Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The cop as hero

Socialist Organiser no. 467, 23 November 1990 · scan pp. 12–13 · Clive Bradley · about 1,738 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Miami police crackdown on rioters. McBain does not romanticise these cops Mass sale popular fiction helps shape and colour the way millio people see and interpret the capitalist world they live in. Detective and police fiction deal society at its ragged edges. It portrays the "grab what you can the social norms and laws through which capitalism regulates itself. In the second of her occasional series, BJ Siddon discusses the work of Ed McBain, king of the "Police Procedural*.

-known for d McBain is probably most well This 87th Precinct stories.

These are tales in the 'police procedural' genre - a sort of Hill St Blues in paper covers.

Mc Bain also writes more traditional detective novels with a Florida lawyer — Matthew Hope - as protagonist. If that wasn't enough, McBain has written a number of "straight' novels under his real name of Evan Hunter. "The Blackboard Jungle', which has been filmed, is the most widely known of these.

Like Agatha Christie, McBain writes prolifically and on different themes. Unlike her, he writes consistently. Any review of Agatha Christie's work would tend to gloss over the ridiculous exploits of 'Penny and Tuppence' - the same reviewer could confidently discuss all of McBain's work, from short stories to serious novels.

For a newcomer to crime fiction, the Matthew Hope books are the most accessible. Hope is a reasonably successful lawyer, with a failed marriage and an interest in crime. He does a fair bit of dashing about, and his cases usually have an acquaintance with glamour - they are set in Florida after all.

But Hope is not Perry Mason. He does make mistakes, and he usually thinks he'll lose! Mason is a professional detective/ lawyer, whereas Matthew Hope is a professional conveyancer.

All the books benefit from Hope's dry humour. Florida weather, for instance, is not all it's cracked up to be:

...only an iguana would find Calusa habitable in the summer months..." ('Jack and the Beanstalk' , 1984)*It began raining again the moment | started the long drive back to Calusa — a big surprise here during the summer months, our daily reminder that there was indeed a God." (ibid).

The 87th Precinct stories share the weather obsession, without the humour. For the detectives of the 87th hot weather means a crime wave, cold weather means freezing stakeouts.

"There were times when he did not necessarily enjoy police work (like night now, freezing his arse off in an alley)." ('Fuzz', 1968).

The weather, like the poor, is always with us in Ed McBain's books.

Poverty, foul, disgusting, urban poverty is more evident in the fictional Isola' (the city of the 87th) than in Florida. The urban poverty is sophisticated — women becoming whores, kids on smack, gang fights, slums and ghettos.

In Florida, poverty American poverty of bad crops, bad weather and farm labourers men and worn out at 30.

McBain doesn't avoid showing the downside of the American dream. The 87th precinct stories would not survive without it. The precinct is not the city's worst, but it isn't nice either, and often the detectives are called to other parts of the city which are really bad. The descriptions of burned out tenements, stretching for block after block, where a white man is either a policeman or a dead man is terrifying.

Isola is based on various Us cities, but Chicago and New York seem the closest models.

I don't much care for paragraphs beginning "The city is like a woman... " which are regrettably common in McBain's work. But away from the generalisations McBain's descriptions can be chilling. "You could always tell a neighbourhood of poor people in this city because the streets were always the last to be plowed and sanded, and the garbage, especially in bad weather, was allowed to pile up indefinitely, presumably as an inducement to free enterprise among the rat population." ('Ice', 1983).

McBain avoid divisions in American society. The slums are nearly always black or hispanic areas, and this is pointed out. But a black slum-dweller is not necessarily a criminal or a failure.

McBain is at pains to distance himself from the racism of both cops and citizens. By contrast, ethnicity is shown positively, even where it leads to prejudice. This is a part of people's lives and McBain's books deal with the whole person, not the stereotype:

.. another Jack, common name. Except in my family. In my family the common names are Sidney, Bernie, Marvin, Irving and Abe." ('Jack and the Beanstalk', 1985).

A number of McBain's detectives are black, and Italians and Jews are also well represented. There are fewer hispanics, and those there are are treated less empathetically. If any of the books falls into stereotyping, it is that drug dealers are almost always Bolivians, Cubans or other native Spanish speakers.

In fairness to McBain, his books make a genuine effort to expose racism, antisemitism and prejudice - including anti-gay prejudice — so what he portrays is probably a fair picture of American society taced by a large ethnic group determined not to integrate and lose their language.

McBain makes few moral distinctions between good and bad guys. By the nature of the books, the good guys are the law in one form or another. But there are good and bad cops, and McBain distinguishes between them, not by his own comments but by the characters own self-image, or by colleagues' views.

"Carella thought Parker was a lazy cop and a bad cop and the kind of cop who gave other cops a bad name. Parker thought Carella was an eager cop and a goody twoshoes cop and the kind of cop who gave other cops a bad name." ("Bread", 1974).

*[Ollie Weeks] knew Carella from a case they had worked jointly some five years back, at which time Carella had called Ollie on his peculiar idiosyncracy of referring to an 86-year old Puerto Rican matriarch, grandmother to 12 children, and proud parent of a son who was then running for the city council as 'that decrepit spic twat' . Ollie had taken offence at Carella's having taken offence, and the working relationship had been somewhat strained from that moment on." (ibid).

The same applies to the bad guys. McBain exposes rather than judges.

"Cindarella' is the story of a cocaine theft, and the search for the woman who has stolen it. Two of the searchers are Cuban gangsters who, in an opening scene, murder a girl for the simple reason that she doesn't provide an address quickly enough.

Later on in the book, the same gangsters are shown worrying about how to pacify their boss if they fail in their mission. These are human beings - different from most of us. but with the same hopes and fears.

That book ends with the death of the two gangsters and the arrest of the woman who stole the cocaine, and her accomplice.

"Dump the dope and the money in the Ford and off we go into the wild blue yonder, riding high...

"But it never works out the way you think it will.

"You sit instead in a 6 x 8 cubicle with bars as thick as your cock, and on the wall, prisoners past have written stupid little sayings and there's a toilet you can sit on with everyone looking through the bars at you, and it never works out the way you think it *And she thought — as he locked the door behind him — they always let me in the ballroom but they never let me dance.

Those two criminals were just taking a chance to get out from under. Other McBain villains are of the "he made me do it" school. My feeling is that these people are the true-to-life criminals, and their stories are very convincing.

"He tried to rush me, and I had to shoot him. Same thing as Jack, if you see what I mean. All I wanted was the money, they shouldn't have tried nothing." ('Jack and the Beanstalk').

*[I] stabbed her without saying a word to her. I didn't want to but...she knew my name you see." ('Shotgun" , 1968).

Or the couple in *80 Millions Eyes' (1966) who were in love, so they 'had to" kill her husband. The criminals whose fault it never is are far more believable than the Agatha Christie murderer who is simply "evil' or From the quotations 1 have used it would appear that Ed McBain's books are non-stop violence, misery and racial and class harmony. In a way they are — they show a side of life, particularly in big American cities, which most British people have no experience of.

But McBain also shows us that everything is relative:

*If you told a slum-dweller on Chicago's West Side that you were going to move him into New Town and you described it as a cluster of two-storey stuccoed buildings surrounding a grassy compound planted with sabal palms, he'd have thought you were inviting him to a paradise on earth. When he got here, though, he might look around and discover for himself how other people were living..." ('Jack and the Beanstalk').

McBain doesn't use the sick society we live in as an excuse for the way some inhabitants behave. Nor does he romanticise his cops — even the good ones. The books are nasty, almore coard. They area astor pari of the world we live in, and they don't make very comfortable bedtime reading. Despite (or because of?) the subject matter, the books lare entertaining, and have few jarring notes.

Scan page 13

Clive Bradley reviews 'Haroun and the Sea of Stories' by Salman Rushdie. Granta, £12.99 aroun al-Rashid was legendary Caliph of Baghdad to whom Sheherezade told her thousand and one stories to avoid execution. Haroun and Rashid are the son and his father at the centre of Salman Rushdie's latter-day Arabian Nights.

Rashid al-Khalifa, a master story teller known by his friends as the Ocean of Notions and by his enemies as the Shah of Blah, lives with his wife and son, Haroun, in the land of Alifbey, in a city so sad it has forgotten its name. An election approaches, and the Demi Moore and Patrick Swayz a storybook couple" Organiser

----- pull-quotes -----

Down these mean streets

however you can" ethos of capitalism when is has overthrown

A defiant sto from Salman Rushdie Books

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 467

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →