The sad story of the left and Europe part 2
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Our answer to the bosses' international unity, the The founding of the Communist international unity of the revolutionary workers. International 1919 Sean Matgamna SO has always rejected the identi-kit 'left' posi tion on the EC and must have seemed to many to be perverse on the issue. Last week I showed, with quotations, that the entire far left started with the same policies as SO and changed under pressure of the nationalists and chauvinists. TEC after those fosit chan wed a ken he only thing that changed in the was that European economic integration continued and intensified, and Britain's non-membership became more untenable.
The CP and the nationalist left both reflected working-class gut nationalism, and rationalised, justified, and reinforced it. Instead of fighting nationalism and chauvinism, they inserted their own nationalist slogans into the working-class struggle that developed against the Wilson Labour government in the mid-'60s.
In 1967, when Harold Wilson decided to try to get Britain into the EC, it was denounced as one strand of a comprehensive "betrayal" • Political confusion on the part of some Trotskyists led them to take up the cry. Calls on Labour to "take power with socialist policies" had been central to the Healy group (SLL) for a long time. Labour wasn't building socialism, but linking up with European capitalism. Cries of treason on this issue merged naturally with the surrounding chorus of the CP and CP-influenced left.
Thus the SLL, then by far the strongest far left group, had the doubtful honour of leading what was to become a gadarene stampede towards the anti-European camp.
The SWP (then called IS) did not change until 1971, when the British ruling class made their last, successful, push to get into Europe. There was a tremendous upsurge against the Heath government and its anti-union laws. At the IS conference at Easter 1971, an attempt to put the organisation in May 1970. Mass protests against the Vietnam war at campuses across the US are met with brutal repression. Four students are murdered at the hitherto non-political ine with the anti-EC mood was heavily defeated. Soon after the leaders of the group decided to change the line.
Bandwagon-jumping is an undignified business, and the IS leaders scarcely tried to disguise their rush and panic. At first they proposed that IS should go on saying "In or out, the fight goes on!", but nevertheless, if its own propositions were defeated, vote with the left in trade union branches and so on. Within weeks they were pushing opposition to EC entry as their line. By the time of the 1975 referendum on the EC, the weekly Socialist Worker had worked itself into a Kent State University Ohio, another two students are murdered at Jackson State University, Mississipi. Despite the hostility of the forces of 'law and order' the mass frenzy of anti-Marketeering in which every problem, battle, ruling-class imposition and working-class interest was meshed into a single focus — getting a "no" vote in the referendum.
In 1971, the undemocratic switch of line on the EC created a major crisis in the then still democratic IS organisation. The crisis triggered the transformation of the group into one more single-faction "revolutionary party", and the expulsion of the Workers' Fight group and, soon after, the expulsion of what became the RCP and RCG.
Militant and the IMG (forerunner of today's Socialist Outlook and Socialist Action) followed more quietly, and it was thus that the "line" on the EC, the far-left orthodoxy for over 20 years, was put in place. changed line were among he arguments for the far left's the worst aspects of it.
*No to the Common Market, Yes to the Socialist United States of Europe" was, they argued, a principled position, an explicit rejection of little Englandism.
Abstractly — yes. Really — no. The argument was a scandalous sophism. The revolutionary left did not conduct its own campaign in a pure and rarefied atmosphere where good intentions and private reservations counted. It attempted to insert its own slogans into an existing chauvinist campaign. "No to the Common Market" was the leading, audible slogan, and the rest was lost in the hubbub. Nonsensical blaming of the movement against the war CO Itinu grow. It played a major pa rt i i for US out of Vietnam.
answer could "his debacle was a major factor in the shan ot retonary left as it exists today.
Irrationality and incoherence is not easily confined to one issue. It spreads. The approach of buckling under pressure and talking out of both sides of your mouth at once - that is a bad education.
It played a big part in the degeneration of the IS/SWP to the level of general incoherence which its founders rightly used to point to as one of the proofs that "orthodox Trotskyism" had lost its way. The IS/SWP's various positions on the Gulf, on the Iran/Iraq war — or on the poll tax, or its insistence that the Labour and trade union leaders could easily get the Tories out "without waiting for an election" if only they tried - all those rely on the same method.
Was it sectarian to stand apart from a powerful movement? No. Opposing the antiEC crusade did not set us apart from either the industrial struggles of the working class or the struggle in the Labour Party. Socialist Organiser - and Workers' Action - stood apart from those struggles a lot less than most of the anti-European far left.
Marxists — though we are politicians, and should sometimes "trim" and duck weave on secondary issues — are first of all fighters for ideas, bearers of a programme and an outlook on the world. We do not "trim" where basic questions are involved.
----- pull-quotes -----
AGAINISI THE TIDE
VIVE LA MIES JNTEFNATICO DECLIVE THE IRd INTERNA