Letters home
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
TV By Tom Othings ive experienced vat ne of the most terrifying sitting in a Manchester cinema — in which there were a lot of youngsters — as newsreel shots from the Nazi death camps were shown in some item preliminary to the main film going to cut his dick off.
Another dyke pops into the story later, with it would seem, a similar relationship to Jessica, ditterent only in that she is very Germanic and white.
We are dealing here in an image of lesbians lifted without modification from male pornography.
Lesbianism, treated as it is here, in a scene of such brutal pornographic excess, serves only to illustrate Jessica's wickedness. The story stinks of male hatred.
Alexander Stuart has set out to shock us, disgust us. It is not a novel that digusts because it accurately expresses a disgusting truth. Vivid and revolting descriptions are a feature of much modern fiction. There can be a point to it: but in this, I find little or no truth at all.
That it is, nevertheless, a marvellously well-written and readable book only makes it more infuriating. He writes in astonishing, acid prose that could surely be put to la finer purpose.
As the big-eyed, skeletal figures, dressed in the regulation striped pyjamas, moved jerkily around the camera, a layer of the youth started to guffaw loudly!
Too many horror films, I suppose. It was all unreal to them.
So it is with war. Too many descriptions in familiar half-dead stereotyped words, too many familiar images, which have long ago lost the power to evoke more than a fraction of a normal human response to the things they should convey.
'A War Far From Home" (Timewatch, BBC2, 13 November) consisted of letters sent home to India by soldiers serving in the war trenches of Europe during World War 1.
These letters read out on Timewatch by wonderfully dignified Indian actors — conveyed the impact of war on them in blisteringly fresh and immensely powerful language, the poetic and vivid language of hill tribesmen, professional warriors bred to value human qualities like bravery and loyalty and personal skill in the use of arms, who found themselves in the trenches reduced to cattle being slaughtered by distant machines hurling maiming and death at them from across the plain and out of the sky.
130,000 Indian "sepoys came to fight, and 30,000 left their bones behind.
They had been sent to fight for England by Indian princes and politicians, who thereby hoped a grateful Britain would grant india Home Rule. In fact, the British distrusted them so much that all letters were translated, copied and censored. (Very little "disloyalty" was discovered.) But this wonderful record exists because of the fear of these warriors' colonial masters.
The letters should be published.