The sad storv of ine sad story OT the left and Europe
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
The Common Market is here to stay... Socialists must realise that it is impossible ti build even a decent welfare state in isolation.
The idea of having a Chinese Wall around Britain, or any other country, absurd.
To the large multi-national and transnational companies, national boundaries mean little in an economic political sense...
I want those of us who are democratic socialists to work for a European federatic of sovereign democratic socialist states... Like-minded socialists should be forging socialist perspective and strategy for the whole of Europe. I am convinced that a point has been reached where socialism must be rescued from its imprisonment within national boundaries.
There is a need for a crusade of dedicated socialists in every country who will put their international concepts before purely national interests. I hope that a start in this direction will be made at the forthcoming Socialist Conference [in Manchester on 17-18 November]..." Ear article excerpted above Heffer's Guardian may help the left to rethink its attitudes to the European Community.
Heffer, of course, has always been more sensible on the EC than most of the Left, though he did for many years share their conclusion, that Britain should be withdrawn from its European entanglements. His Guardian piece comes to pretty much the same conclusions as our editorial in last week's SO.
The would-be revolutionary left is more d b kward Paul McGarry rev To face reality squarely least resistance: to call things by their right names to speak the truth to the masses, no matter how bitter it may be: not to fear obstacles; to be true in little things as in big ones: to base one's programme on the logic of the class struggle: !
be bold when the hour for action arrives - these are the rules of the Fourth Trotsky. "The Transition:
Programmi On every count SWP hack and sometime intellectual Alex Callinicos fails. "...examining the origins...
exploring the crisis and identifying the continuation of Trotskyism" in 90 pages isn't the easiest of tasks. But weighed down by a mixture of pomposity and sycophancy, a serious survey of Trotskyism becomes impossible for Callinicos.
The shortness of this book is its saving grace, in fact. Three volumes of the history of Trotskyism (a partial guide to ry read backwards the politics of the SP, in the tradition of (liff'> Lenin trilog would have been unbearable The book's framework is esfablished in the introduction Modern Trotskyism has been saved by the International Socialist tradition led by guru lon! Cliff. "whose critique ol orthodos Trotskyism was conceived rather as a return to ¿assical Marxisn® Ciff'› critique, of course. es his own peculiar theors of state capitalism in which competition between the superpowers through arms production defines the internal dynamics of the Soviet I nion. Competition as such is carried out via use values, a revision of Marxism rather than a return to it. Callinicos also omits to tell us that many of Cliff's formulations were borrowed From Max Shachiman and the Johnson-Forrest tendency of 1 SWP-US.
And we're not treated to an explanation of how Cliff's infamous article "Trotsky on Substitutionism' fits into this *classical Marxisn"
In the '60s Cliff and the Socialist Review Group was explicitly anti-Leninist and firmly planted in the Labour Party. Cliff cites Trotsky's 1904 warning about the dangers of the centralised party replacing the class, the central committee replacing the party, etc, etc. Cliff laments "Trotsky never returned to it [anti-Leninism| again" . Trotsky, of course, admitted he had been wrong. too much of a tall order for tardy in facing up to the situation created for us by Mrs Thatcher stealing the left's clothes on Europe. If Thatcher is ousted and the "pro-Europeans" are again in undisputed charge of the Tory Party, then much of the pressure on the left to come to terms with European integration will fade.
Most likely they'll leave well enough alone, muting (as now) and then dropping their long-time anti-Europeanism, neither acknowledging their shift nor attempting to learn from the experience. Before long, you'll find SWPers and Militant supporters who will call you a liar if you recall that for 20 years they played their little "socialist" tin whistles on the fringes of the great loud last parade of the "little Britishers"
It is a terrible story, the record of the British far left on Europe. In the history of socialism it belongs to the book of political pathology in which are recorded such episodes as the Communist International's flirtation in the early "20s with German nationalism and even anti-semitism ("'national Bolshevism"), and the efforts of honest communists in South Africa in the same period who organised a workers? insurrection and raised the slogan, "Workers of the world unite for a white South Africa!"
A whole generation of would-be Trotskyists have been educated in an antiEuropeanism and anti-internationalism, in which slogans like the Socialist United States of Europe were advocated as a centrist cover - no, a deodorant — for practical politics that were the purest little-Britainism.
And the story is even stranger than it seems. When the European Community first became an issue in Britain, in the early '60s, the entire revolutionary left - the groups now known as the SWP, Militant, Socialist Action, Socialist Outlook, and the WRPs, all without exception - responded with the same politics as Socialist Organiser now argues. 1 repeat: all, without exception. Socialist Organiser - and its predecessors like Workers' Action - have seemed freakish in the last two decades because we didn't change, and the others did.
When the ec was set up in 1958, Britain stayed out. Britain had its own Cliff and callinicos. Was Cliff's anti-leninism an aspect of the "reorientation" of modern Trotskyism? Callinicos remains silent.
Elsewhere Comrade Alex points an accusing finger at Gerry Healy and his role in the purges of the early British Trotskyist movement. It comes as a surprise then to turn to the "family free" on pages 36-37 to find that none of the six or so groups expelled from the SHP in the "70s are denoted.
Despite his intention to focus on Anglo-American Trotskyism, (allinicos also fails in his family tree to note, never mind explain, the splits from the SWP-L: or the extent of the break up of Cliff's American organisation and blandly comments on the International Marxist Group "disintegrating" in the early "80s.
Strange, I thought the IMG "reorientated" to the Labour Party. Socialist Organiser doesn't appear in the family tree at all! In fact, according the "tree" , there are no Trotskyist groups in Britain today except the SWP and Which reminds me of the story of Callinicos presenting himself to a group of South African shop stewards as Alex Callinicos, a revolutionary from Britain" . He was immediately asked, "where's your machine gun then?"
A nightmare of a book, and a very strange one for the Open University to publish as a textbook.
Scan page 13
nise
----- pull-quotes -----
AGAINST THE TIDE
Trotskyism' by A Callinicos, Open University. £6.99 That rel the me on