Merger would make the union weaker
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-10-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
The reality behind bland slogans branch chair, Merthyr Tydfil & District Area Branch, CPSA DSS Section irstly, the merger doc-ument is a "jobs for the boys" character, and will heap on to CPSA all the most undemocratic things from the NUCPS.
1 believe all officials of a union should be elected annually. The merger document proposes that three of the six top union positions will be appointed for life, with no accountability. It also allows NUCPS to elect their Executive Committee members by block vote, instead of the CPSA's workplace ballot of individual members.
The pro-mergerites say that unity is strength and big is beautiful. What nonsense! Ask my members, who have had four strikes, totalling more than 40 weeks, in the last four years.
NUCPS members, with a few notable exceptions, have scabbed on our disputes. They are management, and they were doing what they thought was their job -which is why we will never get unity.
Another argument for merger is the unions' financial problems. But the two unions don't have to merge in order to share resources. Another cost-cutter would be By Mark Serwotka been correct to ocialist Organiser has oppose the merger betweeen the two civil service unions CPSA and NUCPS.
The Tories are increasing the managerial functions carried out by NUCPS grades, which now include not just annual reports, but also setting targets for work output, disciplinary measures, and merit and performance pay.
Lower management grades like Executive Officers are now responsible not just for the job security of the clerical grades, but also our pay and councils on a regional basis and the annual Trades Council's Conference; and financial support for regional organisers for the unemployed would disappear.
These proposals would very conveniently sever all the main arteries of rank-and-file influence within the official structures of the TUC; they would also very conveniently stifle likely left-wing opposition to a 'National Economic Assessment' (read 'Income's Policy') with a future Labour government.
Our Norman is busy licking his cumbersome organisation into shape for a future smooth working relationship with Brother Kinnock. The "new look' TUC would be dominated by the Finance and General Purposes Committee, which has already approved the plan and to which to pay our full-timers, realistic salaries more in line with the pittance our members receive. (Our grades are paid between f4000 and £9500, our General Secretary well over £30,000)If CPSA has to merge, it should be with other clerical unions which have aims and objectives similar to ours.
conditions.
Sarah Cotterill (SO 462) is right to say that, in general, socialistsshould support unity. We should argue for unity in action, unity on the picket lines; but day-to-day matters cannot best be resolved in one big union.
Of course NUCPS is not a bosses' or a scab union. People do not become part of the enemy when they become supervisors. However, the fact remains that the best socialist in the world, as a NUCPS member, would still have to make day-to-day decisions that affect the clerical grades.
To put forward bland slogans without examining their consequences does no-one any favours.
the General Council is increasingly but a Rubber stamp.
The temptation is to disregard the forthcoming row over the Willis/Barber plan as a bureaucratic wrangle of no consignence to rank and file activists. It is certainly true that many of the TUC bodies now facing the chop were always thoroughly useless. It is also true that even the 'rank-andfile bodies like the Trades Council structures, are dominated by Stalinists and other failed barcaucrats. But the stakes are too high for us to stand on the sidelines and sneer. If Willis wants cutbacks, let him start closer to home: how about the millions wasted on 'refurbishing"
Congress House or the apparently bottomless purse that finances bureaucrats freebies to exotic locations!