Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A bureaucrat and proud of it

Socialist Organiser no. 466, 16 November 1990 · scan p. 15 · about 429 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

Like me, you have probably met people claiming to be left-wingers who reckon that us "Trots' go on too much about union 'bureaucrats*.

The more sophisticated of such people will argue that the concept is sociological and not political; that it substitutes personalised villification for a political critique; that it draws an artificial line of divide between the "bureaucracy' and the "rank and file' that fails to take crucial questions like ideology into account.

Very often, the people you hear these kinds of arguments from, have a fairly obvious axe to grind: they are bureaucrats -(or would-be bureaucrats) themselves. Sometimes they are honest socialists who had the misfortune to receive their political education at the hands of the IMG.

Anyway next time you hear such arguments being used, whip out a well-thumbed copy of "All Against the Collar" by Clive Jenkins (Methuen, £14.99). Brother Clive, you may remember, By Sleeper was the ebullient Cieneral Secretary of ASTMS until, having merged his union with Ken Gill's TASS a couple of years ago, he took off to devote his energies to the Tasmanian rain forests or something like that.

The great thing about Jenkins is that he has no shame. While still General Secretary of ASTMS he bought a luxury cruiser, moved it to the bottom of his riverside garden and named it "Affluent Society" . He was a habitué of joints like the Reform Club and L'Amico, favourite watering-holes of leading Conservative politicians. He once arranged a meeting with Eric Hammond of the EETPU at Covent Garden ("1 booked a box through being a GLC nominated Governor of Sadlers Wells and invited Eric to come along"").

And yet, in TUC terms, Jenkins was on the 'left" Throughout his career, he worked closely with the Com munist Party and with union leaders who were part of the semi-Stalinist 'Broad Left' within the TUC. Before quit ting the labour movement, he ensured that ASTMS linked up with the last bastion of unreconstructed Stalinism within the British labour movement, TASS, to create the MSF (which is still suffering from the 'culture clash' between the tightly-knit structures of TASS and the more open, branch-based traditions of ASTMS).

Jenkins amassed a fortune during his years as a union official and is probably the first man to have become a millionaire on the back of the British trade union movement. But he was not actually corrupt - just very shrewd, especially when it came to property speculation.

In many respects he was a very good (or, at least, effec-

----- pull-quotes -----

INSIDE THE UNIONS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 466

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →