Costs and consequences of unification
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Thomas Kupfer of the Left in Halle talked to The main themes in the elections are different in the West and East of Germany. In the West, the issue which has emerged as the principal one is the burden of reunification, the costs of reunification for the citizens of the old German Federal Lafontaine [the SPD candidate for Chancellor] is trying to score points on this issue, by criticising and attacking the financial policies of the government, but I don't think he will achieve anything in doing so.
In the former German Democratic Republic it is different. What people here are thinking about and interested in are the social consequences of reunification. None of the promises which were made in March or later on on the occasion of the monetary unification have been implemented by the government.
The promised economic miracle has been postponed again and again. The situation here is clearly not attractive for investments. Unemployment will therefore increase, and could reach three millions by next year, plus also those not counted officially as unemployed, such as those on "short-time working: zero" as is already the case.
Is Paragraph 218 an issue? (Paragraph 218 in the West German constitution restricts women's right to abortion, whereas the former GDR allowed women greater access to aborțion./ In my opinion this is not an issue for many people at the moment, given the decision that different laws will prevail for the next two years in different parts of Germany (Paragraph 218 in the West, the old East German legislation in the East).
Of course, once the two years are up, when people are not as conscious of the issue as at present, then the attempt will be made to extend Paragraph 218 to East Germany. But it is not an issue in the elections, partly because some of the less consistent sections of the women's movement have accepted this "solution"
Other issues which are not being taken up in the elections include, unfortunately, the Gulf crisis, the export of armaments, and German foreign policy in general, including proposals for constitutional changes to allow German military forces to take action abroad. On the latter point the SPD [German equivalent of the Labour Party] will knuckle under again.
There are other causes as well which should be taken up, such as land reform in East Germany. But we are too weak to make them an issue in the elections.
Is immigration an issue in the Yes, for example the question of Soviet Jewry, or immigration by gypsies and Romanians which had already been effectively banned by the old East German government. Lafontaine has had a high profile in East Germany, putting forward conservative proposals regarding the right of asylum.
For the left, the situation in relation to this issue is very unfavourable. In situations of social crisis, such as you now have in the former GDR, there is a great temptation to blame foreigners and people who have asylum for the nonappearance of the promised prosperity.
What is the attitude of the United Left to the elections?
We have had a lot of discussions about the elections. There has been a lot of controversy. A number of people have resigned.
The problem is that we have very few people who thoroughly studied the issues, and those people who have done so have not had the time for work at rank-and-file level. Thus, the gap between work at parliamentary level and work at rank-and-file level became bigger and bigger, the gap between Berlin (where the former was necessarily concentrated) and other places became bigger and bigger.
I would say that there are at least three different positions in the United Left. There are those in favour of participation in the elecpiricipand to see hotter covers both a radical anti-parliamentarian wing and also more moderate opponents of participation.
The former covers both those who support the PDS/Left List [see below], not so much because they want to work with the PDS, though this is a factor, but rather because they want to work with the West German left involved in the Left List, and those who support citizens initiatives such as the Greens.
Apart from the PDS [the former East German Communist Partyl, what political organisations are involved in the PDS/Left List electoral coalition?
The Left List was originally a collection of individuals, for a combination of reasons, for example to avoid introducing the arguments between the different left wing organisations into the project. But as a result of judicial decisions concerning the conduct of the elections, the PDS ended up putting up candidates in both Eastern and Western Germany.
Individuals are involved from different organisations, and also people who are not in any organisation. The spectrum stretches from left social-democracy to long-standing left wing organisations such as the United Socialist Party and the Communist League, as well as some smaller Marxist organisations, and also left wing trade unionists and people from the Greens.
What about Workers Power and the Socialist Workers Group /West German SWPI?
As far as I'm aware, Workers Power supports the PDS/Left List, but, of course, critically, but it is too small to have any real presence. The SWG, in my opinion, has a pretty stupid approach to this question. They do not support the PDS/Left List, but have called for support for the SPD, on the basis that the elections are not particularly important, but if there is anything worthwhile to be achieved in the elections, then it is getting rid of Kohl [the current right-wing Chancellor].
What is the political programme of the PDS/Left List?
The programme must be analysed on several levels.
Firstly, there is the programme itself, as it exists on paper. That is not a radical left wing programme, but rather a left social democratic one which raises issues such as ecology, women, and particularly the interests of the inhabitants of Alliance 90 did not win any seats in Parliament, given that the better people in these organisations would then be forced to be active in the extra-parliamentary sphere. I think that the history of the Volkskammer [short-lived East German parliament] has shown that in many spheres more can be achieved outside of parliament than within it by trying to influence decisions when you are in a minority anyway. You can try and publicise your ideas through parliament, but you cannot influence the decisions.
You only need to think of the story of the Stasi [former East German secret police] when nothing at all happened in the Volkskammer until some people occupied the Stasi headquarters in Berlin and thereby, whatever the limitations of the eventual outcome, achieved more than would have been achieved by however many speeches in the Volkskammer.
That is quite a good example of how things will carry on. One thing is for sure. The politics of the street, and the people who were involved in such politics in the former GDR, have hitherto been treated with kid gloves. But that will change. Engineering workers the West
Scan page 8
Lynne Segal argues that men are not the only The Socialist Answer With contributions from Sion Fein, Tony Ben, Geoff Bell, Stan Led. 4l.
Ireland: beyond slogans E1 plus 22 pence p&p PROBLEMS STRUGGLES by Socialist Organiser and Workers" Liberty El A handbook for trade unionists A handbook for E1 plus 21.00 an! al Cathy Nugent talked to Lynne Segal about her most recent book 'Slow Motion: Changing Men, Changing Masculinities*, and about her general views on the state of feminism and women's struggles low Motion: Changing ties' is very much a continuation of those themes I was presenting in 'Is the Future Female?'.
There I was taking issue with certain popular strands of feminism, usually known as cultural feminism, in which it seemed to me that the voice of feminism as it was popularly seen was almost declaring some essential difference between men and women.
In the early days of women's liberation, the stress on an essential difference was something that feminists had their campaign against. Not that they thought men and women were the same, but that they saw masculinity and femininity as socially constructed and that both men and women could be changed by women's liberation. So there was an optimistic spirit in the early women's liberation writing.
By the end of the 70s, and for reasons that are understandable — because of growing awareness of the reality of men's violence, because change is so slow and contradictory, and because feminists became demoralised about the advances of feminism and also perhaps demoralised about the lack of radical changes in their personal lives -this all seemed to fit together with a more pessimistic outlook about there being something that's seemingly ineluctable about women's oppression, and moved back toward something
----- pull-quotes -----
"It's clear that Kohl will win"
Suthen Nachhilelehres tum Eheli nache WErK 12504 -verk
Arabs, Jews TE