Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Miners' overtime ban Why we

Socialist Organiser no. 467, 23 November 1990 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,010 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Scots and Welsh leaders are to blame for defeat foods except bread are rationed. And even if you have ration soupons there's nothing in the thops. Prices are going up between 500 percent and 400 percent. Those are still fixed state prices, so ou can imagine what would hap-en if they left it to market forces. Black market prices had gone up by Tactor of thieep coar Dorippe by septemberpand now it's even more. hen we started studying living tandards in Confederation, we bund that more than half the opulation was below the poverty line.

There's a problem of control of production and distribution.

At the beginning of the year we had 8,000 unemployed, and by the end of the year it'll be 100,000. And still the economic programme has not been enacted, so think what will come after that!

Earlier this year the government moved to liberalise Certain sectors. The result was that the people in power began to buy the enterprises. That's privatisation which we don't want. There was a law in parliament to stop it.

The trade unions have made demands on what should go together with privatisation. We have insisted that the workers should be consulted, that time should be left for workers to make their decision, that workers should be able to participate in the ownership of epterprisess avia 0S. 13 ES8 xoS And we've raised the problem that there is no money for social security - not even for the numbers who are unemployed now. Dave Cliff, Hem Heatl NUM raises some important issues T NUM ballot sor an "he surprise result of overtime ban was a surprise only in that 43% of miners voted in favour.

All the national press without exception gave dire warnings of the consequences of miners voting for industrial action. On top of this British Coal launched a propaganda blitz. Notices all over the pits screamed "Put your families first" '. The same message was pushed into each individual's locker.

What did the NUM do to counteract this overwhelming publicity blitz? Not very much, is the sad fact. A single sheet issue of The Miner, largely dominated by pie charts showing overtime up and bonuses down and a few leaflets giving scant details. Nowhere did I see any clear explanation of what the NUM wage claim consisted of, even less of why British Coal refused to negotiate and the meanings of the conciliation agreement.

British Coal have threatened, bullied and blackmailed miners for five years now. In this latest ballot they perfected these arts, threatening further pit closures, using the prospect of losing up to £10,000 in redundancy payments, and using the UDM to bully their way into forcing what is in effect the fifth annual reduction in miners' pay.

Certain areas, South Wales and Scotland, campaigned against a yes vote, although they should have obeyed their mandate from the national delegate conference. South Wales leaders are now mooting the idea of a breakaway from the national union. The politics being operated in the South Wales area at the moment appear to deny all sense of collective f the Scottish and Welsh area leaderships had campaigned for a yes vote then I'm confident we would have won this ballot," Castlebridge miner Phil Cowan told SO.

But they didn't, and now the Scottish leadership are pushing for the removal of NUM President Arthur Scargill and General Secretary Peter Heathfield.

At the same time they want the NUM to accept British Coal's existing negotiating machinery which would mean that in pits where the NUM is the minority, NUM members would be represented by the UDM. & This Phil Cowan put it:

is selling out NUM members in places where the responsibility.

There are also good reasons why the NUM need to adopt slightly more sophisticated tactics than banning overtime. The ban that would have been effected if the vote had succeeded would have been one that gave British Coal safety cover. The last time such a ban was operated everybody and his dog worked overtime giving safety reasons as the excuse.

To operate an overtime ban without safety cover also has massive drawbacks. The shafts are not inspected for work to commence on Monday mornings, the result of this being many miners losing at least one shift a week. Incentive payments fall to almost nothing during such bans, the result being a huge reduction in earnings even for those men who never work overtime.

As anyone who has been in such a situation knows only too well, you are better off on strike, nobody expects to get paid then, while if you are still earning everyone wants paying. Perhaps it's time the NUM learnt a few lessons from the railway, with their days of action and area strikes of short duration.

The lack of campaigning, the shortsighted adoption of an overtime ban as the NUM's only tactic, combined with the splits in the NUM ranks, and the existence of the UDM, all added up to making a no vote almost a foregone conclusion. It's no use carping on about the tactics used by British Coal; they've been using them for five years now, and the NUM have totally failed to adopt any new strategy to oppose them.

UDM are the majority."

Activists in the NUM will not be surprised by the outcome of the ballot. British Coal pulled out all the stops to frighten miners off action: *They threatened to cut redundancy pay offs and half the direct debit of union dues," explained Phil, who went on to point out that his own Scottish area leadership "are quoting Sir Robert Haslam and Kevin Hart when they should have been putting over the union's case."

Despite the setback, Phil remained optimistic: "We've got to get the left together across the union. We need to rebuild confidence. We've got to convince rank and file miners that with increased productivity, falling coal stocks, industrial action in the North Sea oil industry, and the Gulf crisis, miners are in a strong position."

Scan page 10

aniser

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 467

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →