Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Goodbye ballot-rigging, hello shenanigans

Socialist Organiser no. 467, 23 November 1990 · scan pp. 15–16 · about 529 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

Outright ballot-rigging has been British trade union movement since the EETU scandal of 1960.

That is not to say that it has never taken place over the last 30 years - the old TGWU "tradition" "block voting" amounted to ballot-rigging, for instance. But blatant fiddling on the scale that went on in the EETPU in the *50s is very much a thing of the past and though it sticks in the throat to have to admit it, the Tory legislation enforcing postal ballots now makes ballot-rigging virtually impossible.

The recent attempt to fiddle the TGWU NEC ballot was so crude and obvious that it is not excessively conspiratorial to suspect that the fiddle was meant to be discovered.

Ballot-rigging may be (more or less) a thing of the past, but the mentality that gave rise to it is not. The trade union movement is still rife with practices that may not actually be fraudulent, but are

NSIDE

THE UNIONIS By Sleeper certainly undemocratic and demonstrate complete contempt for the membership. These practices are often referred to as "shenanigans" , a word that is not defined in my dictionary, but recent events in the CPSA may help illustrate what it means. possibility of merging with the other main civil service union, NUCPS, for some time. The issue has split both left and right within the CPSA but on the whole the 'hard left' has opposed the merger. Supporters of the Socialist Caucus (including Socialist Organiser supporters) have been at the forefront of the anti-merger campaign.

The result of the merger ballot is known to be a small (but clear) majority of CPSA members in favour. But, astonishingly, the result has not been officially announced. This is because supporters of Militant on the union's national executive have lined up with the anti-merger right (notably the union president, Marion Chambers) in demanding an "investigaton" into the ballot. Their excuse for doing this is some purely administrative irregularities of the type that are almost inevitable in any ballot. No-one is suggesting ballot-rigging or anything concerning the democracy of the ballot.

What is going on here is and the anti-merger right don't like the result, so they are suppressing it and hoping to get a re-run that might give a different result. Anyone who doubts this should ask themselves: can you imagine Militant demanding a re-run of a ballot that went in their favour, whatever the "irregularities" that may have come to light?

The truth is that the CPSA membership voted for merger and their wishes should be sacrosanct, however much that upsets Marion Chambers, Militant, and, come to that, SO.

Shenanigans like this eventually lead to a quite justified cynicism amongst the rank and file and open the door to anti-union legislation which comes to be seen as at least having the virtue of curbing the trickery of the officials.

The behaviour of Militant in the CPSA is not blatantly fraudulent and it would be grotesque to suggest that it is the same thing as the behaviour of the Stalinists in the EETPU...but the same mentality is at work here. It's time to put a stop to these shenanigans.

Scan page 16

SOCIALIST

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 467

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →