Malcolm Muggeridge's 6 years of disillusion vears of disillusion
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Socialist Party against prime minister Michel Rocard.
Most of the school student involved in the protests see their struggle as "not political" or even antipolitical. On demonstrations, however, such slogans have been shouted as *I am Arab, she is Jewish, he is black! But it doesn't matter! Race doesn't exist!" , or "Money for the schools, not for the Gulf war!"
In some schools the students' demands include the freedom to speak out, to put up posters, and so on; the present situation in that respect varies a lot from school to school. Demands are not yet being raised for students to have more say in the running of schools. By Thomas • very generatio - of ex-socialists teel 'it is the first. Nobody is ever quite so justly and properly disillusioned as you yourself have become.
Sure, you know there were others in the past. But you feel that they didn't really understand. Only now, with your own experience, is true and final understanding and definitive disillusion possible.
The inverted utopians of anti-socialist disillusion usually believe that history begins with their own sad awakening to a sour 'New Times'. Each wave of disillusion is composed of a "me-generation', you might say. Today's crop is, anyway.
Malcolm Muggeridge, who died this week at 87, could have told them a thing or two. He became disillusioned with socialism 60 years ago! He built a long career on his disillusionment. He didn't learn very much though. Someone who breaks with the semi-religious cult of Malcolm Muggeridge Stalin - and with the goal of human self-liberation - in 1932, and dies over half a century later as a famous propagandist for Christianity and a PR man for Mother Theresa of Calcutta can't be said to have advanced much.
Muggeridge was a nephew of the prominent Fabian Beatrice Webb. The Fabians were bureaucratic socialists, and the Webbs - Sydney and Beatrice - their high priests.
Not capitalists, not workers should run society, they said, but the state bureaucracy — middle class technocrats, recruited by ability.
The working class had no place except as "the people" in their vision of socialism. The Fabians found a prominent place in the new reformist British Labour Party, where they were the hated enemy of every brand of class-struggle socialist.
Then something strange happened. When Stalin set up his bureaucratic system in the USSR, lo and behold, said the Webbs, this is our very own Fabian socialism! The aged Webbs became outright propagandists for Stalin.
They remained reformists at home, of course. Sydney was chief jailer in charge of Britain's colonies as a Minister in the 1929-31 Labour government! He was in the House of Lords as Lord Passfield.
Malcolm Muggeridge travelled this far with the older generation. He went further - to Russia itself. There he sobered up quickly.