David Lnch's freak show
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Would scrimp and save; some found it too much And some could scarce afford to feed the childre One day my English book went missing; later, wl The teacher searched the desks, we found it, new Shamed, blushing and trembling: he was beaten. TV Belinda Weaver reports Twin Peaks' (BBC2, Tuesdays)
avid Lynch hasn't been he's already repeating himself. "Twin Peaks' looks like 'Blue Velvet' tidied up for television. It has the same small town setting, the town's economy is based on lumber, and nothing is quite what it seems.
It's soap opera, but aci ording to the hype, it's superior so not your run of the mill Dynasty' Books BJ Siddon reviews Paradise' by Virginia Andrews (Fontana, £3.99)
brief for this week's review was to find and read an immensely successful *international bestseller' on a romantic subject. You know, the sort of two-inch thick paperback sold at station booksellers and produced from the handbags of female commuters.
I began by selecting a bookshop away from my normal patch, and chose 'Gates of Paradise' by allocating points for number of pages (492), position in bestseller We bought our books in Free State schools Penny by penny the poor paid. My mother In flowery wallpaper. The small thief hovered And me, I sat and saw him cringe and beg.
A nervous clever granny's boy, an orphan Of eight or nine, Anthony Cullinan, Who boasted to me once he'd eater an egg.
Property has rites, and children's rights are I redden still for what we did to him. or Dallas. That may be a shame, people got a kick out of Alexis and JR. So far, no-one in "Twin Peaks' has that larger-than-life quality, that low-down, nasty streak that made characters like Alexis compulsively watchable.
The first episode of "Twin Peaks' was watchable, but it dragged a little. It needs revving up.
Part of the problem may be Lynch's sensibility. "Twin Peaks' seems to be striving for weirdness; the oddness of the characters seems imposed rather than organic. It's as if Lynch decided small towns were innately weird and thus every character had to be quirky.
But he's got it all wrong. Small town people aren't weirder than others; they're often less weird than city dwellers who can get away with more because of big town anonymilist (8th), availability of large print (yes), new title (yes), and design of front cover (truly vile with raised silver lettering). By all these simple tests Gates of Paradise' emerged as a truly popular book.
Now all I had to do was read it.
The opening lines were not promising:
*For as long as I could remember, the only person I could share my deepest thoughts with was Luke Casteel Jr.
*I wanted to...look into his soft dark sapphire eyes forever and ever and tell him what I really felt, but the words were forbidden. He was my half brother."
To cut a long story short, our heroine (Annie) is in love with Luke, and vice versa. Their love is forbidden because of their "blood relationship" • Annie is the daughter of Heaven and Logan, and Luke the son of Heaven's sister Fanny and Logan. But he is named after Heaven's father Luke, who Sean Matgamna ly.
Small towns tend to ostracise odsuggests.
In 'Blue Velvet', Lynch was saying that the weirdness is all underneath; that places and people whe seem normal aren't. But hardly anyollc Twin Peaks' seems normal; Lynch has stacked the town full of oddbods from the start, like the woman who carries around a small log. It's gratuitous.
Maybe Lynch feels that soap opera demands oddballs, and so he's sticking to the conventions of the genre. To me it seemed he was papering over cracks. The story so far is thin. A prom queen is murdered, another girl who has been raped and tortured turns up, traumatised? The FBI investigates. was married to Leigh (daughter of Jillian) who died in childbirth. Fanny's half brother Drake has been raised by Logan and Heaven as Annie's brother. Drake is the son to Luke Sr and his second wife. Finally, there are Tony, Stacie (killed in a car crash), and Troy. Tony was married to Jillian and Troy was presumed dead but was really alive all along. When Heaven and Logan are killed in a car crash, Annie goes to live with Tony and finds out that Heaven was really Tony's daughter (and thus he is Annie's grandfather) and Troy is Annie's father so Annie and Luke Jr can get married after all.
It's easy to laugh. There's plenty to laugh at (492 pages to be precise). Opening the book at random produces gems of prose such as ...because she was cursed with a dumpy body, a small bosom and hips so wide they made her look like a church bell, she was doomed to be a domestic servant, always cleaning and polishing in someone else's house." Or: " ..l kept trying to imagine the first time my mother had seen [the room]. She had been living with Cal and Kitty Dennison, the couple who had paid $500 to her father for her."
I confess to having got hooked about page 200, even though (as a reader of detective stories) 1 had guessed ages before that Troy would turn out (a) to have been alive all along and (b) to have been Annie's father. No other resolution of the plot is possible.
There is no sex in the book, and only one real kiss — between Annie and Luke when they still think they are related. The best character is undoubtedly Fanny, who wears leather mini-skirts and has 'younger men" as lovers. Even she turns Instead of getting on with it, Lynch has spun things out with che weirdo stuff, as if he wasn't sure what else to do. That's where the show sagged - in the filler bits.
Otherwise, it had a bit of snap, though the high school scenes were a bit torrid and overheated, like cartoons rather than soap opera.
"Twin Peaks' so far has nothing of 'Wild at Heart"s gratuitous violence and cynicısm, and there is some humour in the scenes between the FBI agent Cooper who plays Sherlock to the town sheriff's Watson. Cooper is genuinely strange; he has a disconcerting quality that keeps you interested.
But if Lynch plays circus master to a freak show in the next few weeks, instead of getting on with the story, "Twin Peaks' may hit a trough. споввевдо зівт699г Had R HER NEW BESTSELLER respectable, moves into the big house, and learns how to inspire loyalty from the servants.
So it is no mean feat to become interested in such a book. It certainly wasn't the quality writing what done it. I've seen better sentences on the back of a bleach bottle. It wasn't the plot what done it either, because the plot was guessable after the first paragraph. The characters were hardly gripping - how can you take seriously people called - Drake, Troy or Heaven? I think what got me in the end was the hope that someone would reveal why Heaven had been sold to Cal and Kitty Dennison for $500. No one did.
Don't buy this book. Don't buy it if you are facing a long train journey and the only alternative is a copy of Socialist Outlook which you've read before.
In years gone by 'bestsellers" consisted of lurid broadsheets sold at the prison gates on the morning of a hanging. Bestsellers have declined since then.
weary from the war, are deserting the front in droves. Soviets spring up in the major cities, but the Bolsheviks are in disarray.
Lenin is searching for a way back into Russia. Out of the blue, an offer of a train and safe passage through Germany is made via an intermediary. The proposal originated from the German High Command itself, hoping that Lenin will lead Russia out of the war.
Lenin lays down strict conditions before accepting the offier, so that he can not be branded as a 'German agent'. He approaches Mensheviks. anarchists, and Bundists (Jewishnationalist socialists) inviting them to join the train.
The scant news that reaches Lenin tells of the worrying drift of the caretaker Bolshevik leadership, (Stalin and Kamenev) towards support for the Provisional government, unity with the Mensheviks, and even support for Russia's 'defence' in the war.
The film begins to go off the rails. once the train journey starts. In valks inessa Armand, a Bolshevil leader, rumoured to be Lenin' former lover. The story increasingly becomes centred around a sort of menage a trois between Inessa, Lenin and Krupskaya (Lenin's wife), only what we see is really the burning embers of a relationship that took place years earlier. Instead of 'steamy' flashbacks, we're treated to long, lingering stares.
The rest of the Bolsheviks, even Zinoviev, who was Lenin's closest comrade at the time, are reduced to virtually ordinary commuters. We're shown none of the feverish debates you may expect about the situation of dual power developing in Russia. No inkling is given that Lenin is preparing for a major battle within the Bolshevik Party to swing it around to the prospect of the working class seizing power.
The film did have the redeeming feature of encouraging me to go away and read some serious stuff on the period. It's a shame about the silly love triangle. Great revolutionary upheavals that lead to the formation of the first workers' state in history deserve better treatment than this.
Scan page 14
Socialist Organiser' and 'Ret Socialist Organiser No. 464
----- pull-quotes -----
dballs, to keep them in their place. They don't get the free ride Lynch