Never imitate the enemies' slogans
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
We must never play with slogans that are not revolutionary by their own content but that can play quite a different role according to their political conjuncture, relationship of forces, etc..." (Leon Trotsky: 'On the Theses "Unity and Youth"', Writings 1934-5)
"The will of the 'Nation' or of its majority. is not a sort of God for Social Democracy. before which it humbly prostrates itself; ol the contrary, Social Democracy's whole Sig0SQ historic mission depends above all on revolutionising, on forming, the will of the 'nation' - that is, its working majority." (Rosa Luxemburg, 1908) "The method of ideological imitation of the opponent and of the class enemy - a method which is thoroughly contradictory to the theory and the psychology of Bolshevism - flows quite organically from the essence of centrism, from its unprincipledness, inconsistency, ideological hollowness...(in the Comintern) we see one and the same spirit of mimicry, constant imitation of the opponent, a striving not to use their own weapons - which, alas! the! do not possess - but weapons stolen from the arsenal of the enemy." (Leon Trotsky: 'Against National Communism" August 1931. From The Struggle Against Fascism in Germany') Common Market, not capitalism, for the problems of workers, was the message, nothing else.
The "No" was reactionary, and not really linked to the Socialist United States of Europe at all. The revolutionary left was like a little boy in front of a large orchestra playing "Rule Britannia". He positioned himself and his tin whistle with the thought: if only I play the first few notes of "Rule Britannia", They'll all hear me and listen as I drown out the orchestra...
Of course socialists should have made propaganda for the Socialist United States of Europe. But its logical starting point was "In or put the fight goes on: neither little Britain, nor EFTA, nor Commonwealth, nor EC, but the Socialist United States of Europe - and, immediately, Europe-wide workers' unity as the response to Europe-wide capitalist integration". Indeed, if the left was to let itself be forced to say yes or no to the EC, then the And on the EC a wrong answer could be — and for the British labour movement was -utterly disorienting.
The Common Market debates were a major battle in the class struggle — a battle on the ideological front for that most precious of all working-class values, socialist internationalism. Not only the broad labour movement, left and right, pro or anti the EC, have been on the anti-working-class side of that ideological class struggle: most of the revolutionary Marxists, too, have fought against the working-class interest.
Those of us who swam against the tide for so long on this question now see our principles and our approach to politics vindicated. Sometimes'it°seets. otherWised that principled socialist politics leads only to isolation and "sectarianism", . The long dispute on the left over the EC proves that Marxist politics does count for something. And what is now proven about the EC is also true about our polities in general.
Scan page 11
SOCIETY