Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Should socials

Socialist Organiser no. 464, 2 November 1990 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 2,602 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

An Iranian socialist fri im Socialism and Revolut on argued for no support for Iraq under any circumstances:

Saddam! Down imperialism!"

" he nresence of the US the Gulf shows that, 17 years after the end of the Vietnam War, the balance of forces has turned in favour of imperialism.

It may be temporary, but the relationship of forces has changed because of Gorbachev's reforms, and Eastern Europe going over to world imperialism.

Trigger-happy generals will be going around the world against working-class movements.

Why the Gulf? Because it is the most sensitive area of the world. There is still the Palestinian upsurge. There is the fight between the Israelis and the masses of the Arab world. Imperialism is in the area.

But in the future we will not have on the one hand the USSR and on the other world imperialism; we will have the two super powers working hand-in-hand against the working This is more important for the US than whether Saddam stays or falls; and it indicates what sort of campaigns we must organise.

We have to mobilise public opinion against US intervention and the change in the relation of forces. If we just campaign in defence of Saddam and against war, then our campaign will be limited; and if war doesn't happen our campaign will collapse. think US imperialism does not intend to topple Saddam, and revolutionary Marxists should not defend Saddam.

During Lenin's period the Comintern said that if an oppressing nation attacked an oppressed nation then we should defend oppressed against oppressor. Some people start from that point and say we should defend Saddam.

The Iraqi working class is suppressed by Saddam's dictatorship. But the national minority, the Kurds, have arms, they have occupied whole areas. They have been fighting for many years to topple If we ask the Kurds to support Saddam against US attack, they will not accept it. It is absolutely out of order for them. They are fighting Saddam Hussein, and even if imperialism attacks they will still go on attacking.

They see Saddam Hussein as an agent of imperialism. They fight imperialism by toppling Saddam. Support for Saddam will not be accepted by the majority of the people in the region.

or the Comintern under Lenin - the situation was utterly different. Then, the national bourgeoisie in the colonial and semi-colonial countries was objectively anti-imperialist. The working class and the national minorities were not lined up against the national bourgeoisie.

The Comintern said that because the proletariat was not strong and the national bourgeoisie was anti-imperialist, we should defend the national bourgeoisies against imperialism, though we do not defend them politically.

Today that situation no longer exists. Countries like Iraq are armed to the teeth, with the agreement of world imperialism. Imperialism has not been stagnating for the past 60 or 70 years; things have changed.

In the early years of this century the interest of world imperialism was predominantly to export capital across the world. In order to export capital they were very interested in control of the internal economies of those countries. They had close links with the states that they established in these regions. The states were pre-capitalist and dependent on imperialism.

After World War II the interests of imperialism changed. They are not exporting finance capital, they are exporting machinery. They paved the way for a capitalist mode of production in the countries which had been colonies or semi-colonies. There were land reforms to bring the peasants to the towns and create a working class, and by giving loans they created bourgeoisies in those countries.

In order to satisfy imperialism, the states which came to power were not the same as the states at the turn of the century.

States like Iraq are politically independent of imperialism, though economically they are very much linked to imperialism.

Such regimes have used anti-imperialist slogans for many years and it is not just Khomeini and Saddam. In the 1960s the Shah of Iran was "anti-imperialist" The Iranian monarchists say that it was imperialism which brought down the Shah!

These states are economically linked to imperialism, but politically they can be anti-imperialist. They can burn American flags. They can occupy American embassies. They can invade Kuwait.

American imperialism is not anragonistic to those states. Yes, they sometimes punish them. But if they do not have a better alternative ready, they will not topple the regimes.

Regimes like Iraq's are allies of imperialism, although they may have some differences. So revolutionary Marxists cannot go to armed Kurds saving: defend the Iragi regime against US imperialism. We have to choose between defence of a reactionary regime against imperialism and support for the mass of workers who are armed. The best slogan we can put forward "Down with imperialism! Down with Saddam!"

In Iran, during the occupation of the US Embassy, the majority of the revolutionary left supported the Khomeini regime. The Khomeini regime however was not in opposis. tion to imperialism. Imperialism never attacked Iran. Some of us said that we should not defend that regime - politically or militarily. We should side with the working class and with the national minorities. We were right.

In Saddam's case the situation is similar. He has become "anti-imperialist" because of the internal political and economic crisis. The "anti-imperialism" is not genuine.

The implications of the line of "defending Iraq" is to have a united front with those who have the same slogans. Today, in Britain, those who are saying "Down with imperialism and long live Saddam" are the agents of Saddam.

We would have to have a united front with the police agents of Saddam Hussein! That is the logical conclusion. We would have to have a united front with them against the Kurds.

Le Pen in France has the same position: long live Saddam, down with imperialism. If you are serious about "defending Iraq" you logically must line up with people like Le Pen.

We must say: Down with Saddam! Down with imperialism! That way we can attract thousands of Kurds to the campaign.

despite Martin Thomas argued th we should say "Troops o of the Gulf! Iraq out of Kuwait!" - but also be prepared to defend Iraq's national rights against invasion raq is a sub-imperialist power — that is a capitalist power of the second or third rank -which is trying to enlarge its sphere of influence and the wealth of its bourgeoisie, to establish itself as something of a regional power. It has done this by seizing Kuwait.

American imperialism is intervening with military force to defend its interests. That, again, is something we have seen in many parts of the world in recent decades.

Those two aspects lead us to the basic position: US and British troops out of the Gulf! Iraq out of Kuwait! We do not side with US imperialism and we do not side with Iraqi sub-imperialism.

So far we have agreement with Socialism and Revolution. We have agreement against a lot of other currents on the left, for example, However, there are also aspects of the situation which are new compared to what we have seen in recent decades. Should we be prepared to defend Iraq agair he Gulf is probably the one area in the world which is absolutely indispensable to the US, because of its oil reserves. The US has a new freedom to inarea which is economically vital.

Those two new. features lead paradoxically, to phenomena reappearing that seemed to have been relegated to the past.

A lot of leftists talk about the whole of the Third World as neocolonial regimes. I agree absolutely that it is an incorrect definition. A country like Iraq, for instance, is politically independent.

US and other imperialisms have operated through an imperialism of free trade" - an imperialism which depends not on colonial or semi-colonial control but on economic power.

But they are not prepared to do that in the Gulf now. Whoever controls the oil reserves has a huge power in the world economy. he United States will not be able to gain advantage over this power just by economic means. tr In the Gulf, now, the US is concerned about political control. That is why the capitalist press says it is not just a matter of getting rag out of Kuwait, but of crippling Iraq so it can do nothing similar in the future.

They want an Iraqi government which will make a treaty with the Us, and the US have forces on the spot, in Iraq or nearby, to enforce the treaty. And it America has that sort of control over Iraq, it will not be just to stop it using chemical weapons. It will be to enforce the policies of the United States on Iraq.

The US wants a permanent military presence in the area, to subjugate Iraq (if they can) and to put down other revolts in the region.

So the conflict started as a conflict between a sub-imperialism, struggling for elbow-room, and the dominant big imperialist power, the United States. But it has gained other dimensions. That is why we have argued in Socialist Organiser that it may become necessary, as the situation develops, to argue for the right of the Iraqi people to selldetermination. _We do not think that socialists should start supporting Saddam Hussein now on the grounds that perhaps, in the future, Iraqi self-determination will be threatened. det WE dal OUT tiol rg qui De

Scan page 9

ever defend Iraq?

the trotskyists arguing TOr ine quite ukely — into an attempt oy defence of the Soviet Union in the the USA to subjugate Iraq and to 1930s were forced to work with the establish the United States as the agents of the KGB. Our united dominant power in the Arabian Gulf crisis:

do believe that selfmination for Iraq may become I issue. buld like to deal with some of objections. Does supporting F-determination for Iraq mean orting Saddam Hussein? No. vould support Iraq despite SadHussein. analogy from the history of movement may help. In the s the Trotskyist movement us› argue for the defence of the R - on the grounds of nalised property, not national s, but the same basic approach Saddam We support Iraq's national rights despite Saddam Hussein.

Nines Saddam Hussein represent a bourgeoisie like the colonial bourgeoisies at the beginning of the century? Quite clearly, no. The Iraqi bourgeoisie is much more powerful and more developed.

But the right of nations to self-determination does not depend on how developed the bourgeoisie is.

There is no threshold of capitalist development above which a nation loses its national rights.

tun Every contlict between capitalist forces, or capitalist and Stalinist WinL that no ınink we al agice mat we savulu have supported the Vietnamese against American imperialism. Yet look what the Vietnamese did with their victory: they established miniimperialist domination over Laos and Cambodia. So you could say we should not have taken sides in Vietnam: the, conflict was inter-imperialist. That would be absurd — not because there was no element of imperialism in the Vietnamese bureaucracy's war, but because that this century. The occupation of the US Embassy in Iran was just slotted into what Trotsky wrote about China or what Lenin wrote about national revolts in 1920I agree that slotting these events into the mould of 50 years ago is no way to analyse them. But to slot what is happening now in the Gulf into the mould of the confrontation between the US and Iran over the Embassy siege, into the mould of the Iran-Iraq war, or into the mould of the South Atlantic war, is equally wrong.

Just as we attempted to analyse what was new at the time of the South Atlantic war, or at the time of the Iran-Iraq war, so also we should analyse what is new - and, paradoxically, also very old — in the Gulf.

We should say: Down with imperialism! Down with Saddam! We should also say: the national rights of Iraq may be under threat and the national rights of the peoples of the Arab world may be under threat. We should support those national rights against US imperialism and its allies.

For independent class action Summing up by Martin Thomas "here is no single force. or called "imperialism"

There are different imperialist powers. For decades past, many on the left have talked about "imperialism" as a single power, because the US has been the strongest power and the second imperialist power, the USSR, has been one which most of the left did not recognise as imperialist. But it was a wrong way of seeing the world.

The usual conclusion drawn was 1o support any regime which came into conflict with the US, because being anti-US was automatically "anti-imperialist" . The conclusion drawn here has been that Iraq is just another expression of the same all-embracing "imperialism" , so there is no real conflict. It is equally wrong.

We should support the working class and the Kurds against Saddam Hussein. We would oppose Saddam Hussein, and work for his downfall, even while supporting Iraqis national rights against the US.

Iraq we would Socialist Organiser No. 464 page 9 Hussein has suppressed the people. He has drawn Iraq into disastrous wars. We cannot rely on or look to Saddam's armies to defend Iraq. The workers should be armed. The soldiers should be able to elect their own officers.

For the defence of Iraq's national rights, as for every other issue, we look not to Saddam Hussein or anyone like him, but to the independent mobilisation of the working class and its allies.

No full-scale war Summing-up by Socialism and Revolution think there will be no full-scale war. If there is a war, it will be a short one, a few strikes on the main industrialmilitary targets.

The aim of imperialism is not the occupation of Iraq but to build a presence in the Gulf region. That is the aim. There is a minimum — one per cent - chance of a war in the immediate future.

What if there is a war? Obviously we will call for the downfall of, imperialism and the removal of the troops from the region. At the same time we will call for the downfall of Saddam. Self-determination for the masses of Iraq can only be through the downfall of Saddam. There is no other wayWhy shy away from calling for the downfall of Saddam? Because America is saying the same thing? It is not the same thing. We are calling for the troops out of the region. We are not calling for the Americans to topple Saddam, we are calling for the working class to topple Saddam. The central question which will open the way for a fight against imperialism is the downfall of Saddam.

Self-determination can only be posed when American imperialism makes. Iraq its 52nd state. But it won't. Even if they attack they will replace Saddam with another bourgeois state.

We must call for the downfall of Saddam, now, before an attack. If there is an attack we are for the mobilisation of the masses against the bourgecisie, for a workers and farmers government.

The calls for self-determination are very vague, not related to the objective situation. We want the working class to topple Saddam, not US imperialism.

Speeches from a London Socialist Forum meeting, Monday 29 October.

----- pull-quotes -----

US has no alternative

tervene, because of the USSR's disarray, and it is intervening in an

forces, involves an element of inter- imperialist conflict. For example, d

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 464

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →