Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why do Militant End the Ban'?

Socialist Organiser no. 466, 16 November 1990 · scan p. 14 · about 990 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

weekend.

At the CPSA Broad Left conference they opposed a motion calling for support for and affiliation to 'End the Ban!', the broad-based campaign to defend Socialist Organiser from the witch-hunters.

it seems that the word had gone out to leading Militant supporters present that under no circumstances should they allow 'their' Broad Left to come out on record in defence of Socialist Organiser. 'End the Ban!' was to be opposed by any means necessary.

Moving the resolution in our defence, Mark Serwotka pointed out that supporting End the Ban!' was the only meaningful way of defending Socialist Organiser.

"You can't say, argued Mark, "that you are against the ban on Socialist Organiser and the expulsion of people like me who sell the paper if you then refuse to back the only existing campaign which is taking up our defence. If you say you are against the ban then you must back 'End the Ban! otherwise existence in the real world."

Militant had no answer to this argument. Instead they came to the rostrum to display one of the most pathetic collections of red herrings ever to be assembled for use in a debate.

Their first line of autack was that old conference chestnut: •We don't know enough about this campaign". . A strange argument from people who have voted in BL regional meetings not to distribute 'End the Ban!' material and stranger still when you consider that every Constituency Labour Party has received three mailings from the campaign. Are no Militant supporters active in the Labour Party anymore?

This argument was followed up by vague allegations that End the Ban! includes witch-hunters in its ranks and the rather shaky logical deduction from this that therefore the campaign could not be supported The force of this argument was lost somewhat when Steve Ion, the Militant supporter keen to prove that SO was getting in 10 bed with witch-hunters, when challenged "couldn't remember the exact names" of the alleged witch-hunters.

Having failed to gain an echo with their 'reasonable' arguments, the Militant machine switched gear.

*Socialist Organiser is a collection of petty bourgeois individuals with no roots in the working class, no ideas and no prograninic, argued Militant "politico" John Melnally. This crude argument backfired Socialist Organiser supporters are known as serious working class fighters by all the independent people present at the conference.

For instance, it was SO sellers and their allies in the Socialist Caucus who launched the Branches Against Agencies campaign: a broad-based unofficial alliance of all those in the union who want to fight to defend the pay and conditions of civil servants and resist the transformation of the civil service into a series of Agencies. Right now, two SO sellers. John Meloney and Chris Hickey, are in the forefront of the campaign in the Property Services Agency to defend Jobs and conditions. fighting to held the action together and escalate it in the face of sabotage from some NUCPS officials.

SO seller John Williams is the ideas, he then proceeded to attack us for our ideas: for daring to criticise their dismal record ir Liverpool *SO has sided with Kinnock, the media, the Tories and their state against the former Marxist leadership of Liverpool City Council.

SO seller Trudy Saunders put Militant straight: *We don't support Kinnock against Militant. We do believe that there should be a rank and file labour movement inquiry into the Hatton affair and the working of the council. Ordinary workers in Liverpool have the right to know what went on and if, as Militant say, they have nothing to hide Anyway, Militant were attempting to avoid the real issue. SO supporters think Mililant are hopeless politically, nevertheless we are prepared to defend them against the rightwing. They should do the same for us. It was a basic principle of uniting against the witch-hunters and of defending the right to socialist dissent. If Phil Kelly of Tribune was prepared to rudimentary support 10 then why shouldn't Militant?

Militant had no answer.

When it came to the vote some very strange things happened.

Militant won by a tiny margin of the 150 or so present. But all the independent people voted for ETB and a large number of Militant's own people voted with SO, abstained or left the room to avoid the vote. They included former CPSA President Kevin Roddy who abstained.

One leading Broad Left Militant supporter who is regularly put forward on the Militant slate' and has held office in the union several times, gave us this confession: "I want you to know 1 couldn't stomach that last vote.l left the room...maybe the tinie will come when I don' just do that...

Militant hatcher man Melnally even came up to SO sellers to apologise: *1 realise I went over the top and 1 apologise for that And I want you to know that we will be defending you against the right wing." Empty words.

He'd done his job, He'd kept the BL as Militant's property.

All this is evidence of a serious crisis within the ranks of the Militant. The CPSA Broad Left has long been the jewel in their trade union crown. Twice in the last decade they have taken over the national leadership of the union and...done nothing. The battle was always tomorrow, never today. They have failed to lead the left and they know it That is why they react with such hysteria those who challenge them politically. The hysteria is the public counterpart of Militant's religious, sect-like internal" polemics against opponents.

Militant scent ser driving any dissident voices of the Broad Left.

They will not End the ban If you want to find out more about 'End the Ban!' write to ETB c/o Martin Thomas, 12a Cannonbury Street, Islington, London N1

----- pull-quotes -----

your opposition to the witchhunt is purely "theoretical' and has no

then they should welcome an in- name Which would clear their

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 466

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →