Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Militant and the CPSA en wasted years

Socialist Organiser no. 465, 9 November 1990 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 1,926 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

As government departments are privatised and turned into Agencies and thousands of civil service posts relocated alongside job cuts, flexible working practices and flexible pay deals the very structures on which the civil service unions have been built are threatened.

Thatcher's plans and their consequences are not secret to the Civil and Public Services Association (CPSA), the union of low-paid typing, clerical and secretarial grades. Yet over the years, various union leaderships have allowed the Tories to strike blow after blow against its members.

The current right-wing National Executive, who have been in power since 1988, have deliberately chosen not to lead a fightback against Thatcher's grand plan for the civil service.

Yet the CPSA has the largest Broad Left in the country, able to drum up thousands of votes at election time. So how, in a youthful and historically militant union, has such a Broad Left allowed CPSA to reach a state of affairs where the leadership are refusing to fight and the rank and file seem unable to?

The answer lies in the grouping who dominate the Broad Left -the Militant. A look at their role in the CPSA over the last ten years reveals exactly why the union is in the sorry state it is today.

n the late 1970s/early '80s the Campaign for Union Democracy (CUD) was set up with the aim of replacing the block vote system of elections with individual ballots, held and cast at workplace meetings. The campaign was set up the Broad Left, including Socialist Organiser), and supported by a cross section of the union.

The arguments for the new system were overwhelming -politics and policies would be argued in every workplace throughout the union as CPSA members were given, for the first time, the democratic right to elect their own leadership.

Militant opposed CUD's aims, believing that electoral success for themselves would be more difficult to achieve. And they campaigned hard against getting rid of the block vote. Why? Because the Militant would rather lead the CPSA on an undemocratic basis than be forced to argue politics in every workplace and thus begin to build up a genuine Tank and file movement able to win on a democratic basis.

CUD was successful, despite Militant's pitiful attempts, and individual workplace balloting was introduced. Yet when the right wing won the first elections under the new system, the Militant argued for the return of the block vote!

Meanwhile, the rest of the left began the job of building a left base in the union and extending CUD's victory by fighting for and winning the right of members to elect the CPSA's senior full-time officers.

Today, Militant consistently oppose Socialist Caucus's call for the yearly election of all full-time officers. Militant argue for fiveyearly elections. Why? Because they are not interested in genuine union democracy and, on a more sinister level, tear their own candidates would not get re-elected in yearly For Militant, the prime aim is for Militant supporters to lead a passive membershp for as long as possible. Thus they are obsessed with electoralism rather than democracy, winning strikes or building an active and genuinely broad rank and file movement.

Our executive is got a President who supports the dreaded Militant tendency.

*But they're all piss and wind as tar as i can see. They never wanted this strike, and they've given us no real support up to nowThat was the comment of a CPSA picket in Birmingham to Socialist Organiser (2 December December 1982.

The CPSA executive for 1982-3 had a Broad Left majority. But that Broad Left executive tried three times to end the strike with a compromise — twice failing, eventually succeeding. They did nothing to help spread the struggle. Kevin Roddy, a Militant supporter and then President of the union, made one of the attempts to end the strike in person.

The basic argument of Militant and their co-thinkers was that this was the wrong time and wrong issue for a fight. Better keep the union's powder dry for the 'big one' - the 1983 pay fight.

In this way they subordinated the class struggle to pre-ordained schemas worked out by a pre-ordained leadership. Instead of seeing the job of socialists as starting from and helping to develop the real struggles of the rank and file, they demanded that the rank and file fit into the schedules of the socialists.

80 DHSS workers in Oxford, nearly 1000 in Birmingham, struck to demand increased staffing. The background was increased pressure on the workers from two directions: both from the lengthening dole queues (meaning more work), and from the Tory government's determination to cut civil service Tories strateg the al strike numbers.

On October 27 Kevin Roddy proposed in Oxford a deal which gave Oxford and Birmingham (between them) 52 extra posts temporarily — in return for CPSA nationally ending its overtime ban and ban on casuals, and promising no strikes on cuts or staffing. The deal was rejected unanimously in Oxford and 427-26 in Birmingham.

On November 19 the CPSA NEC again recommended the same deal - only slightly changed. Rejectin was unanimous again in Oxford, 520-23 in Birmingham. The CPSA NEC began to do something, calling a one-day national strike on December 3.

But at the CPSA Broad Left conference on November 27, a motion to condemn the NEC for recommending acceptance was defeated. The motion, moved by Socialist Organiser supporter Penny Barnett and backed by the Oxford strikers, also called for extending the strug gle to an all-out national strike.

On December 9 a national meeting of CPSA DHSS delegates voted for a proposal from Oxford to recommend an all-out national strike from January 17. A CPSA special conference was planned for January 12. The strength of the struggle was making itself felt despite despite the Broad Left.

But then the government retreated slightly - and the NEC used the Christmas break to sink the struggle.

Just before Christmas the NEC voted unanimously to accept a new offer, increasing the temporary extra posts to 100 and withdrawing the demand that the CPSA end the overtime ban and promised no strike action. The NEC cancelled the strike call and the special conference and ordered the strikers back to work.

Evidence was that top TUC and Labour Party leaders were central in engineering this deal. The CPSA Broad Left leaders went along quietly.

Militant went on to throw away opportunity after opportunity to fight the • A disastrously half-hearted y and a failure to recognise sility to organise an all-out in the DHSS ended in defeat for the Newcastle shift-workers in 1984, when Militant once again controlled the Executive.

The magnificent nine-month struggle of the shift-workers was wasted, as was the tremendous opportunity to link with other strug gles — all because Militant refused to escalate the strike.

In 1986/87, a Militant-led DHSS Section Executive Committee committed perhaps their biggest blunder — a blunder which was to be a turning point for the fightback in the DHSS and which opened the way for the right wing to seize control not just of the DHSS, but of the whole union.

In 1986, a Militant motion to DHSS conference called for a fight against the Fowler Social Security Reviews - designed to reduce benefits and cut jobs in the DHSS. A strike against the Fowler Reviews was deemed "political' and therefore illegal under the anti-union laws.

By 1987 the Militant-led DHSS Executive had ditched their own campaign because they refused to fight the Tories' anti-union laws Despite the strong groundswell amongst DHSS workers to fight, the cowardice and political bankruptcy of the Militant meant that fight never took place.

Thus the Tories were able to implement the Fowler Reviews and all they implied for the job security and working conditions of DHSS workers.

In 1987 the Militant DHSS Executive went on to sell out DHSS workers who took strike action against Limited Period Appointments (LPAs) — ie. long-term casuals - brought in by management to implement the Fowler Having encouraged over 70 offices to take some sort of strike action and promised them a national strike ballot, Militant then lined up with the right wing to call off such a ballot. Members had made sacrifices for nothing and were left feeling demoralised and disillusioned.

Reviews or the fight against LAs, but their election onto the National Executive Committee. When Militant won a majority they spent the next year fighting boardroom battles with the right wing instead of leading struggles on the ground.

YTS was a big issue, yet the Militant leadership wasted the opportunity of leading a battle. 1987 conference mandated the NEC to ballot totally disillusioned by a so-called 'left' leadership who spouted fighting rhetoric while in opposition but failed to deliver the goods when in power. Militant and the Broad Left were smashed in the 1988 NEC and DHSS SEC elections, and have not controlled these two main bodies of the union since.

Since 1988 the biggest threat facing civil servants has been Agencyisation — a prelude to privatisation. When it was clear the right-wing NEC - by now firmly in powerwould not lead any sort of fight, Socialist Caucus supporters launched the Branches Against Agencies (BAA) initiative.

BAA aims to unite all members who wish to fight Agencies through a branch-based campaign. The whole idea of BAA is to cut across the political divisions of the highly factional CPSA and bring together members of all political factions and non-aligned members. BAA infuriated the Militant.

They condemned it, set up their own campaign, attempted to take over BAA, and essentially did everything except build it. With over 70 branches supporting BAA and a successful launch conference, BAA is the best hope we have of fighting Agencies.

Yet for the Militant, anything that is not the Broad Left, ie. not controlled by them, is to be opposed. Militant are not interested in organising the rank and file because they fear they would not control such a movement.

Militant's behaviour over BAA clearly showed they would rather sabotage a fight for members' jobs, wages and conditions than support any campaign they do not control. M to the development of a ilitant have been a block broad, fighting rank and file in the CPSA.

Their obsession with securing leadership positions for themselves at all costs has led the Militant to sell out workers in struggle, refuse to lead fights that do not fit into Militant's "scheme' and behave undemocratically within the Broad Left.

They have argued for undemocratic policies within the union, they have even gone so far as to use the bosses' courts to attempt to secure union positions (as when John McCreadie took the CPSA to court over the General Secretary election in 1986), rather than campaign and fight for justice amongst ordinary union members.

Militant's role in the CPSA is a sorry one. As such, CPSA members have little faith in the Broad Left whose active membership remains the domain of many left groups. When faced with the might of the Tories and an undemocratic, toadying right-wing leadership, the fact that the CPSA does not have a mass, fighting rank and file is a disaster. Yet even now, faced with our most crucial battle, Militant still would rather sit back and hope to get elected than fight.

Scan page 7

AE Socialist Organiser No. 465 page 7

----- pull-quotes -----

O-upposed to be 15 left wing: We've even

How not to lead the left

or Militant, the big issue of F Reviews or the fight against

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 465

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →