Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why Thatcher can steal the clothes of

Socialist Organiser no. 464, 2 November 1990 · scan p. 10 · about 1,063 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

The modern industrial trade unions began in 1888/89 with a series of great strikes. The most spectacular of these was the London Docks Strike of 1889, led by the Marxists Tom Mann and John Burns. But the first was the strike of the "Matchgirls', the grievously exploited women workers who made safety matches for Bryant and May in the East End of London.

The 'Matchgirls', who succeeded in getting better conditions, were moved to go out on strike after reading an exposé of their terrible conditions in Annie Bessant's journal 'The Link'. It must be one of the clearest proofs ever of the value of left-wing agitation! Karl Marx's daugher, Eleanor, was one of the organisers the 'Matchgirls' strike.

Matgamna t looks like Mrs Thatcher intends to play the British nationalist card in the upcoming election.

And she must have some hope left that she will after all get the benefit of a "Falklands effect" after a war in the Gulf. Labour is to be presented as a "European fifth column" the party prepared to "sell out Britain"

As Mrs Thatcher tries to make the Tory party into the party of rearguard action against any more steps towards a united Europe, Labour has become the European party - still divided on the issue, but much less seriously than the Tories are.

And what an irony there is in that for a Labour Party led by Neil Kinnock! For most of his political life Kinnock has subscribed to the antiEuropeanism which has been the dogma of the left - Stalinist, Trotskyist, and reformist alike, with little distinction - for over 20 years. He probably didn't change his mind - he just put his mind, along with his political conscience on this and on everything else, at the disposal of the opinion pollsters, the image-makers, and the public relations operators. • A lot of erstwhile Labour Party opponents of the EC have quietly gone along with Kinnock. A principled anti-EC stance in the Labour Party is now the preserve of the anti-Kinnock left, people like Tony Benn and Dennis Skinner. Outside the Labour Party it is the — now muted - slogan of the revolutionary left. (And that is a measure of the political crisis of the left! But [go ahead of myself.

The anti-EC left is now trapped in impossible contradictions. If it were just a matter of a Kinnock betraying the anti-EC cause, then he could be denounced and campaigned against. There could be hopes of a future favourable swing of the pendulum.

But Thatcher is the problem! Thatcher has stolen the anti-EC clothes of the far left! Of course they can denounce Thatcher and question the sincerity of her antiECism. In a Commons exchange with Thatcher on Tuesday 30 October, Tony Benn did that. Thatcher was just an electoral opportunist, not someone who could be relied upon for serious work against the Common Market, he said.

A lot of Trotskyists who spent decades in an identical posture towards Stalinists carrying through anti-capitalist - but not working-class - revolutions could tell Benn that's a pretty hopeless posture against someone as entrenched and powerful as Thatcher. Resistance to the full absorption of Britain into a united Europe is now Mrs Thatcher's cause for as long as she wants it.

That is one reason why the revolutionary left — once the most strident and fervent in the anti-EC camp — is now almost silent. But there are surely other reasons.

The bourgeoisie has taken Europe to within hailing distance of federal unity and a United States of Europe. The collapse of the Stalinist empire in the East has opened up the prospect of European unity of a scope unseen since the division of the Roman Empire late in the 3rd century AD. In its own way and with the characteristic consequent evils, the bourgeoisie is carrying through one of the historic goals of the left.

The idea that this can now be undone and Europe returned to the madness of economic and political nationalism - the seedbed from which erupted two world wars - is increasingly difficult to take seriously. The idea that it should be undone and European history rolled backwards is impossible to argue from any socialist or progressive point of view.

Facts are imposing things; and burgeoning facts like the developing European capitalist unity eventually overwhelm, displace and leave behind those can't keep pace.

It is more natural for a right-wing party like the Tories to be in Thatcher's present vein than for the left to be nationalist, as it has been on this issue for so long. Except that it is the British left that has opposed the growth of European unity, and the capitalist Right which has promoted it!

It is a recurrent pattern in history. In 1848 the bourgeois democratic programme for a united Germany was defeated. Germany was united nevertheless, by the Junkers and the Prussian monarchy, in their own way. That the bourgeoisie has gone so far towards realising the old democratic and working-class programme of European unity is not difficult to explain or understand: it is a product of working-class defeat.

European unity is being realised in this way by the bourgeoisie because of the defeat and prolonged eclipse of the genuine left.

But a situation where the Tory party can steal the political clothes of the left in general, and of the far left and even the Trotskyist left in particular — that needs some explaining! It is another product of defeat — a product of ideological defeat and erosion.

It is part of the topsy-turvy state of politics in a world distorted and misshaped by the cancerous growth! of Stalinism. The parameters of left and right have been shattered and overlaid, creating crazy patterns.

The concerns, attitudes, mores, and moralities, the definitions of good and bad and right and wrong, of a ruling class — and moreover a ruling class of singular hypocrisy, one which all the time feverishly pretended to be what it was not -became mixed in with the goals and hopes of working-class socialism. Ideas that were authoritarian and therefore right-wing were legitimised and licensed in the thinking of That, I believe, is the root of the left's disarray on this issue. I will return to the argument next week.

----- pull-quotes -----

Matchgirl strike of 1888

AGAINST THE TIDE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 464

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →