Ireland moves left
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Last Friday Mary Robinson broke the calm exterior she had maintained during her election campaign to movingly thank the "Mna na hEireann" (the women of Ireland) who, she said, had been iesponsible for her surprise victory.
It was a big occasion, not least because long-suffering sections of the Irish people seemed to have given a shock to the political establishment. Women had, "instead of rocking the cradle, rocked the system"
Whether Mary Robinson will rock the system or be lulled to sleep by it is another question - but there was much to smile about in this result.
Mary Robinson represented three sweet firsts last week. She is the first woman to be elected President, this was the first national election victory for the left, and the first time Fianna Fail lost a Presidential election. Just to ice the cake, it was the worst election result ever for the main opposition, Fine Gael.
After the first round Brian Lenihan of the governing Fianna Fail party was just ahead with 44% of the vote, Robinson was second with 39% and Fine Gael Austin Currie was well behind with 17%. After Currie's vote had been redistributed Robinson had received the bulk of them and this put her 86,000 votes ahead of Lenihan.
Everyone, of course, has their account of the reasons for her We asked two of Ireland's most prominent response to the election of Mary Robinson Republic of Ireland.
Jim Kemmy is a socialist member of Dail Michael D Higgins is a long-time wing of the Irish Labour PartyThey talked to Mark Osborn. Michael Higgins believe that the election of Mary Robinson represents a shift in Irish culture. The The corrupt old establishment Fianna Fail Ber hands triumph. Labour Party leaders emphasise the slick middle-of-theroad campaign which concentrated on getting her image right and tried to avoid controversy At the level of conventional politics she certainly ran an efficient campaign, it started early, emphasised her distance from the pettiness and patronage of the major party system, and appealed to a 'rainbow coalition' of outsiders. Her opponents like to stress the extent to which she benefitted from the scandal surrounding Brian Lenihan and his subsequent sacking. Although it damaged him in mid-campaign, at the last moment he appeared to win a sizeable sympathy vote. There is something in all of these accounts, no doubt, but three other interlinked factors seem to be decisive.
One is the huge turnout of women, across the party system and the country, to support a candidate who spoke to them as people with specific interests and grievances. The second is the emergence of an urban vote which is clearly more radical and progressive. Dublin gave Mary Robinson her victory: she took nearly 50% of the vote there, sweeping the board in some constituencies. Its large and concentrated population made up for Lenihan's success in rural areas. He won in every western constituency bar Robinson's own of Galway West.
Thirdly, and most importantly, there is a more long-term shift in Irish politics. Ireland has the youngest population in Europe and this young electorate is more demanding, less loyal to the old socialists for their as President of the clectron campaign brought together many groups who hoped for ethical change.
At its base much of the strength shake party machines and more resistant to the Catholicismevailing values of and populist nationalism. This development is the most worrying for the right-wing parties, because it will destroy them unless they can control it.
The implications of Mary Robinson's victory will take time to sink in. In the short term it is the traditional parties which are feeling the effects. The leader of Fine Gael, Alan Dukes, has resigned.
Charles Haughey has faced crises before but this time his intervention managed to both scapegoat a friend and ally and practically guarantee defeat to save his own skin. Haughey has failed five times in 10 of the campaign came from women's groups, groups which had campaigned for family planning rights and divorce rights.
Mary Robinson is an egalitarian and a feminist. She is driven by a strong sense of fairness.
It is possible to overestimate the division between town and country. In my West of Ireland constituency, Connemara, Mary Robinson topped the poll. She not only won in Dublin, but also in Cork City.
There was a strong vote amongst years to get an overall majority for his party in the Dail. Even his Tammany Hall machine might creak under such pressure. The vote of Labour and the left should be boosted at the next election thought its representation is dominated by pale pink Springites and the even more rightward-moving Workers PartyFinally, there Is Kobinson herself. In fact the President's job is a powerless one, but this victory has awakened expectations and Mary Robinson will be looked to as , in her own words, "a voice for the disadvantaged and marginalised" She will suffer the dual strategy of isolation and incorporation from women. But that does not explain the whole story. There was a big vote amongst the young: they wanted a breath of fresh air. Neither the politicies or language of the big parties relate to the young people; they do not have a coherent dialogue with the young.
Much of Mary Robinson's language in recent years has been against the principles of exclusion - for women on juries, for homes for the homeless. Mary Robinson is for participation and inclusion.
It is true that there is some backlash from the defeats on abortion and divorce. The campaign drew on a broader constituency than the left.
There has been a good deal of cooperation between Labour and the Workers Party during the campaign. Statements have already been made in favour of continuing work in this spirit. This welcome development Jim Kemmy Be are very pleased with the victory of Mary Robinson. The left here is very excited. This could herald a new era in Irish politics. This victory is good for women and good for socialism.
Mary Robinson has broken the Fianna Fail stranglehold on the Presidency. They have seen the post as an extension of their party. So the victory of Mary Robinson is good for democracy too.
The campaign against Mary Robinson was very dirty. Lots of mied was throw at bortiabout hed views the establishment and there is no clear sign that her politics will protect her from either. With a dynamic, campaigning left the chances are better than for some time; with a defensive, "respectable" left, many of the grievances Mary Robinson's victory represents will be absorbed by one of the other parties, most likely the populist and ever-adaptable Fianna Fail.
At the moment 1 prefer to be op timistic about overall developments. In a part of her acceptance speech which visibly disturbed Charles Haughey, Robinson declared that the Irish people had cast aside the dusty flags of the civil war. We need to see them torn up and buried forever.
contraception. The labour movement here is very fragmented and quite weak. We have lost a number of battles - including referendums on divorce and abortion. It is good to be on the winning side.
Obviously Mary Robinson's vote will not directly translate to us. But it will encourage more women to come forward. It has also boosted our morale. It proves there is a constituency out there that we can win. We have got a new appetite. -Fianna Fail were able to get out their traditional, strong vote in the country. This was surprising given the sacking of Brian Lenihan during the previous week.
One interesting, sad fact about the election was that although women of all classes came out to vote, one third of the electorate did not vote at all. Many of those who did not vote were working class men from the housing estates. Many are demoralised by unemployment and povertyMary Robinson is a liberal socialist. By Irish standards this is good. Mary Robinson is a good person with a record of fighting for people's rights. She represents social progress.
Women are under-represented in Irish life and Irish politics. None of the Labour Party or Workers Party TDs are women. This is a good victory for women.
We are a country with a quarter of a million unemployed, a third of the people on or under the poverty line and emmigration on the increase. Fine Gael's leader resigned yesterday. The likely replacement is John Bruton, a right winger. This will give Labour more space. The economic situation combined with a leadership change in Fine Gael will opportunities
Scan page 6
Socialist Organis