Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Whose gunpol plot?

Socialist Organiser no. 465, 9 November 1990 · scan p. 13 · about 764 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Ages. It is not futuristic at all.

For instance, in the film the handmaidens wear a red scarf covering their hair. In the book they wear a winged white cap that restricts their vision. They are not allowed to see or communicate with their eyes. Some of the symbolism of the book is lost, here. Eyes are evil, dangerous and portray the influence of the devil. The Evil Eye (a primitive pagan but Christianadapted concept) is everywhere.

Kate is not so fearful here. But that is quite pleasing. Predictably, too, the film makes too much of the "romantic interest', but that's quite pleasant too. Go and see it. class. But Amis's conception of class is more to do with culture -taste in clothes, leisure pursuits, etc. Keith, the working class, comes out of this badly. Keith's wife Kath appears as worn out and used up. In other words, working class people are not capable of struggle or even of wishing for anything better, apart from ridiculous contemptable things — Amis says — such as winning a national darts competition. In other words, Amis is a snob.

Overall, Amis's politics are pessimistic: it's a tired old world, there is no genuine, positive human creativity left in it. They call this the post-modern condition, | believe. And there is no way out. We live in a sick, dog-eat-dog society and it is all rather distasteful.

But class divisions can also be a source of discontent focused not on doing someone else down (cheating, thieving, and coshing as Keith does) but rebellion against the system in quest of emancipation.

For this reason I cannot take Mr Amis's middle-class angst seriously. In fact I find it repulsive.

1 enjoyed the book, however. Buy it but spit on the polities or alternatively, if you ever happen to be in a restaurant where Mr Amis is sitting, spit in his nouvelle cuisine soup. Trouble lis, he'd probably find it amusing. Television Harange it is that Catholic ave you ever thought how kids should burn effigies of Guy Fawkes, and set off fireworks to celebrate his capture? (He was hanged, drawn and quartered for treason after trying to blow up parliament with gunpowder in 1605).

For Fawkes and his friends were Catholics, and Catholics were long blamed for what he tried to do. Remember, remember The Fifth of November, Gunpowder, treason and I see no reason Why gunpowder treason Should ever be forgot.

That old kids' jingle started life as a serious political battle chant. It meant: keep the Papists down. Catholics didn't achieve full civil rights and equality before the law until 1829.

Most British Catholics had converted to Protestantism by the 18th century, so it didn't matter too much here, except to a small layer of the upper classes. In Britishruled Ireland, where Catholics are the majority, the consequences of their long persecution and legal outlawry in their own country are stil being felt. -Traitors, BBC2's Bonfire Night by King James I's Chie Minister Cecil to frame up English Catholics as "terrorists drama, put forward the thesis that there never was a "gunpowder plot" by Catholic desperadoes to blow up Parliament. The "gunpowder plot" was something else entirely, a plot hatched by King James I's Chief Minister Cecil, to frame up the English Catholics as terrorists. His spies and agents controlled it from the beginning.It was a government-sponsored "happening" ; so to speak, a contrived and faked historical "photoopportunity". It was the sort of thing the Nazis did when, for example, in 1939, they dressed captured Poles in German uniform, shot them, and charged the Poles with attacking Germany (which then invaded Poland).

Jimmy McGovern's play was more of a lively lampoon than a po-faced thesis. It made the Catholic Church - which would continue to* be a combative force in most of Europe for most of the 17th century - too much the innocent victim, the fanatics being manipulated by government agents just too untypical. Yet it was thoughtprovokingAnd it highlighted a truth no socialist should forget: the victors write and censor history, and shape to suit themselves the beliefs and myths into which real events are transmuted in popular consciousness.

Next time you see a young Catholic acquaintance letting off fireworks on Guy Fawkes night, think of all the workers who let off mental fireworks in honour of their masters, masters who have risen to rule them by defeating them and their forefathers and who stay where they are now by brainwashing them.

----- pull-quotes -----

The "gunpowder' plot was something else entirely, a plot hatched

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 465

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →