Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Those who do not likely to repeat it

Socialist Organiser no. 466, 16 November 1990 · scan p. 12 · about 951 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

After four and a half years of carnage and slaughter during the First World War the victors, the British, French, and Americans sat down to dictate the peace Treaty of Versailles, to re-dividi the world. American President Woodrow Wilson's plans for a liberal settlement, based on American apsirations towards equal access to markets were thwarted by the dyed-in-the-wool imperialist/colonialist attitudes of the French and Commonwealth trade links, and its own looser rival EC of peripheral West European countries, EFTA.

Staying out was soon shown to have been a mistake. The EC showed tremendous dynamism. The Tory government decided to join in 1961. De Gaulle's France blocked British membership. From then on it was an issue. The Labour government decided to join in 1967, and was again blocked.

A sizeable chunk of the capitalist class opposed EC entry - those with ties, including ties of sentiment, with the Commonwealth. In the Labour Party, the traditional left, represented by Michael Foot and Tribune, were traditional patriots. The Labour Right, too, initially opposed entry. Labour, too, had ties to the Commonwealth. The trade union establishment wanted to keep undisturbed its cosy links with the British state, which continued, even under Tory governments, into the "70s.

The Communist Party, too, was antiEuropean. The CP then had perhaps 30,000 members, and great strength among both the trade union bureaucracy and rank-and-file leaders in industry. It reflected Russia's foreign policy on this as on everything else (it would make its first important break by opposing the invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968).

The CP opposed the EC. CP and Labour responses combined to produce a powerful current of working-class, and even left-wing working-class, nationalism. It was part of the same complex which, in the late '60s, set militant London dockers marching through the streets in support of the Tory race demagogue Enoch Powell. The broad left lined up with the "nos" in the "great debate about Britain joining the EC.

The revolutionary left held their ground, retusing to join the "No to the EC" camp. We poured bitter scorn on the little-England patriots like Michael Foot, with their vision of a "British socialism" modelled on wartime Britain, and on the Stalinist "patriots Then a serious though sectarian he Socialist Labour League group, later to go mad and take the name WRP - explained: *What in fact has happened is that labour and trade union 'personalities' and journals have found themselves quite naturally taking sides on the question: what is best for British capitalism? In most cases that is not surprising, but it exposes the misleadership or lack of leadership of both the Right wing and the Tribune and other Lefts.

It is scarcely necessary for the labour movement to get involved in a detailed and necessarily inconclusive discussion about the British - keen to maintain overlordship of their dominions, and impose a crippling and ultimately catastrophic settlement upon Germany. Only the Bolshevik revolution in Russia in 1917 held out hope for a genuine working class internationalist solution to imperialism's machinations for the working class and oppressed nations of the world. That revolution was defeated outside Russia. pros and cons of the Common Market. This cannot inspire the rank and file or build its strength... Consistent socialists should be unequivocally in favour of breaking down national barriers, not under the auspices of the trusts seeking to exploit labour power more methodically and play one section off against another more successfully, but by working for a workers' government which alone can do the job in a genuinely internationalist way.

Taking sides for or against the Tories joining the Common Market means arguing about just how Europe's workers should be exploited. Instead, the working class movement must unite around a programme for the socialist planning of European industry... Whether or not Britain enters the Common Market the same principles will govern our approach" (Tom Kemp, "Socialism and the European Common Market", Newsletter, 24 June 1961), The future Socialist Workers' Party declared: *In or out of the Common Market, the problems facing the British labour movement are likely to be very much the same. Indeed, the point is that the issues facing us are more similar to those facing European and American workers than at any time in the past 40 years" • (John Palmer, International Socialism journal, Spring 1963. Labour Worker, the group's fortnightly paper, was "softer" , reflecting some of the pressure from the broad left).

The future Socialist Outlook, Socialist Acfion, and Militant were all then in one pod. Ernest Mandel summed up their views:

"For revolutionary Marxists, this conflict [about Britain's application to join the EC and De Gaulle's opposition] is a typical inter-imperialist competitive struggle in which the working class has no reason for supporting one side against the other. To the policies of both sides, they must counterpose the struggle for a Socialist United States of Europe, for a really unified Europe which could effectively surmount the antagonisms bred by capitalist competition; that could only be a Europe which has abolished both capitalist property and the bourgeois state....

"It would be pure suicide for the working class to solidarise itself either with its own bourgeoisie or with that of the opposing camp. Its only effective reply can be to affirm its basic class solidarity: Workers of all European countries unite against the Europe of the monopolies, whether it raises the slogan of the Europe of "fatherlands" , the "open" Europe, or the European "community"?.." (From "Crisis in the Common Market" , International Socialist Review, spring 1963).

Next veek Ill cover how the far left changed ts line, why, and thei mplicatii Ins.

----- pull-quotes -----

The Tre aty

learn from history are of Versailles 919

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 466

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →