Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[The debate on Palestine, Zionism and anti-semitism (including…]

Socialist Organiser no. 468, 30 November 1990 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 796 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

The debate on Palestine, Zionism and anti-semitism (including "Trotsky and Zionism' A Workers' Liberty pamphlet The women's movement is fragmented plus 22 pence p&p to PO Box 823, 1 SE15 4NA pre-feminist, ie. sex-war thinking about men and women.

So it seemed essential to me — as a socialist-feminist — to attempt to keep alive those hopes around sexual politics, that men and women could work together, although not easily and no doubt in conflict, toward some better future for men and women.

And the problem was being defined as men. Whereas in the early days of women's liberation we tended to see inequalities and oppression as coming from many different structural roots - from the organisation of the family, from the organisation of the workplace, and mediated by the state and social policy, these were looked at as well as the problems of men themselves. It seemed by the end of the '70s everything was being reduced to the problems of men themselves. → say, shirting social policy and omehow the old goals towards, these types of campaigns, were losing ground partly because the welfare state was being rolled back. So those issues were not being so much focused on.

There was the idea that men were never going to change, no matter what advances women achieved. We come back to this inevitable problem.

So that's why I wanted to ask, once gain, is it the case that there is

Scan page 9

al optimist problem some essence, some biological essence, of masculinity that inevitably oppresses women or is it that there can be some world historic construction of men from the beginning of time that will always oppress women or is it that we are not only dealing simply with the psychologies and nature of men but with something more complex and in that very complexity hard to shift.

After all, when you get change in one area then you get a consolidation of relations in other areas and that is what I thought.

I tried to look at all levels of masculinity. Interestingly, feminists haven't written a lot about men -not only feminists but no-one had written about men because it was always women who were seen as the problem.

In problematising men, and taking it seriously, this suggested there was not going to be a simplistic inswer.

This is the problem. How do we connect out our psychologies as nen and women and the understanJings we do have of what it means o be men and women with the Lynne a higher priority. And it's those structures that we have to engage ones in general who suffer most. Unfortunately, men are more trained into the use of physical violence.

So we can't just have a vacuous analysis of that; we have to look at ways in which types of physical aggressiveness becomes embodied in men in a way in which it doesn't become embodied in women.

And on the other hand, there isn't something naturally inevitable about rape and violence. It's not for instance that rape or levels of rape - which are for now highest particularly in North America - are universal across time and place.

And there are different explanations. There is the straightforward feminist explanation that men are socialised into ideas of masculinity to connect masculinities up with the performance of authority and power and aggressive sexuality and that somehow both men and women were socialised with the idea of man as the active and woman as the passive.

But there is the idea that violence has become so much a part of subcultures of disorganised communities in which you see men most likely to use violence against women but also much in the air.

It's not the case that though women are systematically disadvantaged and also that they are victims of male violence these things are all off the agenda. That for me suggests that struggles will continue to go on. So I'm not pessimistic. Women are strong and have become stronger over the last few decades.

The changes in the economy have actually sharpened the differences both between men and between women - some women are much better off than others. That's happened in a way that undermines the attempt to think of fundamental change in gender relations.

I don't think either the abandonment of women's committees all over the country or the bureaucratic enrolment of women by trade unions will silence women's voices or women's struggles because women are still nevertheless at the bottom of the labour movement and are organising together.

Also, I think there are other ways in which sexuality and sexual politics are very much on the agenda, because of AIDS for instance.

----- pull-quotes -----

RCH ant not

Pales tine: the great debate

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 468

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →