CPSA/NUCPS: merger yes. but not this one!
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Friday-Sunday 9-11 November National Conference. Coventry PolyA Details: 071-700 2393 Saturday 10 November. Demonstration for Troops the Gulf. Assemble 11.30, Sparkhill Park, Birmingham. Saturday 10 November. Irish Unity Connally Association seminar with Kevin McNamara and Clare Short 10,30, MSF HQ, 79 Camden Road, NW1 Saturday 10 November. Polish Solidarity Campaign meeting. Speakers: Anthony Polonsky and Taras Kuzio. 1.30, LSE, Houghton Street, London WCZ. Saturday 10 November. Women in Black picket of El Al office to protest about the occupation of the West Bank and Gaza by Israel. 3-4pm.,. Regent Street, London W1. Womer. only.
Sunday 11 November. Vigil outside the Chinese Embassy. central London. 3-4pm. Organised by the Chinese Solidarity Campaign.
Sunday 11 November. Anti-fascist demonstrations in York and London Sunday 11 November. Variety night with Jeremy Hardy, Tom Robinson and Billy Bragg. Bloomsbury Theatre, near Euston. Proceeds to the Londor Campaign for the Birmingham / Monday 12 November. Isaac Deutscher Memorial Lecture. Terry Eagleton on the origins of ideology: 7.30. New Lecture Theatre at the LSE, Houghton Street, London WC2 Tuesday 13 November. AntiFascist Action meeting with Mildred Gordon MP and Micky Fenn (T&G, Tilbury). Davenant liven its undemocratic nature, I think it is -clearly right to oppose the current proposed NUCPS/CPSA merger.
To support it now in the hope of putting right vital democratic questions at later date (Sarah Cotterill, SO462) would be a serious tactical mistake. It would leave the merged union even more securely in the hands of a strengthened and emboldened bureaucracy.
Sarah is, I think, correct in principle, however, in supporting a CPSA/NUCPS merger. A single civil service union should be our aim and a CPSA/NUCPS merger would be a big step towards this but any merger must safeguard the democratic advances won in both unions.
Some of the other contributions clearly spring from opposition to the merger 'in principle" , based on a crude and simplistic view of NUCPS as a "bosses' union"
Trudy Saunders' and Mark Serwotka's articles exemplify this approach. Their view, that NUCPS members' managerial/supervisory role in the work process acts as an absolute determinant of their consciousness is both one### PO Box London SE15 4NA dimensional and pessimistic.
NUCPS members_largely represent a strata, between the bourgeoisie and the working class, of lower-paid supervisory grades. In advanced capitalist countries such strata make up a large section of society. I would agree with the view of these strata being proletarianised due to the "de-skilling" of their work.
Trudy and Mark, on the other hand, implicitly define NUCPS members as simply middle class. Thus Trudy (in SO462): "the strength of CPSA is that it is a union which does not include executive grades", and furtherWinston Silcott Silcott. more, "CPSA and...NUCPS members have different interests to defend". Different class interests? That is the implication.
Such an exclusive and restrictive definition of the working class would tend to make the working class minority not only in the civil service but in society as a whole.
Logically this view is deeply pessimistic and poses serious questions not only about the ability of civil servants to defend their pay and conditions, but also fundamentally about the prospects for socialism.
As Marxists we have a responsibility to develop a strategy which unites the broadest section of the working class possible and strengthens the ability of the working class to fight for its interests. As a step along this road we should oppose this merger but argue strongly for a democratic merger.
Martin Donahue West London it ceived a Winston His brother, George Silcott, is in danger of being framed.
Apparently the police have been regularly picking on him, Winston Silcott is permanently 'on the block' at Albany Jail (Newport, Isle of Wight, PO30 SRS). If you want to write to him, his prison number is 4053.
Mike Shankland Sheffield to boost the When I stood as No Poll Tax' candidate in a local council by-election I received a rasping rebuke from an interfering bureaucrat at Walworth Road who urged me to stand down.
Against the official's advice, fighting on a clear-cut socialist programme, we quadrupled the Labour vote, and only lost the election by one single vote.
In the recent parliamentary by-election at Eastbourne, local choice candidate Peter Day, fellow poll tax fighter, was replaced by 'nonJob loes noswimming Anti-poll tax Labour candidates can focus the resistance controversial' Kinnockite Charlotte Atkins. Contesting the election according to what Eric Heffer would correctly call an 'SDP Mark 2' programme, they halved the Labour vote, only retaining the deposit by three votes.
Now they have intensified the McCarthyite witch-hunt against socialists in Sussex by closing down the Brighton Labour Party. The way they are going about things, they may well find they don't have enough activists left in the Labour Party for forthcoming election campaigns.
Moreover, given a choice between the Liberal Democrats and a lookalike new non-socialist Labor Party, southern voters ma actually plump for the formi - or not vote at al uninspired by a toss-up be ween a dead parrot and wilted rose.
----- pull-quotes -----
WRITEBACK DearS.O., Touire done it again! Your recent artice on thel Write 10 SO,
KIDS CUTS