demonstration 1848. The first mass political organisation of British workers had a comprehensive democratic programme: universal male suffrage, annual parliaments, secret ballots, payl. nt of MPs, equal electoral districts and the abolition of the property qualifications of MPs. ideologically opposed to major changes in social structure. They would have been happy to go along with a radical programme had socialists been able to maintain their influence in the Party and above all lead it to electoral victories. The involvement in leftwing politics and constitutional struggles of the seventies and early eighties of many a supporter of the present Party establishment proves this. However, with the prospects at the present of a Labour government uncertain, and of a socialist one indefinitely postponed, careers win out against socialist commitment. PR-based Lib-Lab coalitions seem to offer more promising pastures.
Another partner in the Labour Party coalition - the rank and file members - have been driven to PR by sheer despair. With the Left's failure to present a credible alternative to Kinnock, PR appears to many members as the only alternative to continued Conservative rule.
Finally, and far worse for socialism, is the reason behind the conversion to PR of some of the 'far Lefts'; it is not the desire to see Thatcher off, but because in PR they see an opportunity to set themselves up in competition with the Labour Party. Some 'far-Left' groups were attracted into the Labour Party during the constitutional struggles in the late seventies and early eighties. Then, it was obvious that the struggle for socialism is conducted within and not outside the Party. The Labour Left's defeat - to which the 'farLeft's' adventurist and populist leanings made their contribution - prevented the Party from becoming a convincing alternative to Thatcher. This helped the Conservatives to electoral success, produced demoralisation in the Labour camp and accounts for PR's sudden popularity.
One aspect of this demoralisation is the revival on the 'far-Left' of the fantasy that PR will enable it to bring the socialist torch into the darkness of bourgeois parliament. This fantasy provides a smokescreen for the "far-Left's' retreat into a 'radical' ghetto — its old habitat - where the ruling class is only too happy to tolerate it.
In all the above cases, however, advocacy of PR represents an accommodation to capitalism. The fact that here the abandonment of socialism is unconscious, hidden behind elaborate rationalisations, makes no difference.
PR's current vogue is only one of the many "popular' currents which characterise the present reactionary climate of opinion - just one of the panaceas that are being peddled as solutions to complex problems. It is part and parcel of the same trend which presents privatisation, freedom of choice, 'Europe' as the answer to the problems facing the contry, and OMOV, 'professional' use of the media, and new realism as the answer to the problems facing the Labour Party. Would the left be making a mistake to just pick out the present undemocratic electoral system as something to campaign against, leaving other, arguably even less democratic features of the British state untouched?
lan Johnson accuses Roy Hattersley "no party would ever achieve overall parliamentary majority". In fact it is the advocates of PR who are pessimistic (or worse).
According to Cde Johnson socialists must wait until they gain 50% support before they can set about changing society. Anything less would be "imposing socialism from above" If this were so, socialists would be waiting for ever. The highest popular vote Labour ever achieved was 48.8 per cent. This despite the fact that Labour never campaigned on a socialist programme and, at best, on a radical reformist one. Some European parties which fought elections on a socialist programme feared far worse. This is no accident. In our society there are a number of factors which prevent people from responding positively to the idea of radical social change. Their upbringing, education or lack of it, the mass media, conditions under which people have to work, all combine to produce this result.
Lenin was overoptimistic when he wrote that the support of hundreds of thousands can be won for socialism by propaganda. But he hastened to add that the support of millions would be needed if socialist changes are to be brought about. Such support, he argued, can be won only through the masses's own experience.
In fact rational arguments are likely to carry weight with relatively few. Nevertheless past experience shows that millions can be won for a radical reform programme. The election of a Labour government on such a programme is only the first step on the road to socialism. For once a radical Labour government starts implementing its programme, those who seek to preserve the status quo will resort to extra-parliamentary opposition -methods which will be unacceptable to the vast majority of the population. This alone would enable a legally elected government to mobilise the masses behind it and win the active support that, as Cde Johnson argues, is necessary for a socialist transformation.
But Cde Johnson puts the cart before the horse. That kind of support will never be produced by propaganda alone. Nor will it be produced by adopting an electoral system which requires a party to win the support of 50 per cent of the electorate before it is 'entitled' to form a government. Since the elecThis obscures the tion of a reforming Labour government is tion of a reforming Labour governn only a preliminary to winning mass si only a preliminary to winning mass support for socialist measures it should not be a 'mat- for socialist measures it should not be a ter of principle' whether such a gover ter of principle' whether such a government is elected under PR or first past th is elected under PR or first past the post system. The one difference is that system. The one difference is that on the available evidence PR would make this available evidence PR would maki preliminary step almost insurmountable.
Cde Johnson runs away from politics in the real world and takes sheiter in syndicalist fantasies eg " ...socialism..can only be created from below by the self-activity and creativity of millions of people...
It is not surprising therefore that given his disregard of politics Cde Johnson takes exception to Roy Hattersley's argument in favour of 'strong government' nor that he finds himself agreeing with Gavin Laird. To justify his position he falls back on the theory of the monolithic bourgeois state pointing out that it "is not an instrument which we can simply wield for our own very different purposes". He ignores the contradictions to which a bourgeois-democratic state can give rise under a two-party system when one of the parties represent the working class.
In this situation the bourgeois state can cease to be monolithic. Representative institutions of the state preserve the status quo only so long as they are dominated by bourgeois parties. Once a party committed to the working class gains a parliamentary majority this ceases to be the case. The machinery which ensures bourgeois rule is thrown into crisis.
This is much more likely under the first past the post system than under PR. First past the post favours the major parties not minor ones. It maintains a clear choice between two alternative governments, one for the status quo and one for social change. It brings together broadly compatible interests within a single party. Thus, it tends to line up the conflicting interests which are at the basis of class society into two opposing blocs. It also provides a constitutional basis for 'strong government' - horror of horrors - which the party of social change desperately needs if it is to implement its programme. Last, but as important, it provides the basis for accountability both of parties to the electorate, party leaderships to party members and MP's to their constituents.
PR on the other hand generates the proliferation of parties. This obscures the fundamental antagonism which underlines capitalist society. Voters do not elect governments of their choice but only numerous parties and must leave it to their leaders to decide the composition of governments. Consequently governments are not accountable to electors nor are party leaderships to party members once they participate in coalitions. Such governments often depend on tenuous compromises between parties, consequently the parties have to dilute their programmes. For this reason PR is the ideal system for upholding the status quo.
Of course electoral factors are not the sole factor determining the political complexion of a country. Political traditions and social structures also play an important part. An electoral system can either facilitate or hinder a party in advancing the interests of the class it represents. Their merits or demerits must not be judged be abstract criteria of "fairness' but by what effects they have on the realities of an unfair world.
In the final part of his article Alan Johnson touches on the acountability of MPs. Typically he only sees MPs in their nonpolitical role ie their social worker function. He does not even mention the accountability of MPs to their party, dramatically demonstrated in the recent Conservative leadership election. Yet when we are talking about introducing 'socialism from below' it is the local party which is the vital link between the voters' class interest and the party's representatives in parliament. It is the local party which can deselect MPs who do not stick to the programme on which they were elected. Under all PR systems, accountability doesn't exist.
Scan page 11
ganiser
----- pull-quotes -----
HE POLITICAL E POLITICAL FRONT FRONT Vladimir Derer
ome of Labour's parliamentarians and Sie more crew of pornia care
"PR generates proliferation of parties.
fundamental antagonism which underlines capitali: society"