Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

An open letter to a left Zionist friend left Zionist friend

Socialist Organiser no. 465, 9 November 1990 · scan pp. 7–11 · Michel Wa · about 6,049 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

The Gulf crisis has sharpened political lines in Israel already drawr deep by the three years of the intifada. The real threat to the Israeli people from Saddam Hussein's chemical weapons has rallied people to the Israeli right. A number of people who used to criticise Israeli policy from the left have swung back into the consensus, sharply distancing themselves from the Palestinian Arabs on the grounds of the Palestinians' support or semi-support for Saddam Hussein. The internationalist left, however, continues to argue that peace and security for the Israeli people can be won only through consistent democracy, recognising the national rights of the Palestinians. This letter by Michel Warshawsky poses the stark choice: murderous nationalism (with or without criticisms and reservations), or internationalism and consistent democracy for all nations. It is translated from the French socialist weekly Rouge.

Israeli Trotsky alleged aid to 'terrorists"

rshawsky, an ist in jail for Palestinian resents tres of ine Right are rou have received lots of resentatives of the Right are greeting you as the prodigal returned; the newspapers talk about you and your sudden reentry into the consensus.

And, inside your camp - that of the Zionist left - you and your friends have been arguing and exchanging mutual accusations for a month and a half now. I would like to express my opinion on some of the issues that bother you and your friends.

You are still in anguish, seeking understanding and even compassion. But you will get no understanding or compassion from me.

You are torn between your aspiration to peace and your desire to be part of the Jewish national, consensus; between your loyalty to old school mates and army comrades from the elite military unit to which you belonged, and your commitment to new friends in East Jerusalem; between your admiration for the United States and the image which you have tried to create in progressive circles in Europe; between your impartial statements and your rational conclusions, and your loyalty to the tribe and the excitement stirred up in you by the preparations for war and the call to the flag.

The Gulf crisis has been a heaven-sent opportunity for the political-military apparatus and for the right in Israel. In the first place, the crisis has diverted attention from the intifada, postponed international pressures, and, more importantly, put the question or war back on the agenda - fulfilling the secret, and sometimes avowed,

Scan page 8

Honour Across the Soviet Union Lenin and the Bolsheviks are being turned into scapegoats for the crimes of Stalin and his successors. The reality is that the Stalinist system, which is now tottering on the verge of complete collapse, was built on the grave of the first genuine workers' revolution in human history. Martin Thomas explains why we honour October.

November 1917 Rosa Luxemburg, the leader of the anti-war socialist internaionalists in Germany, received n her prison cell the news of the tussian Revolution. She wrote • her friend Luise Kautsky:

Are you happy about the Russians? Of course, they will not be able to maintain themselves in this witches' Sabbath, not because statistics show economic development in Russia to be too backward as your clever husband [Karl Kautsky] has figured out, but because social democracy in the highly developed West consists of wretched cowards who will look quietly on and let the Russians bleed to death. But such an end is better than living on for the fatherland'; it is an act of historical significance whose traces will not have disappeared even after many ages have passed.

Later, still in prison, she wrote a itical, but sympathetic pamphlet 1 the Russian Revolution. After ming out of prison in November 118 she changed her mind on some the criticisms she had made of e Bolsheviks, and did not publish e pamphlet. Nor, in the midst of e revolutionary struggles of Gerany, did she have time to revise it fore she was killed in January 19, on the orders of the reformist scialist' government. But the conision of her pamphlet summed up and all the more eloquently cause of her criticisms - the itoric significance of the Russian volution:

The Bolsheviks have shown that they are capable of everything that a genuine revolutionary party can contribute within the limits of the historical possibilities. They are not supposed to perform miracles. For a model and faultless proletarian revolution in an isolated land, exhausted by world war, strangled by imperialism, betrayed by the international proletariat, would be a miracle...

It is not a matter of this or that secondary question of tacties, but of the capacity for action of the proletariat, the strength to act, the will to power of socialism as such. In this, Lenin and Trotsky and their friends were the first, those who went ahead as an example to the proletariat of the world; they are still the only ones up to now who Luxemburg can cry with Hutten: I have dared'.

This is the essential and enduring thing in Bolshevik policy. In this sense theirs is the immortal historical service of having marched at the head of the international proletariat with the conquest of political power and the practical placing of the problem of the realisation of socialism, and of having advanced mightily the settlement of the score between capital and labour in the entire world. In Russia the problem could only be posed. It could not be solved in Russia.

And in this sense, the future everywhere belongs to "bolshevism'.

All over the world, revolutionary militants rallied to 'bolshevism'. In the USA, for the left wing of the Socialist Party:

Cannon The Bolshevik revolution in Russia changed everything almost overnight. Here was demonstrated in action the conquest of power by the proletariat. As in every other country, the tremendous impact of this proletarian revolutionary victory shook our movement in America to its very foundation. The inspiration alone of the deed enormously strengthened the revolutionary wing of the party, gave the workers new hope and aroused new interest in those theoretical problems of revolution which had not received proper recognition before that time.

We soon discovered that the organisers and leaders of the Russian revolution were not merely revolutionists in action. They were genuine Marxists in the field of doctrine. Out of Russia, from Lenin, Trotsky and the other leaders, we received for the first time serious expositions of the revolutionary politics of Marxism. We learned that they had been engaged in long years of struggle for the restoration of unfalsified Marxism in the international labour movement.

Now, thanks to the great authority of their victory in Russia, they were finally able to get a hearing in all countries.

(James P Cannon)

In Europe, militants trained in Marxism by the old pre-war Socialist Parties, re-examined their theories in the light of the writings of the Bolsheviks and the experience of the Russian Revolution. The Italian Communist Antonio Gramsci has described how he and others decided to:

...devote our energies to the discovery of a • tradition of Soviets within the Italian working class, to seeking out the thread of real Italian revolutionary spirit - real because it coincides with a universal spirit in the workers' international...

he very first decree was a call for immediate peace negotiations.

In proposing the conclusion of an immediate armistice, we appeal to the class conscious workers of the countries that have done so much for the development of the proletarian movement. We appeal to the workers of England, where there was the Chartist movement, to the workers of France, who have in repeated insurrections displayed the strength of their class consciousness, and to the workers of Germany, who waged the fight against the Anti-Socialist Law and have created powerful organisations.

In the manifesto of March 27th we called for the overthrow of the bankers, but, far from overthrowing our own bankers we lie. the bourgeois Provisional Goverment] entered into an alliance with them. Now we have overthrown the government of the bankers.

The government and the bourgeoisie will make every effort to unite their forces and drown the workers' and peasants' revolution in blood.

But the three years of war have been a good lesson to the masses: Soviet movements in other countries, the mutiny of the German fleet, which was crushed by the Junkers of the hangman Wilhelm...news can spread quickly.

The workers' movement will triumph and will lay the path to peace and socialism.

Like Luxemburg, the Bolshevik leaders saw their revolution as merely the first act of the world revolution. They redoubled their work to build a new workers' international on the ruins of the old International which fell apart when its main leaders supported their own ruling classes in the First World War.

In March 1919 the first Manifesto of the Third, Communist International went out to the world:

If the First International presaged the future course of development and indicated its paths; if the Second International gathered and organised millions of workers; then the Third International is the international of open mass action, the international of the deed.

Bourgeois world order has been sufficiently lashed by Socialist criticism. The task of the International Communist Party consists in overthrowing this order and erecting in its place the edifice of the socialist order. We summon the working men and women of all countries to unite under the Communist banner which is already the banner of the first great victories.

In Russia, for the first time, the working people had taken power for themselves, instead of overthrowing one variety of exploiters to the benefit of a new variety as in all previous revolutions. The American revolutionary John Reed described it like this in his eyewitness account:

Imagine this struggle the successful struggle which he had just witnessed, to win one particular regiment over to the side of the Soviet government] repeated in each barracks in the city, in the region, all along the front, all over Russia. Imagine the sleepless Krylenkos [Krylenko was a Bolshevik leader] surveying each regiment, flying from one place to another, discussing, threatening, begging. Imagine the same scene repeated in all the union halls, in the factories, in the villages, on board ship: think of the hundreds of thousands of Russians, workers, peasants. soldiers, sailors, watching the orators, applying themselves so intensely to understand and choose, reflecting so keenly, and, in the end, deciding so unanimously. That's how the Russian Revolution In a declaration announcing the victory of the revolution in Petrograd, Lenin wrote:

Comrades, working people!

Remember that now yOu yourselves are at the helm of Granisci Soldier distributes revolutionary papers state. No one will help you if you yourselves do not unite and take into your own hands all affairs of the state. Your Soviets are from now on the organs of state authority, legislative bodies with full powers.

Rally around your Soviets. Strengthen them. Get on with the job yourselves; begin right at the bottom, do not wait for anyone. Establish the strictest revolutionary law and order, mercilessly suppress any attempts to create anarchy by drunkards, hooligans, counter revolutionary officer cadets, Kornilovites and their like.

Ensure the strictest control over production and accounting of products.

Workers' control was among the st decrees of the new Soviet gime: 1. In the interests of a systematic regulation of national economy, Workers' Control is introduced in all industrial, commercial, agricultural (and similar) enterprises which are hiring people to work for them in their shops or which are giving them work te take home. This control is to extend over the production, stor ing, buying and selling of raw materials and finished product as well as over the finances the enterprise.

Scan page 9

Ictober! s took the power 2. The workers will exercise this control through their elected organisations, such as factory and shop committees, Soviets of riders, etc. The office employees and the technical personnel are also to have representation in hese committees.

3. Every large city, gubernia, and industrial area is to have its awn Soviet of Workers' Conrol, which, being an organ of the Soviet of Workers' , Soldiers' and Peasants' Deputies, must be composed of representatives of rade unions, factory, shop and other workers" committees and —workers' co-operatives. -. The organs of Workers' Control have the right to supervise •production, fix the minimum of output, and determine the cost of production.

5. The organs of Workers' -Control have the right to control mall the business correspondence of an enterprise. Owners of enterprises are legally responsible for all correspondence kept secret. Commercial secrets are abolished. The owners have to show to the organs of Workers' Control all their books and statements for, the current year and for the past years.

6. The rulings of the organs of •Workers' Control are binding on the owners of enterprises and can be annulled only by decisions of the higher organs of Workers' Control.

Another decree put the land he hands of the peasants. T ing October, the power of the hroughout the months followSoviets was extended and consolidated throughout Russia. Through these Soviets the workers and peasants exercised direct power, instead of just choosing every five years who was going to misrepresent and oppress them, as in parliamentary democracy, All delegates were recallable, and in any case had to be re-elected every three months. In the villages, the Soviets were general assemblies of all the inhabitants. The all-Russian Congress of Soviets was to be convened (with the delegates from the local Soviets newly elected each time at least twice a year.

But the new power. openly proclaimed its class character. The propertied classes were excluded from the vote (though Lenin declared that this should not be a general principle) and one workers' vote was given an equal weight with five peasants' votes. All this was considered necessary because the working class was a small minority.

This was the regime which made "Soviets' synonymous with the liberation of the working class. But soon, as the revolution was plunged into war against White Guards (counter-revolutionaries) and invading imperialist armies, military necessity took its toll. The problems were similar to ihose Jean Jaures described in his history of the French Revolution:

When a revolutionary country fights both against internal groupings and the outside world, when the least hesitation or the slightest error could damage the new world order for perhaps centuries to come, those who head that enormous undertaking do not have the time to gain the support of dissenters, to win over their opponents. They cannot make much headway either by engaging in polemic or by compromise. They have to knock down the obstacles, they have to act, and to keep their active forces united, to avoid dissipating them, they make an absolute condition of immediate unanimity among those around them n December 1919 the Bolshevik der Kamenev had said this: We know that during the war the best workers left the towns en masse and this led to a situation in which it was necessary here and there to recreate a soviet in this or that province or town giving it a basis for working properly...The soviet assemblies thus often degenerated as political organisations with people occupying themselves with purely technical tasks. General assemblies of the soviets were rarely held, and, when the deputies met, it was merely to be informed about a circular or to hear a speech...

This was not, however, the ureaucratic dictatorship which talin was to lead later. True, the olsheviks were driven to ever more implete repression against other arties, as those parties Menleviks, SRs, anarchists - suported or participated in armed acons against the workers' state. But verdlov, secretary of the Central ommittee of the Bolshevik Party, ad a staff of only 15 people; and le Party itself, in this period, virtally merged itself into the war ef art to defend the workers' state. The Civil War was won by 1921. ut in the meantime the revoluonary wave which had swept urope in 1919-20 - with Soviet epublics being set up in Hungary ad Bavaria, Workers' Councils ross Germany, factory occupaons and factory councils in Italy - had been defeated. Revoluonary parties on the model of the olshevik Party had not been built in time, and the old Social lemocratic parties were able to ive the capitalist order, The Bolsheviks remained conInced that socialism could not be uilt in one country. But in the fort term they had to maintain the osition conquered by the workers evolution in Russia./ With the isolation of the revoluon in backward Russia and with le exhaustion of the working class. nd the Bolshevik militants after le civil war, came the mortal angers of bureaucratisation, Before his death Lenin tried to orm a bloc with Trotsky against ureaucratic tendencies. In 1923 the rotskyist opposition in the olshevik party began its struggle or workers' democracy, for plannand rapid industrialisation, gainst excessive concessions to the ch peasants and for a revolulonary policy internationally.

923-24 were to be decisive years, what Trotsky later called the Soviet Thermidor, by analogy with the overthrow of tobespierre in the French Revoluion in 1794.

The German Revolution of 1923 vas defeated. The 'Lenin levy' of 1924 swamped the Bolshevik party with 200,000 new recruits, many of them careerists. With a virulent campaign against "Trotskyism', the leaders of the rising bureaucracy, round Stalin, cut themselves free from Bolshevism and Marxism. In 1924 Stalin proclaimed the programme of Socialism in One Country.

So little, however, was Stalinism legitimate continuation of Bolshevism, that Stalin was only able to consolidate the domination of the bureaucracy by the expulsion from the party, the exile or the murder of all the main leaders of Bolshevism, even those who had sided with him against Trotsky. This bloody process reached its height in the Moscow Trials of the 1930s.

This was not, as the academics and the reformists say, the logical development of Bolshevism, but a bloody counter revolution which was not secure until it had drowned Bolshevism and the Bolsheviks in a sea of blood. In October 1917 Trotsky wrote:

Bolshevism is the only possible form of Marxism for this epoch.

The Bolshevik party has shown in action a combination of the highest revolutionary audacity and political realism. It has established for the first time the only relation between vanguard and class that can assure victory.

It has proved by experience that the alliance between the proletariat and the oppressed masses of the rural and urban petty bourgeoisie is possible only through the political overthrow of the traditional petty bourgeois parties. The Bolshevik party has shown the entire world how to carry out armed insurrection and the seizure of power.

Those who propose the abstraction of soviets to the party dictatorship should understand that only thanks to the Bolshevik leadership were the soviets able to lift themselves out of the mud of reformism and attain the state form of the proletariat.

But this is not all. The Bolshevik party was able to carry on its magnificent prac tical' work only because it illuminated all its steps with theory. Bolshevism did not create this theory: it was furnished by Marxism. But Marxism is the theory of movement, not stagnation. Only events on a tremendous, historical scale could enrich the theory itself.

Bolshevism brought an invaluable contribution to Marxism...

The degeneration of the Comintern [Communist International| is most crudely expressed by the fact that it has dropped to the theoretical level of the Second International. All the varieties of intermediary groups Independent Labour Party of Great Britain, POUM and their likel adapt every week new haphazard fragments of Mar and Lenin to their current needs. They can teach the workers 1917: How the workers made a revolution From SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA 60 pence plus 22

Scan page 10

Organise Matgamna September, was one of the key erry Barrett, who died in rank and file working-class leaders during the years of the great labour upsurge of the '60s and "70s.

In the late '60s he was secretary of the London port workers' committee, whose better known leader and public figurehead was the Communist Party member Jack Dash. This was a time when the dockers had the power to choke off supplies to British industry, and sometimes proved it.

In the mid-'60s, when I first encounted Barrett, he was a member of the Communist Party, in transition to the Socialist Workers' Party's ancestor, the International Socialists (IS).

He was the most prominent of a group of militants trying at the eleventh hour to organise a national resistance to the reorganisation of the ports, the so-called "Devlin scheme". We brought three areas out on strike against it — London, Liverpool and Manchester. As a result of these strikes, dockers gained a better deal for letting the reorganisation take place.

But we failed in our main task — to stop the bosses reorganising the ports in their own way, for their own interests, and, ultimately, at the expense of the dockers. Everything that has happened in the docks since flows from that defeat — the massive loss of jobs, the destruction of the dockworkers' legendary militancy and solidarity, last year's abolition of the Dock Labour Scheme.

last saw Terry Barrett a couple of years ago, at Bank underground station on a Sunday afternoon. We travelled together for a few stops, Terry with his loud London voice commending the IRA, more to the rest of the passengers than to me.

I didn't argue with him. It was, I thought, more a matter of rehearsing tribal warcries with an old comrade than anything to do with current policies. It wasn't the place to denounce the IRA, and I'm not sure I'd have engaged him anyway. He seemed not in the best state.

I have better memories of Barrett. In 1967 he came to Manchester during a tour of the ports, attempting to create a network for a rank-and-file organising committee for a national strike against "Devlin"

The situation was complicated in Manchester. Militants had joined the breakaway "blue" union in the mid '50s, but the strikes to force the Dock Labour Board - on which the TGWU had half the seats — to give the "blue" negotiating rights were defeated. A dozen years later, the TGWU had most of the dockers, the "blue" was perhaps a hundred out of 2000 dockers, and there was some non-unionism. • The old rank and file movement had been absorbed into the "blue" — but the "blue" leaders, Joe Hackett, Joe Barry, and others, doubled as a rank-and-file leadership still. What was what was unclear — but they were the people who convened the frequent mass meetings on the croft to discuss events in the port. They did most of the talking.

They had good relations with management. They couldn't negotiate officially, but did, as the saying went, go "up the backstairs" while the official union -widely despised, its officials without influence except when strikes were petering out — went "up the front stairs". The "blue" leaders were good trade unionists, unlike the TGWU leaders, and had real respect. But they were tired, too. They were influenced by Catholic Action, and they hadn't a clue about Devlin.

Mersey dockers teil &G leader jack Jones what they think of him Siss had been sitting about tee ome younger militants - Trotskyneed to fight Devlin. We stirred things up enough to force it to showdown with them at a mass open-air meeting, 1500 to 2000 strong.

A "compromise" proposed to "settle" the difference by electing Harold Youd and myself to "the committee" the "blue" branch committee under another hat - had alarmed them mightily, and they unleashed a flood of tabloid-press style witch-hunting Youd and I were "politically motivated men" (the phrase was Harold Wilson's, from the seafarers' strike) and "communists". We "didn't care about dockers". We were nothing but "homewreckers".

In scenes that could have come from On the Waterfront groups of dockers squared up to each other, and we lost the vote, about two-to-one. But we moved them. They had to move, or next time our vote would be more than a third.

Into this situation, soon after, we brought Terry Barrett. We announced a meeting on the croft, and put out a leaflet inviting people to hear the secretary of the London dockers' committee speak on the reorganisation of the ports.

The "blue" committee responded with a furious campaign. London? There were bitter memories in Manchester and Liverpool from the six-week strike for recognition of the "blue" in 1955. London was under Communist Party leadership, and the CP supported the TGWU. Although CPers were banned from holding office in the TGWU, and they would continue to be banned until backed the GWU against the blue, which was Trotskyist-influenced at the beginning.

LONGOI •WORKCE THOUSE LIC SIX-WECK recognition strike. DocKers had long memories. Good militants had a strong class identity, but a stronger group identity as dockers. There was also a local identity. People would tell us with scorn: "You can't rely on London. Look at them during the sixweek strike"

Barry and Hackett and their friends stoked parochialism and bitterness. That London now represented militancy, and that Hackett and Barry, the rebels of 1955, were now burned-out do-nothing second-string tradeunion bureaucrats, was something we had to argue.

to the dinner time Barrett on the croft, lot of suspicion and some hostility.

atmosphere too.

But he didn't.

that he mere "performance" to psychologically for me, •TOT example. He fighting, disarming, pushing parochialism, 10L capitulating" to it.

Having for classical orator's gambit, "l pause for a reply", he put down the loudhailer and stepped back.

Of course they agreed to hear him! You admire the skills you haven't got - and Barrett's performance left me ruefully wondering whether with more skill we could have avoided some of the dramatic confrontations with "the leadership" Barrett made a fine speech explaining what reorganisation meant, holding out the convincing prospect of a national docks strike in a couple of months' time, and pledging that London would be "solid"

Two months later, Manchester was one of three ports that did "come out" against Devlin. Mare is from the same second memory of Terry period, July 1967.

The first of two national gatherings of rank and file leaders was convened by Terry in London. It was all terribly late. Reorganisation was coming in September, and here we were in July trying to get a minimal national organisational structure in place.

The unions were supporting Devlin. So was the only political party with enough dockers to give a lead, the Communist Party. The Healy group (SLL, later WRP) had strong support in Liverpool and some in Hull, but they were very sectarian, on the verge of going lunatic. They thought literary denunciation of the CP - including Barrett — was more important than organising unity in the actual class struggle.

There was couple of Trotskyists (Workers' Fight) in Manchester. There were lots of militant dockers and a few unofficial committees - but no shop stewards, even (not until 1970). It was all terribly late, but we met that first time with high hopes and in good spirit, around a long trestle table in someone's back garden in Tower Hamlets, shaded by trees from the sun.

Terry presided expansively as "mine host". Until we talked on the train, I'd remembered the scene as Terry's own Vic Turner, one of the five dockers jailed by the Tories 1972, and then released when a quarter of a million workers struck backyard. I even remember him as chairing the meeting, though probably he didn't.

I don't remember much else except the reports from the areas, a member of the Communist Party executive arguing that we should get the best deal we could and accept reorganisation, and having my own awareness of how far we were from being halfway ready intensified. You can talk a lot about "the crisis of leadership", and still be shocked when you see and feel what it means in real struggle.

he rest of my memories of Terry Barrett have a different colour. Yet they too should be recorded, because they deal with something of great importance: Barrett's subsequent political fate.

There were - and are - vast numbers of competent and sometimes inspired rank and file trade union leaders. Not too many of them found their way to the revolutionary movement, though I guess some thousands did. Very few stayed for long. Barrett was representative in a highly dramatised way.

Disillusioned with the CP, he went over to the IS/SWP was then a loose federation. Very middle-class, anti-Leninist, tending to equate Bolshevism with Stalinism and a 'centralised revolutionary organisation with Stalinist or Healyite bureaucratism. The Healyites were held up as typical "orthodox Trotskyists" the logical result of the Bolshevik tradition. All good came from the rank and file. The job of the revolutionaries was to listen and learn "modestly" (in contrast to the Trotskyist idea that we also have something to teach from "the memory of the class").IS lionised Barrett - unmercifully, you might say. He became more and more primadonnaish, and contemptuous of the people who lionised him. Barrett would have been very stupid not to see the lionisation as reflecting the middle-class nature of the group. But he accepted it. For a while.

Eventually Barrett blew out of IS in a huff over some personal slight or conflict -nothing of any consequence politically. He became a fellow-traveller of the IMG for a while, getting exactly the same lionisation from them as from IS, and then, as far as I know, quit politics. He moved from the docks to the car industry. He never, to my knowledge, again played any important role in industry.

The SWP claim he rejoined them recently. But neither the SWP nor Barrett were the same as when they last met...

For a while in the mid-'80s, Terry Barrett was a porter for the Greater London Council in the Ken Livingstone epoch. And there was a cruel symbolism in that too — one of the best militants of the '60s fetching and carrying for the municipal socialists, who cared more for gaining publicity and lobbying the House of Lords than for the working class.

Barrett, in my mind, is the representative of a whole layer of militants who came to revolutionary organisations for a while, and then moved on, often damaged, diminished even, WICH they been aron when chanla strengthened. They could have been the backbone in industry of a movement able to do more than talk about socialism. But because of weaknesses of their own and, more to the point, because of the state of the revolutionary left during the great labour upsurge, they were lost, just as that great historic tide itself was lost.

Barrett remained a socialist to the end. The socialists who continue owe him respect and a debt of gratitude for his struggles. And we owe it to him and the others like him to learn from their fate. When we have built a real revolutionary movement, that will be Terry Barrett's monument.

Scan page 11

aking the labour movement accessible to lesbians and gays ve Bowk 3 Florence Kine Alce Walker mia Marning, Sante winterson Joanmia y Ss By Janine Booth, Wom Officer, National Union Students eter Tatchell's I'new gay equality' outlined in SO 462 was a welcome contribution to a crucial debate.

It offered a thorough examination of repressive legislation against lesbians and gay men. However, believe that it has two major failings. Firstly, it sees lesbian and gay liberation as solely a civil liberties issue; and secondly, it offers no strategy for the building of a fighting lesbian and gay movement.

We live in a society which controls and oppresses everyone's sexuality. Lesbian sexuality and gay sexuality are at the sharp end of bigotry, discrimination and prejudice.

Capitalism attempts to force every person into its only acceptable' sexuality monogomous, married, childrearing heterosexuality. Every other sexuality, every other lifestyle, is subjected to ridicule and disadvantage, lesbian and gay sexuality most viciously of all.

This repression also hits bisexual people, celibate people, nonmonogomous people, unmarried peopie, and peuple raising children outside heterosexual partnership. —lt denies women the right to control our own bodies and fertility, and pushes men and women into stereotyped roles. It shapes and constructs people's sexuality, denying our right to make our own choices.

Lesbian and gay liberation, therefore goes beyond the narrow confines of achieving civil liberties for a minority. It can only come about as part of the liberation of the whole of human sexuality. A liberation that will allow all people our right to decide and express our sexuality as we choose.

The achievement of equality before the law for all regardless of sexuality would be a significant step forward, but would fall well short of real liberation. Lesbians and gay men should aspire to more than just formal equality and respect in a rotten society. We should work for a wholly new sort of society, a socialist society.

Peter advocates the introduction of a co-habitation law, granting legal rights to co-habitees whether lesbian, gay or straight -including such rights as prison visiting, immigration, inheritence etc. While I would welcome the removal of discrimination in the laws governing these rights, 1 believe it is wrong to grant these rights to co-habitees only.

For example, socialists should support everyone's right to immigration and to abode in the country of their choice. A Cohabitation Act would give official state preference to monogomous partnership and co-habitation, which amounts to discrimination on the grounds of sexuality!

In a similar way, it is blatantly discriminatory that only heterosexuals are allowed to marry. However, the solution is not necessarily that lesbian and gay couples should be allowed to marry (although that would be preferable OUT AND PROUD to the current situation). Far better would be for the institution of marriage to be abolished altogether (as a legal contract, not as a cultural or religious act), and for all the privileges accompanying it to be open to all.

Peter's strategy does not address the need to build a powerful movement to win liberation. No matter how well-intentioned the Labour Party (and it seems not even to have good intentions any more, change will not come from above. Liberation cannot be granted from high, but will be created by mass activity and struggle. The liberation of sexuality will come only with increased understanding of sexuality, people's awareness raised by their involvement in struggle.

The labour movement must take lesbian and gay struggles seriously. It is not even coming close at the moment, and needs to change its attitudes and actions. Sexuality is not even thought of as a political issue in much of the Labour Party (including sections of the lett). It needs to be brought onto the centre stage of socialist politics.

The Labour Party and trade unions have to be made more accessible to lesbians and gay men - both can be inhospitable and are often completely uninhabitable.

The biggest change the labour movement must make is to commit itself to fight for very well-worded policies. There are some very wellworded policies around, but precious little action. The labour movement must fight alongside the lesbian and gay community, and involve lesbian and gay people in fighting as part of the labour movement.

A promising new initiative is "Labour Must Deliver' , launched recently by the Labour Campaign for Lesbian and Gay Rights.

Lesbian and gay socialists also need to play our part in building a strong self-organised lesbian and gay movement. What exists at the moment is sizeable, and it is committed. But it is fragmented and politically weak. We can build this movement in campaigning for positive demands (including legal Socialist Organiser No. 465 page rights such as those advocated in Peter Tatchell's article), defending. and developing cur communities, setting up autonomous lesbian and gay groups in workplaces, colleges and Labour Parties, and widening political debate.

So, perhaps this is another 'new strategy for lesbian and gay equality. Political rearmament, transforming the labour movemen and building a mass lesbian and gay movement.

----- pull-quotes -----

AGAINST THE TIDE

Petrategy for lesbian and P strategy for

za Alther Warhol (JohreRechy

keryD Eller

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 465

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →