Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Friday picket Stoke. Thursday 1 November. Anti-poll tax…]

Socialist Organiser no. 464, 2 November 1990 · scan p. 14 · about 1,259 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Friday picket Stoke. Thursday 1 November. Anti-poll tax picket of Oxford Magistrates Court.

om onwards.

Thursday 1 November. How to stop the Gulf War. Speakers: Iqbal Sram and Socialist. Organiser. 8pm Manchester Town Hall.

7 November. Anti poll of Fenton Magistrates 1.45pm onwards.

Friday 7 November. Why socialists should be in the Labour Party. Speaker: Paul McGarry. Workers Liberty meeting at Liverpool Institute. 12.45pm.

Saturday 3 November. demonstration. Cardiff Saturday 3 November. March tr support oil workers. Assemble. 11am at Allison Place, Newcastle. Rally at 12.30 at Newcastle Poly Students Union Saturday 3 November, Launch of Charter of El Rights tor black and migrant workers. 9.30 - 5pm at Conway Hall, Red Lion Square, Holborn, London.

Sunday 4 November. Women Against War in the Gulf. 2pm, Durham Road, Community Centre.

Monday 8 November, Socialists and the Labour Party. Socialist Organiser meeting. Essex University. 6.30pm.

Monday 5 November. 'Conscience and the law and Social progress', Speaker: Tony Benn. 7pm at London School of Economics, Holborn London.

Tuesday 6 November. Oxford Poly Labour Club meeting to oppose the Gulf War. 1pm.

Tuesday 6 November. Israel and Return, a magazine our complaint is that produced by a group of mainly anti-Zionist Jews, has "undercut" and "undermined" the End the Ban campaign around Socialist Organiser.

Not so. All we have done is point to the contrast between your attack on the right's intolerance of dissent within the Party, with which we agree, and your own record on the subject.

It is a fact that Socialist Organiser supporters at NUS conference either supported the ban on Return or were completely indifferent to it.

Far from it being any odd couple of Socialist Organiser supporters who signed a petition demanding that we be banned, the persons in question were two of your NUS Executive members, including the Women's Officer. The petition in question was used to create a witchhunting atmosphere against Return, which directly led to the ban in question. Despite this your two supporters refused to withdraw their names from the petition and Socialist Organiser supported them in this.

The demand for Return to be banned came from the Israelifunded Union of Jewish Students, for whom the presence of anti-Zionist Jews is, quite understandably, intolerable, given their claim to represent all Jews. Their reaction was no different to that of the military in Israel to books and pamphlets they disagree with. They sought a ban. In this situation you sided Write to SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA with Zionist versus anti-Zionist Jewish and Palestinian students.

The Union of Jewish Students are not banned in colleges, nor has Return ever supported moves to that effect. It is nothing but guilt by association to suggest that "those who share the views of Return to one extent or another" have done so.

If you dispute any of the above, then I have but one question to ask. Why have the four Socialist Organiser members of NUS Executive done nothing to reverse the ban on Return?

We oppose the ban on Socialist Organiser that that good friend of Zionism and the Israeli state, Neil Kinnock, is Yours in solidarity Tony Greenstein Editor Return Jill Mountford replies That Return did was fabricate a false political profile for SO on the basis of a plain lie.

In Return's faked picture, SO was in favour of banning Return at the conference of the National Union of Students, and we were therefore hypocrites when we appealed on general libertarian principles for support against the Labour Party's ban on us.

For serious principled democrats who believe that "freedom is always for the one who disagrees" - that is, that the issue is only tested when it is a question of freedom for those you detest - support for SO against the ban could not be conditional on SO itself consistently opposing bans. Consistent democrats are none too plentiful, though, and very scarce indeed in wide stretches of the left.

Return's story about SO provided those who wanted one with an excuse to do nothing about the ban. It served, for ex ample, Phil Kelly, editor of Tribune, as one way to distance himself from SO at the End the Ban rally. At the rally, John O'Mahony nailed Return's lies there and then: the underground whispering campaign in a number of Constituency Labour Parties probably did real damage.

Return's sabotage of the Ban campaign was motivated by unbridled and political hostility, Its lies helped license and excuse other who have political differences with SO to give full vent to their malice and hostility.

Lies? Yes. For years SO has campaigned against the dominant *ban your opponent if you can" culture in the National Union of Students. And it has not been a popular stand.

We have said with every collective voice we have that we are against banning Return — though we will fight Return's politics as a source of confusion and, often, lunacy. We did not vote to ban Return. No representative of SO signed the petition for banning Return: around 100 student supporters of SO at the NUS conference refused to sign it!

To argue that because (wo SO supporters (one, not two, them, on the NUS Executive) signed the UJS petition, SO has collectively turned itself inside out on the question of banning would be tendentious to say the least - far-fetched to the point of silliness.

But to go on from that and to spread it as an alleged matter of fact, as an account of an event already in the past, that SO supported the ban on Return decreed by NUS president Maeve Sherlock - that, Mr Greenstein, is a plain and deliberate lie.

Like so much of the politics of Greenstein and his friends, it is probably generated by hysteria. But it is no less a lie for that. Nor is Greenstein's activity to undermine the End the Ban campaign anything other than plain scabbing.

Yes, Jewish student societies have been banned in certain col. leges. For the better part of two decades, it is the Jews in NUS who have been witch-hunted — by the hysterical "anti-Zionists" like Greenstein, and the mindless militants of the Socialist Workers' Party. Sherlock's ban on Return was a result of shifts within the Stalinist-tinted Kinnockite faction of Labour Students, which has often been among the "anti-Zionists"

NUS conference discussion on the Middle East has become very emotional and viciously factional. People tend to take sides broadly, and then not bother too much about the details.

The sole element of truth in Greenstein's picture of SO at NUS conference is that SO people would instinctively have been on the side of the Union of Jewish Students, who are normally the victims in the conflicts, and were the victims or bullying at that conference.

"Free speech" for Return was a slogan on the banner of those - the Socialist Workers" Party, for example — who normally make free speech and rational discussion about the Mid. die East or Israel impossible, and who routinely harass and bully young Jews. To focus on the issue of principle is difficult in such an atmosphere.

The remarkable thing, therefore, is that only two SO people signed the Union of Jewish Students petition, and perhaps a hundred refused to.

As 1 understand it, Sherlock imposed a one-off ban on Return, for that conference on ly - for the last few minutes the conference, to be exact. There is no general ban.

----- pull-quotes -----

WRITEBACK DearS.O., You've done it agoun!! Your recent article on the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 464

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →