VITEURS ANG Will Thatcher gazump the left?
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
WLLLUME LooKikdren Europe: Tories seize the nationalist flag International workers' solidarity - the way forward Aro play the British nat- s Mrs Thatcher attempts ionalist card for the upcoming general election, the Tories are split on Europe — perhaps badly split.
By contrast, Labour 1s united around Neil Kinnock's new-found Europeanism. The anti-CommonMarket left is almost a spent force. The long, long saga of the left's struggle against the EC now culminates in this comic opera absurdity: the most deservedly hated, and certainly the most vicious, Tory prime minister for half a century is stealing the left's clothes!
There have always been rightwing, or just plain maverick, Tories whose attitude to the EC has paralleled that of the left. In the '60s they were quite powertul, their attitude given wide currency by the Express group of newspapers. But this is different! This is Thatcher!
Now what is the left going to do? Sing along in the British nationalist choir, even under the baton of conductor Thatcher? Some of them will, unfortunately.
Others, however, will realise that a political posture which leads to an absurd de facto political and ideological alliance with Thatcher needs to be rethought. Radically.
The choice is clear and sharp. Either the left will continue burrowing itself into reactionary ir1 lads is also the emanciparun: herman rises-0t Karl Man Socialist-Organis Box 823, London X15.40 Newsdesk: 071 639 7965. erts: fist pod Editar: John O Mahony Published by WL Publications Lid, PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Printed by Partobelle CP Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Articles do no: necessanly reflect the views of Socialist Organiser, and are in a personal capacity unless otherwise stated relevance and political invisibility, in a corner of the political ground on which Thatcher is pitching her tent; or it will now, very late in the day, face the truth, that it has been wrong on this question for 30 years. To continue as at present is to add wilful self-wounding of a suicidal scope to the immense difficulties the left faces anyway.
uropean unity was already the -cause of the left at the beginning of this century.
The banner of the United States of Europe was raised during the great European capitalist bloodbath of World War One by socialists such as Leon Trotsky, who diagnosed the cause of the war in the outmodedness of the old European nation states. As long ago as 1923, the Communist International raised the slogan "For a Socialist United States of Europe"
The defeats of the working class, the destruction of the revolutionary workers' movement by Stalinism, and the consequent rise of ultrachauvinist fascist movements to power in Italy and Germany, aborted the prospects of the revolutionary working class winning European unity and putting its own stamp on it. World War 2 was a consequence of that failure.
Like the First World War, it arose because the productive powers of capitalism had outgrown the nation state, and in the first place the German state. Hitler set out, as the Kaiser had set out a quarter century earlier, to unite Europe by way of German military conquest. Unlike the Kaiser, he succeeded between 1940 and 1944.
The reformists prefer to forget it now, but a number of prominent pre-World-War-2 European "socialists" went over to Hitler in 1940 and after, partly because they believed Hitler had solved the problem of European unity.
After the war, the European nations were liberated - and immediately the question of European unity again presented itself. National antagonisms had been intensified and rubbed raw by the war; Germany had been levelled and divided. The bourgeoisie sought advance on a new basis.
They had a rough historical parallel and model in the process of uniting Germany in the 1850s and '60s by way of a customs union which prepared the way for the dramatic accession of the King of Prussia to the imperial throne of a united Germany after Prussia's victory over France in 1871.
Leaving the political sovereignties in place, they created a Common Market, first for coal and steel (1951), then for everything else (1958). From that has grown, under the exsting nation-states, a capitalist economic unity which has by now irreparably undermined the separateness and sovereignty of those nation states. Though there is a long way to go yet, and there may be unforeseen shocks and tremors along that way, the movement towards a federal Europe now seems inexorable.
t is a capitalist Europe, that is, a Europe of wage slavery, of bourgeois law, of crying absurdities like food mountains in a world where millions are dying of hunger.
But most of those things were there in the old Europe - and, in addition, national antagonisms which led, twice in the 30 years before 1914 and 1945, to the destruction of much of Europe and to the deaths of tens and tens of millions of people.
We should want socialism? Yes, we work for socialism, but the alternative now to the ramshackle EuroDean is noy soci lism geonors harve pean socialism, nor socialism in the - not euroindividual countries like Britain.
The left used to argue - before Mrs Thatcher's discovery that the EC is a socialist conspiracy against Thatcher has stolen the left's slogans the sort of Britain she wants - that the EC would stop them taking socialist measures if they had power in Britain. If that happened, then a left-wing government would repudiate the authority of the EC in the name not of little Britainism but of socialism - and it would appeal to the workers of Europe to support it by following the left-wing British example. But throughout the long "debate" on Europe that was never the immediate alternative to the EC. The alternative then and now was a capitalist Britain.
In any case, a socialist-ruled Britain would not survive long unless the workers of Western Europe, at least, quickly followed the British example; and a socialist Britain -in the sense of a stable socialist system of working-class rule - inconceivable except as a unit in a European socialist system.
The working class least of all has an interest in going back to the divided bourgeois Europe which the bourgeoisie itself has now abandoned.
Our interest lies in cleansing the EC of the historical paw-marks of the bourgeoisie. Thatcher is right when she points out that the EC is grossly undemocratic and bureaucratic; and so is the left when it says the same. But the socialist conclusion is not a reversion to the reliance on the old sovereign national parliaments — which do not now, and cannot, control the great Europe-wide economic machine of which the nation states are more or less subordinate parts. The socialist answers is to fight for a fully accountable sovereign democratic European parliament.
Westminster cannot fight the "faceless bureaucrats of Brussels" not unless Britain withdraws and declares a siege economy; only a fully democratic Europe-wide political system could. That is what the left should fight for.
That is the way out of the present cul de sac the left finds itself in. In the language of the Trotskyist movement, the demand for an accountable European parliament is not counterposed to socialism: it is part of the "democratic programme" of socialists.
Nor is it necessarily counterposed to the fight for a system of workers' council democracy ("soviets" in the original meaning): in a great revolutionary working-class upsurge the workers might quickly go beyond the bourgeois parliaments, but that does not exclude fighting to expand bourgeois parliamentary democracy now.
In World War 1 Trotsky asked socialists do if the German Empire unified Europe?
He answered that socialists should then try to transform that German militarist empire into a European republic. Probably he underestimated the force of the nationalisms that would have been pitted against the German European empire - but the approach was identical to that of Marxists from the beginning.
When the capitalists created hellish factories, the socialists did not say "back to the handicratt system" - not even when the workers we supported broke the machines in righteous rebellion. We said: seize and use the new system of production, cleansing it of exploitation.
Right now we can reasonably hope to take the working class with us, and unite with the European workers in a fight for a programme of democratising Europe, and in the first place democratising the EC. If the left continues to advocate rolling the film of modern European history backwards we can only hupe for deepening isolation from the European working class and from all progressive thought and aspirations, or else to be a distant satellite of a demagogic, populist, Thatcherled chauvinist movement.
Irs Thatcher is certainly not intent on bringing Britain out of the EC.
She is driven by a mixture of electoral opportunism, unpurged gut chauvinism, and the uneasy awareness that Britain - the Britain she has shaped - is out of step and way behind the comparatively enlightened bourgeoisies of Europe on social welfare, civil liberties, trade union rights, environmental legislation, and many other things She is aware of a "left wing"
Europe, which is the opposite of the Europe the left has feared would Turn to page 5
Scan page 4
er