The stark choices facing the Israeli left
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Victim of the Temple desires of the big majority Israeli ruling class.
But also, for you and for many of your friends, the possibility of war has brought a new pleasure which you are not ready to admit, even to yourself. The fact is that you like wars - "inevitable wars", of course. You like uniform, you like the appeals and the preparations, you share the enthusiasm which runs through Israeli society when the smell of gunpowder tickles the nostrils. And, above all, you like the feeling of national fraternity which characterises the run-up to war.
Your distance from the national consensus was imposed on you. You have emphasised that fact many times, and it is true. It was not you who were changing, but rather the political apparatus which had begun to support options, or more precisely phraseology, which no longer reflected everybody's feelings. You have been forced to say: "This ideology is not my ideology, your methods are not my methods."
Are you hesitant? Are you torn? In fact, you had already taken your decision before the Gulf crisis. You wanted something to happen so that you could rediscover the warm embrace of the consensus and feel anguished about it. Once again — "shoot and weep"
The truth is that you have shown this anguish, this "shooting and weeping" , this position of criticising but not deviating too far from the sacred consensus, since the start of the intifada. Even when you protest against government policy -and I do not doubt the honesty of your protests — you feel obliged to set limits from the start.
And you define that limit, that frontier between what is allowed and what is forbidden, between agreement and opposition, above all to show, or to try to show, that you are not outside the consensus, and you do not belong to the left which is outside the national camp;
you are not among those who con sciously and whole-heartedly place themselves outside the national consensus.
* the Gulf crisis you have been at pains for your true position not only to be stated but also to be visible. You have aligned yourself with the Israeli warmongers. You have joined the crazy racist chorus denouncing the "Iraqi Hitler". You have not found the courage for a single word of criticism of the hypocrisy of the American government, which invaded a sovereign state in Central America just a year ago, or the cynicism of the leaders of the state of Israel.
To leave no shadow of doubt about your return to the bosom of the national consensus, you have officially broken links with your Palestinian friends who, as was to be expected, did not see things in the same way as you. That official separation, and the arrogant statements that accompanied it, were in your eyes more important than the problem of lining up with the positions of Sharon and Geula Cohen [ie. the Israeli hard right].
The statement of divorce was meant to cleanse you from any suspicion of lacking patriotism or of cooperating with the enemy. All that and much more.
I know that you are a polite person and if you have used insulting expressions to Feisal al-Husseini and Sari Nusseibeh [Palestinian leaders], whom you were visiting only yesterday, there must have been a reason for your rude behaviour: you wanted not only to join the national chorus, but also to sing all its songs, the bar songs, the crude songs, the racist songs. You are nostalgic for the slogans of 1956 and 1967; you're dying to chant We'll get you" and Saddam is waiting for Arens" [Moshe Arens, the Israeli defence minister].
Sometimes I think that you leave the consensus only so that you can have the joy of throwing yourself back into its arms...
The arrogance of Yaron Yossip Sarid or Eleazar Granot [left Zionist leaders] consists in this, that they demand from Sari Nusseibeh, Feisal al-Husseini OT Hanan Ashrawi what they do not demand of themselves: to cut themselves off from their national unity and their national aspirations. They respond as Zionists, or at least as people who are loyal to the interests of faithful and "sober" Zionists, who are loyal first to their Jewish brothers and only second to the moral and humanist values which they claim to defend. "Love me more than you love your brothers" say the representatives thẻ Zionist left to the leaders of the Palestinian community, "but, as for me, I love my brother above all else.
That is where our paths diverge, my friend of the Zionist left. My first loyalty is not to whomever was born of a Jewish mother or a kosher convert; nor to a flag, a national anthem or a tribe. My first loyalty is to the universal values in which I believe, and the realisation of which is the only way to peace and security for my people. I feel no kinship with a right-wing Israeli, and for sure I am much closer to a Palestinian fighting for their national rights than to an Israeli who thinks that their fundamental loyalty is to the tribe.
Not only do I find it not a problem, if necessary, to be outside the national consensus, but I even feel that my place is there, and I want my place to remain there. Being outside the national consensus is not the result of having no choice. It is my choice.
For many years we, the anti-Zionist militants, have been on our own, outside the consensus. You and your friends have always been in the front line of those who called us traitors and placed themselves on the other side of the gate. The attacks against us, in the '60s and '70s, served the same function your current attacks on Feisal alHusseini and Sari Nusseibeh: an alibi to demonstrate your patriotism and your adhesion to the national consensus.
But I have news for you, my Bare no longer alone: in your are no longer alone. In your camp, in the Zionist left, in the Hashomer Hatzair kibbutz movement, there are already thousands of men and women who are disgusted by the consensus, who are not afraid to support those who refuse to serve in the army, who are tired of Shamir's and Sharon's wars, who hate Rabin and are beginning to sympathise with the Palestinian children fighting for their freedom.
You are beginning to be in a minority in your own camp, as the recent decisions of the youth movements of Ratz and Hashomer Hatzair show. Many of your friends. are beginning to understand that there is no more room for "shooting and weeping" and for being a loyal opposition in the framework of the consensus. There is a choice between life and death, between peace and war - and it is also the choice between Feisal alHusseini or Geula Cohen.
That does not mean that they accept what Feisal al-Husseini, or Yasser Arafat, says, as the law of Moses from Sinai. On the contrary, they remain critical but in the framework of identification with the Palestinian struggle for national liberation, which is also the struggle for Israeli-Palestinian peace.