Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Tribune wields a natchet

Socialist Organiser no. 464, 2 November 1990 · scan p. 6 · about 605 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Last week's Tribune carried an article by Jeff Lovitt which was clearly meant to be a "hatchet job" on Socialist Organiser.

The point seemed to be to assert that Socialist Organiser is pretty much what the Labour Party National Executive said we were.

The article also quotes from a two year old SO discussion bulletin an unflattering comment on some of the people who have clustered around the Socialist Movement. The point here seems to be to sow ill-will between SO and the Socialist Movement.

Lovitt talked to SO editor John O'Mahony on the phone, and quotes him in the article. In fact he gave O'Mahony no indication of the scope of the article; O'Mahony thought it would be one of the short "update" pieces Tribune has carried regularly on the ban on SO and the campaign against it.

That the article should appear now is all the more odd because Tribune's first response, four months ago, to the moves to ban SO was a long front-page article rehashing the NEC documents and adding own factual (and factional!) "corrections" . Nothing very new is added now.

Tribune's role in the anti-ban campaign was always strange and ambivalent. And surprising. Tribune has drifted a long way to the right in the slipstream of the Kinnockites, albeit at a distance: Its "Diary" comments on the far left are - even when they report and sneer at real idiocies - among the worst examples of sterile sectarianism on the left today. There was not much natural sympathy between SO and Tribune!

Tribune's declaration of hostility to the ban on SO was surprising -and welcome. Unfortunately, its opposition to the ban was grounded exclusively on an abstract liberalism. Almost every concrete comment Tribune made about SO - and many of the comments weren't really about SO, but about *Trotskyist groups" in general -would have backed up and justified the NEC's decision to ban for anyone not inclined to stand on a dogmatic and abstract liberalism.

Tribune was not even consistently liberal. It published - and maybe commissioned - a vicious piece of mudslinging by Clare Short MP in defence of the ban. Indirectly and slyly, but nevertheless clearly, she smeared SO by association with violence, fascists, and "'criminals"

Tribune published a fine letier in reply by Danny Nicol. It would not publish a brief point-by-point rebuttal from SO editor John O'Mahony. By contrast, SO would have felt obliged to publish a direct reply by those charged to such direct charges.

Tribune editor Phil Kelly spoke at the End the Ban rally like a man who was very worried lest the NEC misunderstand wha: he thought he was doing there. He was at pains to insist that he had "never agreed with anything he had ever read in SO" - and he gave no indication that he was joking. He felt obliged to raise the stupid canard that SO supported the ban on the "anti-Zionist" journal Return within the National Union of Students.

And despite its opposition to the ban, for Tribune it was always None of that surprise came Tribune in HAL The witchhunters "business as usual". They charged full commercial rates for the halfpage advertisement End the Ban published in the Labour Party conference issue. Solidarity is one thing; business is business.

is surprising. The long ago when sharp contrast to much of the "revolutionary" left press — came out, in however contradictory a fashion, against the ban. Even abstract liberalism counts for something. Not much, but something.

And, all in all, we continue to be grateful to Tribune for its support before the Labour Party conference.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 464

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →