Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

An oppressed nation fights against The struggle for Saharawi independence

Socialist Organiser no. 466, 16 November 1990 · scan pp. 10–12 · about 2,662 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

By o reach the Saharawi drove across completely featureless desert._ The sand has been blown away, so there's just a layer of fine dust on rock, and a straight-line horizon. It's very oppressive, very exposed to heat and cold.

The Saharawi struggle is in essence anti-colonial. The Spanish were the coloniai power and ceded half the country (then the Spanish Sahara) to Mauritania and half to Morocco. The Saharawi mounted a war of independence against both countries and Mauritania was beaten back. Morocco now occupies all the coastal areas and has built a huge wall across the country; about one-third of the population live in the occupied territories behind that wall, and two-thirds in five refugee camps just over the border in Algeria, where they fled after being napalmed by Morocco In those refugee camps, the Saharawis have achieved a tremendous amount in the most difficult conditions. In any other place I've been where there's been a war of liberation, the whole ethos has been war, but it's not like that in the camps.

There's no military strutting at all. When the soldiers came back to the camps, they were welcomed back, but we never saw a gun in the camps, other than on the sentries They look forward beyond the war, and the camps are set around the idea of planning for the future beyond the war.

The conditions they are in are horrendous. They're in what is called, literally translated, the desert of deserts, and the Algerians didn't believe it was possible for anyone to survive there. The Saharawi are recognised as refugees, and they are dependent on international aid; but they are extraordinarily independent within the inherent dependence.

Inside each camp they have a delegate democracy. All the municipal committees are based on little street groups. They're trying to involve the whole community in decision-making.

When the Spanish left in 1975 the nation had only one teacher. Now, in the desert, they have built themselves hospitals and schools. They train themselves. They ask people to go for three or six month stints of training elsewhere, and then come back to train others.

They've also developed a way of growing things in the desert, aided by War on Want. They grow cabbages, onions, tomatoes and beetroots under the palm trees.

This is very important for their diet, but extremely difficult, as the soil is saline, and they have become innovators in desert horticulture.

The Saharawis have developed tactics which make the Moroccan soldiers on the wall sitting targets for them. It's their country, and they aren't going to go away. The soldiers are not fighting for any cause they believe in.

Military aid comes from the Algerian government, but the Saharawi army has no outside military advisers.

The Saharawi are trying to look after themselves in their own way. People coming from our culture just ask the wrong questions. They're dependent on International Red Cross aid, and they have distribution committees. To get a measure of how the committees worked, I asked one woman: "If your little boy is on his last pair of trousers, do you have to wait for the next month's distribution, or can you go to going to go away languages, maybe four. They now have high schools in the camps, teaching up to 15 years, though they have to go outside for further education. They have set up training centres, which teach administrative skills as well as sewing, knitting, car maintenance and so on.

They don't have their own printing presses, so they're dependent on school books and literature from outside.

Health is a very high priority too; they're building up a mix of traditional medicine and Western technology.

As far as I know, they have the distribution committee straight away?" She looked astonished and said: "If he's on his last pair of trousers, my neighbour will give me a pair"

They are Muslims, but it's very different to what you'll find in Algiers. They don't have mosques, presumably because of their nomadic background, and they see religion as a private thing.

Everyone is dedicated to learning. Everyone seemed to speak at least three no very fixed ideas about how they will organise their economy when they get their country back. They say, not capitals, wists.

developing our own way forward"

The Western Sahara is mineral-rich. They're very alive to the danger of neo-colonialism, but as far as 1 know they have no particular prescriptions for avoiding it.

I don't really know what would happen if people wanted to organise politically outside the nationalist movement, Polisario. While we were there, there was evidence of individuals being able to dissent, but of course that's very different, and much less threatening, than a group getting together.

think Polisario would feel able to allow independent political organisation. I'm not sure, because they've already done the impossible in so many areas. But there are open discussions, with a lot of conflicting views, in the local committees.

They're mostly women and children in the camps, because the men are fighting, and although the president is a man, women are in positions of responsibility right through the structures. Women are responsible for most of the outstanding progress made by their nation within the refugee camps. One woman who spoke to me said: "We know what has happened in Algeria. We know that the women were very strong during the revolution, and now they've gone back behind the veil. We'll have to stay strong and find a way for ourselves"

Polisario is recognised as the legitimate government of the Western Sahara by a majority of the countries of the Organisation of African Unity. The United Nations is committed to organising a referendum regarding independence from Morocco amongst the Saharawi in the camps and the occupied areas, and is supported in this by Polisario.

It is a vote that the Polisario will undoubtedly win. Morocco has been obstructive at every stage, but now it looks hopeful.

At a current UN meeting, chaired by the UK, members will be asked to agree funds for the referendum process. If this is agreed, the Saharawi could be in their homeland by the end of the year.

However, there are fears that Britain may jib at the financial cost of peace.

Scan page 11

the shanty towns workers philosophy. Different positions coexist within it in a dialectical relationship, which does not predetermine the dynamic syntheses that may emerge in the elaboration of concrete policies. What unites these various political cultures of freedom is the common project ot creating a new society favourable to ending exploitation and oppression.

Our commitment to democracy makes us anti-capitalist militants. This choice has profoundly marked our struggle for democracy. The discovery (which for many of us was empirical betore it became theoretical) of the structural perversity of capitalism has been a very strong stimulus for most PT activists to organise in a political party. We have represented, and continue to represent, an angry response to the pointless suffering of millions of people that flows from the logic of capitalist barbarism.

Our concrete historical experience - the other side of the coin of the 'Brazilian miracle'. , and many other tragic circumstances here and in other countries have taught us that capitalism, whatever its material power, is unjust by nature, that it marginalises millions of people and blocks a fraternal division of social wealth, which is a mainspring for any real democracy.

The founding documents of the PT - the Manifesto and Founding Programme - already explained that the end of Brazilian capitalism was an essential precondition for genuine democratisation of Brazilian life. Even if these first documents made little progress in defining an alternative society, the PT's historical project was already clearly socialist. The ten years since the founding of the party - years of bitter but inspiring strugglehave confirmed our anti-capitalist options and redoubled our determination to transform society.

This anti-capitalist conviction, generated by the bitter experience of Brazilian society, also impels us to take our distance from the projects of the social democracy, which historically have not led towards disengaging from capitalist society.

The past social democratic experiences prove that even if you get into the government or the institutions of the state - notably, the parliament - without a mass mobilisation at the grassroots it is impossible to reach socialism.

The social democrats believed in the neutrality of the state apparatus and thought that capitalist efficiency was compatible with a peaceful transition toward a different economic and social logic. Over time, this current abandoned the perspective of a parliamentary transition to socialism and even the aspiration of socialism, without however leaving the state institutions.

Critical dialogue with social democrats doubtless has its usefulness for the workers' struggle internationally. But the social democrats' ideological project does not correspond either to the anticapitalist convictions of the PT or its objectives of emancipation.

Our strategic fight for demor racy our very identity has also led to us rejecting the models of the so-called actually existing socialism. We have always known that this appellation was false. The conservative ideologues are using the crisis in the East to According to its detractors, socialism is in fact incompatible with the ideas of progress and freedom. We challenge this reactionary conception.

The abstract term, 'actually existing socialism' ', does not take account of the special features of countries, of different revolutionary processes nor of economic and political differences. It equates experiences of social transformation that are by their nature heterogeneous. It minimises certain historic gains that are definitely important for the peoples that have won them.

Some so-called socialist regimes came out of popular revolutions. Others were engendered by the defeat of Nazi Germany and the Soviet army's occupation of a series of East European countries. In some of these processes, the masses managed to exert an influence on the national life. A foremost and special place has to be reserved for the Sandinista experience in Nicaragua, despite its difficulties. The Sandinistas were able to establish and maintain a political and civic equality that the people never knew before.

The PT supports the struggle of the workers and the peoples for liberation. It defends genuine revolutionary processes while maintaining an independent attitude and reserving the right to make criticisms. Since its founding, the PT has known that the theory and practice of the experiences of so-called actually existing socialism are incompatible with the project of liberating socialism that it proclaims. We reject the lack of political, economic and social democracy; the monopoly of power by a single party, even when there is formal acceptance of multipartyism; domination by the bureaucracy, transformed into a privileged layer or caste; open or veiled repression of ideological and cultural pluralism; and the management of production by top-down authoritarian and inefficient planning.

We have always criticised these regimes from the standpoint of revolutionary struggle and in the light of the various international socialist processes. The PT was the first Brazilian party to support the democratic struggle of Solidarnosc in Poland, even though it had no other ideological affinities with this union movement. We have denounced the violations of trade union, political and religious freedoms that have occurred in the so-called socialist countries in the same way as we have fought for public freedoms in Brazil. We have denounced the crimes against humanity committed in Bucharest or elsewhere, such as the premeditated murder of agricultural workers in Brazil. For the PT, there can be no socialism that is not genuinely democratic.

The movements that have led to reforms in the Eastern countries have rightly rebelled against totalitarianism and economic paralysis, seeking to establish democratic regimes and to end the bureaucratic, ultra-centralised management of the economy. The outcome of these changes is not yet determined. Political and social struggle will mould these new regimes.

The PT is convinced that the upsets that have occurred in the East and are continuing in the countries of so-called actually existing socialism have a positive historic portent, even if reactionary currents favourable to capitalist restoration are in the majority today.

These movements - even if they do not put forward a project for renewing socialism - are breaking the political ice and bringing the various political and social forces back to the front of the stage. By encouraging democratic gains, they can offer new possibilities for socialism. The political energy that has been liberated by social mobilisation will not be easily tamed by the recipes of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) or the false paradises of capitalist propaganda.

'he movement we want to build from the rich tradition of mass struggles in the history of Brazil. It must base itself on solidarity among human beings and be a sum of specific aptitudes for solving collective problems. It will have to be a collective democratic suband without negating the rich and Wage necessary individual specificities.

It will have to perfect the fundamental equality among citizens, while jealously safeguarding the right of political, religious, cultural and other differences.

This society will fight for women's liberation, against racism and all forms of oppression, and foster the emergence of an integrating and universalist democracy.

Pluralism and self-organísation will not only be permitted but encouraged at all levels of social life. They will be an antidote to the bureaucratisation of government, minds and wills.

While affirming national identities and independence, the new society will reject any imperial pretension and foster cooperative relations among the peoples of the world.

As we defend Cuba or Grenada against US imperialist aggression, we defend the right of self-determination of the peoples, and we encourage internationalist action. Democratic, socialist internationalism will be a constant source of inspiration.

The socialism that we want to build will only be achieved if it establishes an authentic economic democracy.

It will have to be organised therefore around social ownership of the means production which cannot be confused with stat‹ ownership - that will take forms democratically decided upon by the society (individual, cooperative, nationalised, and so on).

Such economic democracy must overcome the perverse logic of the capitalist economy as well as that of the autocratic state commandism that prevails many so-called socialist economies Its priorities and objectives will have to be subject to the will of the society and not to any supposed strategic interests of the state.

It will have to combine - and that is the greatest of the challenges it will face - increasing productivity and satisfying material needs with a new organisation of work that will end the present alienation.

It must strengthen the management of the units of production factory councils are an essential reference point - and the entire system through strategic planning under social supervision.

In the political field, socialism will have to preserve the democratic freedoms won with such difficulty in capitalist society but also broaden and radicalise them (freedom of opinion, freedom to demonstrate, freedom of civic and political organisation for the parties).

Such freedoms concern all citizens, being limited only by the democratic framework.

Instruments of direct democracy that preserve the participation of the masses at the various levels of political leadership and economic management will have to coexist with the instruments of representative democracy and flexible mechanisms for consulting the people that can express collective interests without the interference of the capitalists.

In its fight for socialism, the PT does not minimise the theoretical and practical obstacles it will have to overcome.

It knows that it has to make an enormous effort in the field of programme and social struggle.

It is more than ever ready to undertake this, along with all of the forces striving for democracy and transformation in Brazil.

Scan page 12

sCi PECTIVE

----- pull-quotes -----

*It's their country and they aren't

At the moment they're in a state of war, and I don't

Our model of socialist democracy

combat any project that might run counter to capitalist domination.

A rich tradition struggle - takes venere on concretely.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 466

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →