[Books Ruth Cockroft reviews £8.75) Kagarlitsky s book…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Books Ruth Cockroft reviews £8.75)
Kagarlitsky s book, b sed on articles he wrote for for dissident circles over the last lew years, combines an CAn. eyewitness account of momentous events with picture of the development of Kagarlitsky's own political thinking.
That in turn reflects the growing sophistication of the new workers movement itself.
Kagarlitsky begins his story with the 'Popular Fronts' (PF). The PFs were huge spontaneous rank and file organisations formed to ensure the reform process was not jeopardised.
During the Hot Summer" of 1988, sections of the bureaucracy were making ominous noises about not 'giving up principles The liberal intelligentsia and the population al large feared an almighty clamp down and the return of old style Stalinism.
The unofficial and informal groups faced persecution and petty bureaucratic obstacles. They grew quickly into a force that could def! he authorities and call huge stree meetings and vast demonstrations.
The Moscow Popular Front was dominated by socialists; their flag was red, green and yellow, symbolising socialism, ecology and freedom.90 T9bpol Kagarlitsky chronicles the rise the popular movement and the new found confidence of the Soviet people.
The 19th Party Congress' which was televised across the whole of the Soviet Union played a massive part in politicising people and raising their expectations. That conference backed Gorbachev's proposals for a Congress of People's Deputies.
The proposed congress, rathe than dampening the popular movement, acted as a catalyst for further protest action. democratic elections but he PFs did not boycott the worked to ensure that dissident views were represented.
Their organisation ensured Yeltsin's 90% vote as well as other significant victories against the conservatives, not least the broadening of their own base. Socialists in the Moscow Popular Front fully supported this tactic, in contrast to the Polish socialists who had boycotted the clections in 1989 and as a result had become marginalised Kagarlitsky:
Kagarlitsky was not unaware of the dilemmas of working within the Popular Fronts. There were severe organisational difficulties because of the hostility of many liberals to "centralism", and the socialists were extremely conscious of their lack of support from the organised workers' movement.
The thousands of workers who had been prepared to rally to the Popular Front's banner on the streets during the Congress were los, and the socialist groups had failed to consolidate any form of organisation.
As well as this, in different national regions the Popular Fronts were open to the political domination of chauvinist nationalism.
Kagarlitsky can barely hide his disappointment when *the Estonian miracle, a huge well organised movement which was seen as a turning point in the liberation movement's fortunes, proved to owe its popular sucess to nothing. other than Party patronage.
*The Popular Front was engendered by the patently sympathetic attitude to it of a significant section of the party and managerial apparatus, which strove to gain greater autonomy from the central authorities in Moscow", In addition the estonian and other Baltic Fronts contained a highly suspicious attitude to their own Russian minorities.
The result has been the harmful fragmentation of the movement on nationalist lines, and many Russian speaking minorities finding it necessary to form their own separate organisations.
Where the bureaucracy was unable to influence the nationalist popular fronts, it came into sharp conflict with them. Accusing the fronts of 'bourgeois nationalism", the conservative bureaucrats in the the borderlands unleashed a vicious counter-attack on the popular movement.
Demonstrations were violently broken up by the police, special Iroops were used to break the resistance of the strikers sympathetic to the Armenian PF, and in Georgia a movement demanding secession from the USSR was violently put down with great carnage.
The paralysis of the bureacuracy at the centre in the face of the fragmentation of the periphery led to civilian carnage over Abkhazian national rights and 10 terrible tragedies in Armenia. This unleashed hatred, arising from nationalist discontent, gives us nightmare glimpse of Eastern Europe's possible future. TUnian alone the lines ofi he disintegration of the Soviet its deep national antagonisms has been met either by increasingly ineffective force or by the paralysis of the bureaucracy.
Unable to use its traditional method of political intervention, terror, the bureaucracy sits inert as the Empire crumbles around it.
Meanwhile the broad based PFs have been unable to overcome the ideological constraints of nationalism and have fallen into espousing the interests of their own local burcaucracies.
By 1988 Gorbachev was using the slogan of a law governed state while legislating for an undemocratic constitution. This *legalisation of bureaucratic tyranny" again. exacerbated the nationalist crisis. It further reinforced the process of turning the Popular Fronts into narrowly Striking Soviet miners 1989 nationalist movements.
-But gi perestroika's T failure and Gorbachev's increased desperation shook up a whole new social layer of the population - the working Tessence signaled the rise of he 1989 miners" strike in La new opposition at the same time as the nationalist opposition was involved in armed clashes.
"The prospects the East are no democracy and liberal market as Kagarlitsky calls it, market Stalinism The crisis for the bureaucracy had become particularly acute.
Workers" independent organisation promised a new way forward, the possibility of a path leading away from national conflict and disintegration. On the whole the two movements have not crossfertilised.
Miners organised workers* committees which involved all nationalities in the workforce and became the actual centre of popular power. The official unions belatedly supported the strike, but they were kept ou of negoriating and the formulation of the strikers demands. Party officials became involved in the strikes in order to confine them to the level of cconomic demands.
The demands of the majority of strikers did remain economic but the movement as a whole inevitably became political, for example, demanding the right to free trade unions. Miners occupied the squares of city centres for days -debating and discussing ideas.
The strikes were finished and on the whole undermined by local strike committec leaders. But, as Kagarlitsky points out, the real weakness was that "there were not only no free trade unions but also no unified organisational centre"
In the spring of 1989 Kagarlitsky was central to the formation of Sotsprof, and later the Socialist Party. Through the Popular Fronts and their glaring weaknesses. Kagarlitsky had begun lo understand that a powerful socialist organisation was needed. capable of drawing behind it broad strata of workers and of beginning 1o fight in a revolutionary manner- The miners" strike in the USSR was one of the biggest spontaneous workers' movements which had crupted into strike action in postwar East European history. In some regions a revolutionary crisis and dual power existed, with workers committees taking on board the functions of the local soviets In the midst of the now familiar chorus from the right wing that socialism is dead, it is as well for us to remember this fact.
Vorkuta miners demanded the separation of Party bodies and state power. Gorbacher, quite righily interpreting this as a demand for his resignation, facilitated an anti-strike law.
Undemocratic laws have been imposed by Gorbacher during times of greater and greater crisis. The moves from a command cconomy into a market economy has led to a energed a new corrupt bureaucratic bougcoisic* extruded fro the old nomenklatura.
Kagarlitsky gives us an warning:
*The guardians of old ideas can talk about the restoration of capitalism, but the fact is that this social milieu is incapable either of creating from within itself a modern western style bourgeoisie or of building developed capitalism. The most of which it is capable of is forming a dependent. poorly developed society with a parasitic ruling class combining all the negative features of both Eastern and Western models."
The prospects for the East are not healthy liberal bourgeois democracy and liberal market regulation, but a Third-World style cconomy, slavery and poverty. or. as Kagarlitsky calls it, a market Stalinism Kagarlitsky also warns that with Gorbacher now administering the •Lebanonisation" of Soviet society, the prospect is for civil war, pogroms and rampant national chauvinism.
Our movement, the movement of the working class, has emerged as a a powerful force just once since the breakdown of old Stalinism - in the miners strike and the political demands raised there. But the size of that morement and the formation of new independent structures give us a glimpse of the possible alternative to GorbacherYeltsin.
*An alternative has yet to be created. Before us are hard times. But before us is the future. We live. we act, and that means we have hope"* Kagarlitsky's words should be a reminder toucall that in these eithes! of bourgeois rejeiing about the end of history" (in their favour)! the working class, the gravedigger of Stalinism and capitalism. is | still an immensely povertul force
Scan page 13
FE 000 E LEE* The inhabitants of Twin Peaks list Organiser No. 4 By Ward Geoff • rowsing in the video shor I came across The Seale Train', a film starring Ben Kingsley as Lenin.
The video dramatises the period from Lenin's last weeks in exile in Switzerland (March 1917) to his arrival at the Finland Station in Petrograd, Russia.
The February revolution has toppled the autocratic Tsarist monarchy, establishing a provisional government. Soldiers,
----- pull-quotes -----
"Farewell Perestroika' by Boris Kagarlitsky. (Verso,
healthy liberal bourgeois
regulation, but a Third-World styk economy, slaver and poverty, or,
Crisis front? whìch has huge social