W convinced? What
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Social structures out there, be they •conomic, political or ideological? That just really isn't easy.
Another problem is that these tifferent structures do work fairly lutonomously, so we can't just educe one from another, so I do It seemed by the end of the seventies aroblems of men themselves* ink that it's important to engage ith the psychology of men and omen, and in doing that look at hat the psychologists have said.
Well, the psychologists have -ent a hundred years doing frantic -search trying to find some funimental sex difference which at ice value looks like a biological sex fference.
At around the mid twentieth cenTy they thought they had found ological sex differences. These Ined out to be the minutest, _allest differences and they also med out to discriminate more thin a sex than between a sex, so the 1970s the massive amount of -x difference research the ychologists had done turned out suggest more the similarities beteen the sexes than the differences, id yet we live in this world where ere is the systematic gendering of erything.
We know of men and women no have the same types of romosomes and yet we experience irselves to be quite different.
Because of the commitment that ost of us have or perhaps because the conflict we have around ideny as men and women I felt that it as necessary to look at some of the ychoanalytic work and see nether that tells us something out the rigidities and patterns we e so clearly around gender identifind so interesting about some of the psychoanalytic work - which itself is complex and contradictory — is the idea of masculinity and feminity forming a part of all of us at birth.
It's only later on that girls and boys take on the polarised ditferences of masculinity and feminity — and we see a struggle going on whereby nobody is ever wholly masculine or feminine. Boys come to repress their earlier femininity and girls come to repress their earlier active (which equals masculine) desires for more passive and receptive ones. I think that's interesting in suggesting some of the tensions that surround sexual identity.
However, the whole of Freud relies on the privileging of masculinity and he connects that with the possession of the penis which has been re-interpreted more recently as a cultural symbol. The privilege of this organ culturally creates boys' great anxities about whether they're ever going to be proper men, or ever be man enough like their fathers and a girl's awareness that she will never be a man at all and so she can only hope for the man who will give her power and engage her.
And this is something that has caused enormous contention within and without feminism. What we think of this depends on what we think about where this privileging of masculinity comes from.
And what I think is absent from the psychoanalytic line is an adequate account of precisely why masculinity is so privileged. I think they could well be right, I think it is true to say that the penis as phallus becomes the symbol of masculinity and that therefore is something which is incredibly important.
It is obviously something which is experienced centrally for both men and women. But if you accept that it is a cultural image, you then have the problem of explaining what has created this cultural image. And that is where it seems to me we have to move over to more sociological and more structural and more historical cultural understandings of why it is that masculinity is given with and subvert if we are feminists or anti-sexist men, attempting to bring about greater equality or greater intimacy or greater happiness as men and women.
The problems of the psyche which the psychoanalysts talk about are problems of the psyche because of a reality which has been around for as long as we know whereby men are allocated privilege. That takes us back to looking at the organisations of labour where at work those at the top, in general, are men.
I wouldn't see this as a primary exactly. We have to look at the organisations of labour, the organisations of the family and also working alongside that with a certain autonomy of its own, the cultural habits of masculinity and femininity.
Those three things have a very long history and interact with each other and as one gets subverted -for instance women going into the labour force - still in all other ways, physically and culturally, men are at the centre.
We can't just say in the end it's about class, in the end it's about the organisation of labour.
Most popular or populist feminism now is stressing that the central problem is men. However, I don't find that most women do that. The current most commercially popular feminist project has got separated off from women's strug gles on the ground. I moot he the go out ise bet i most criticised about is what I say about the supposed inevitable connection of men and violence. That doesn't necessarily understand the problem of violence, and it isn't necessarily in women's interests to deny that women can be violent. Especially if you look at the high levels of depression in women which is due to women suppressing their own Also in relation to domestic violence there are cases in the beginning where women have initiated violence as much as men. The problem is that though women may have initiated violence they are the against other men and against themselves.
here is now a lack of an organised women's movement, but on the other hand feminists are there, and also diverse feminist campaigns are still very much around.
So I think that the effects of the women's movement are still alive and well and in some ways, although they have diversified and some strands of feminism seem to be very much at odds with the views of the other strands of feminism, the issue of gender relations is very At first it seemed it was simply going to strengthen the moral right (and it did do). But the way to fight AIDS is for men and women to talk as much as they can about what they see as healthy and unhealthy, good and bad about sexuality, which again gives women more of a voice.
Although so far the campaigns around AIDS have been phallocentric about condoms, there is more chance for women to say what they think about sexuality, about penetrative sex and what they want.
So women's struggles are going continue.
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser No. 468 page 10
----- pull-quotes -----
that everything was being reduced to the