Will the new socialist paper back Labour?
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-11-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
the Labour Party Socialists he biggest controversy at AGM was over the planned Socialist Movement newspaper.
The paper is to be launched next March, probably as a fortnightly, with a pilot issue this month (November). People involved in the project wanted Labour Party Socialists (which is an autonomous offshoot of the Socialist Movement) to sponsor the paper; other LPS activists were worried about whether the paper would call for a Labour vote in every constituency, or instead hint at support for Greens, or Welsh or Scottish nationalists, in some areas.
Some left Greens, and left Welsh and Scottish nationalists, are involved in the Socialist Movement; and some people in the Socialist Movement who are members of no party look more to such parties than to Labour.
There was a sort of compromise at the AGM: the people involved in the paper promised that they would press for it to call for a Labour vote everywhere, and the others agreed to sponsor the pilot issue. The debate will obviously continue.
At the AGM, Reg Race put the case for the paper. "It's likely that Marxism Today is going to go down the hatch. New Socialist has already gone. The New Statesman is in serious difficulties. There is a strong need for a clear non-sectarian voice on the Labour teft which is going to promote the issues that Labour Party Socialists believes in.
"We want to discuss how to get issues about the Labour Party into that Socialist Movement newspaper between the LPS officers and the Socialist Movement officers over the next few weeks."
Keith Veness said that the Socialist Movement had made a "potentially disastrous" decision that the paper would not necessarily call for a Labour vote in every constituency. "If we, as LPS, are seen in any way to give aid or comfort to people who are not campaigning for a Labour vote, that will be disastrous.
"The Socialist Movement is a broad debating forum open for anyone to come along. That's its value, that's why I've supported it. Once you try to codify that in fixed positions, there are real problems."
Davy Jones defended the paper. It could be invaluable for Labour Party Socialists — a paper we could sell much more broadly than Labour Briefing, Socialist Organiser or any of the other left papers.
"The Socialist Movement doesn't have a position on the general election. But it has started a discussion. The officers of the Socialist Movement are proposing that it calls for a Labour vote in every constituency. There are some people in the Socialist Movement who don't agree. But wę are starting a discussion, and Labour Party Socialists should argue for the position."
Paul McGarry said: "When the issue was first raised on the Labour Party Socialists committee, it was said that the paper would call for a Labour government. I asked whether this meant calling for a "LPS activists worried about whether the paper would call for a Labour vote in ever constituency, or instead hint at support for Greens, or Welsh or Scottish nationalists, in areas.
Labour vote in every constituency, and I was told no. It seems to be that that is a fudge.
"I don't want to see Labour Parly Socialists going into an election with a paper that says •Vote Labour. PS: vote Green if your Labour candidate is no good. Vote Plaid Cymru. Vote for the Socialist Party...
*If your Labour candidate is a right-winger and a witch-hunter, the thing to do is to recruit new people to the Party, kick out the candidate, and get a left-winger next Green or Plaid, " 80 off and vote time - not to Bill Hamilton replied: "Yes, we should be absolutely up front, and say vote Labour in every constituency. But the Socialist Movement helped get LPS off the ground. We must recognise that there are people in the Socialist Movement who are involved in other parties, and we must work with them.
Paul McGarry, he said, was "anricipating a decision which has not been taken yet. The comrades are only going to be able to put the position which we all believe in, for voting Labour everywhere, if we're in there supporting the newspaper rather than carping from the sidelines."
Mike Marqusee was concerned about "the effect on Labour Party Socialists of endorsing a Socialist Movement newspaper which does not call for a Labour vote in every constituency. " He was in favour of LPS having "a fruitful and positive relationship with the Socialist Movement" - but LPS must also be "clearly autonomous and independent, as an organisation of Labour Party members. It we are seen in any way as an arm of people who are outside the and indeed hostile to it, then we are in trouble.
"The politics of calling for a vote for the Greens, or Plaid Cymru, or why not the Liberal Democrats while we're at it, are the antithesis of class socialist politics."
Jim Denham said he thought there were hidden agendas floating about". "In the Socialist Movement there clearly are people for whom an orientation to the labour movement is not central. They support Plaid Cymru or the Greens. There are also people who hark towards an idea that somehow the Socialist Movement, eventually, in the distant future, will turn itself into a coherent socialist party, a viable alternative to the Labour Party.
*I suppose it's quite an attractive idea. But in Labour Party Socialists we must clearly reject and dissociate from anything that deviates from an orientation to the labour move ment. And that's why we've been having this debate.
Terry Conway said she agreed with 95 percent of what Jim Denham had said. But the best wa for LPS to put across its argument was to get involved in the Socialis Movement paper. If LPS did no get from the Socialist Moveme the assurances it needed about su porting Labour everywhere general election, then LPS sh pull out from the Socialist ment paper. But the first thing + was to get involved,
Scan page 7
LEFT JNI STUFF POLITAX Organiser