Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Fighting against Il odd

Socialist Organiser no. 464, 2 November 1990 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 1,589 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

enamoured of the idea of studying often complain that many of the classic texts are impossible to read. Books about historical events usually presume detailed knowledge of those events. Unfamiliar jargon is common. Trotsky, Lenin, Marx and Engels write beautifully with both anger and humour. They write about the "big truths' - relevant today, but hardly easy reading.

James P Cannon is different. He was 'one of us' in that he is not a historical figure studied at Oxford, and he never led a great revolution or even a mass movement. He knew Trotsky, and he visited Russia in the 1920s as part of the American delegation to the Comintern.

But he was also part of a small group of revolutionaries, forging their way through strikes, party building, faction-fights and antiwar struggles. These events did not take place in semi-feudal Russia — remote from our experience - but in modern America, as familiar as "mom's apple pie'.

The 'History of American Trotskyism' is the story (complete with anecdotes) of the break from Stalinism and the founding of the American Trotskyist movement. The chapters of the book are 12 informal talks given to young comrades.

James Cannon and 2 others (Abern and Shactman) were expelled from the American Communist Party for "Trotskyism' in 1928. Cannon had been one of the leaders of the party, and had attended the 6th Congress of the Comintern on its behalf. Entirely by accident Cannon was issued with a copy of Trotsky's "The Draft Program of the Cl: a criticism of fundamentals?

Trotsky was in exile in Alma Alta, after being expelled from the Russian party. He had sent the document for discussion and the bureaucracy had failed by a series of mistakes to suppress it completely. The Canadian Maurice Spector also got a copy. "We let the caucus metings and the Congress session go to the devil while we read and studied this document. Then I knew what I had to do and so did (Spector). Our doubts had been resolved... we made a compact... that we would come home and begin a struggle under the banner of This book is about the struggle to set up and keep together a group of revolutionaries against overwhelming odds. As Cannon says: "It was not too promising a struggle from the point of view of numbers. The three of us... Abern, Shactman and myself - felt pretty lonely as we walked down to my house to lay plans to build a new party that was to take power in the United States.

At first the new party oriented to the Communist Party, calling itself the Communist League of America (opposition) and trying to win the educated workers away from Stalinism. The organisational difficulties were enormous - no money, no office, few members. The new party also faced opposition both from capitalism and from the Stalinist bureaucracy which was prepared to go to any lengths including violence, to silence its critics.

When Stalin announced his left turn' and the first 5 year plan ir 1929 he cut much of the grounc away from under the feet of the Left Opposition. These seemed to be the very things the Trotskists had been calling for. Cannon and the CLA were presented as arguing about minutiae.

Many workers were still euphoric about the success of the revolution in Russia. Compared to the conditions of the American depression the Stalinist propaganda promised paradise. Only the Trotskyists didn't believe Stalin's lies.

In the same way, today's Trotskyists campaigned for freedom for Eastern bloc workers — and now point out, amid all the capitalist clamour, that the greater liberation has yet to be won. The long called-for revolutions are victorious - and still the Trotskyists complain!

"At a time when tens hundreds of thousands of elements were beginning , to ook toward the Soviet Union.. while capitalism appeared to be going up the spout; here were these Trotskyists, with their documents under their arms, demanding that you read books, study, discuss and so on. Nobody wanted to listen to us.

But the book is not all depression and hardship. It is also heroic and inspiring. Cannon's description of the New York hotel workers strike is fascinating. This is (to my mind at least) an almost foolproof set of instructions on how to conduct a strike and how to lose one.

"As the hotel workers began to turn towards unionism in a big way, this handful of Trotskyists found themselves in the midst of a swirling mass movement." As the campaign for unionisation of the hotel workers gathered strength, the tiny The degeneration of the Communist Party egan when it abandoned the perspective of evolution in this country, and converted itself into a pressure group and cheering Russia & which it mistakenly took to be the custodian of a revolution in another What happened to the Communis Party would happen without fail to any other party, including our own, if it should in this country, as the realistic perspective of our epoch, and degrade itself to the role of sympathiser of revolutions in other evolutionists should indeed sympathise help them in every way they can. But the est way to do that is to build a party with a confident perspective of revolution in this country. Without that perspective, Communist or socialist rary Dees Is name. It ceases to be a help and becomes a T BERET TEDIOUS TIL WUEL HIRE pither.

1F6A P Cannon party threw all its resources into the struggle. They won the respect of the workers by their obvious committment and organising ability.

every worker in the industry on strike saw 'the Militant' (no relation) every other day popularising the strike, giving the strikers side, exposing the bosses lies, and offering some ideas on ways of making the strike successful". At the height of the strike, Jame Cannon spoke, to over 10,000 workers at Madison Sq gardens.

Tragically, the strike was lost, primarilv by one BJ Field, a party "intellectual' put in place by the CLA to help lead the workers. Field like so many before and after him fell victim to professional government 'negotiators'. He began to consider himself above the party and above the workers.

*Instead of organising the militancy of the ranks from below, and thus coming to the negotiations with a power behind him - the only thing that really counts in negotiations when the chips are down - he was moderating the militancy of the masses and spending all his time running around from one conference to another with these government sharks, politicians and Labour skates who had no other purpose but to knife the strike"

To the shock and surprise of the American labour movement, the CLA expelled Field in the middle of the strike. They didn't keep quiet, and draw away from him, failing even to denounce him in their paper, nor did the Trotskyists follow Field into selling out the strike.

Derek Hatton is helping the police with their enquiries into property speculation in liverpool. The whole of the left themselves open to the accusation that Hatton was-working to their instructions. The whole of the left will suffer by the association off corruption.

By contrast, the CLA went on to win a huge strike in Minneapolis -the whole party having learnt the lesson provided by BJ Field's behaviour.

The story of the Minneapolis Teamsters strikes is the story of how, exactly, to win. The chapter blueprint for action today. For on the Minneapolis strikes is those who think Trotskyists are against women's organisations there is a description of the Women's Auxilliary - not making soup but "running round and protesting and scandalising the bosses and city authorities" and distributing the strike paper - the Daily Organiser.

The final chapters of the History deal, with considerable humour, with the fusions and faction fights which recruited large numbers to the Party in the 1930s. As the Communist Party became increasingly bureaucratised, newly radical youth and workers were drawn to the Socialist Party. The Cannonites, now the Workers Party resolved to join the Socialist Party to recruit these radicals. In order to do this, they had first to negotiate with the Socialist Party leaders. These people too are recognisable in and around the left today. I can only give a flavour here:

*There was Murry Baron, a bright young college boy who... got a job as a trade union sificed ... He lived considered important that he continued to do so. At the same ume, he was dabbling with the task of leading a revolutionary movement like someone who takes up a hobby on the side" . or "Norman Thomas... who as Trotsky very well explained called himself a socialist as a result of a misunderstanding"

The negotiations were succesful, and the Trotskyists spent a year inside the Socialist Party and left to form the Socialist Workers Party in 1937. At this point the story takes a break. It is continued in 'The Struggle for a Proletarian Party. and Trotskv's 'In Defence of Marxism'.

*The History of American Trotskyism', once started is as hard to put down as a good thriller. It is full of people we know - either as comrades or enemies. and situations we have lived through. But it is not a novel or a piece of historical journalism. Like all the texts of our movement it is a guide to laction and a çall to revolution.

Scan page 12

HE CULTURAL FRONT Boris Kagarlitsky's Soviet chronicl Socialist Organiser No. 464 page 12

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 464

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →