Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A plague on both houses

Socialist Organiser no. 463, 23 October 1990 · scan p. 14 · about 705 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Road-wants-to ban You can also subscribe to Workers Lilkmagazine - CHa NamE 823, London SE15 4NA Gees the Gulf crisis erry Bates (SO 460)

turning into "an attempt by the United States to effectively conquer Iraq... a huge imperialist military presence in the region, sparking mass revolts"

He uses this scenario to justify defending Iraq if war breaks out. But Iraq is not a small defenceless country. It is not a Panama or a Grenada. It is a powerful sub-imperialism with an army one million strong. In its expansionist bid for regional domination it has run up against the imperialist interests of the United States and Britain; the result is a reactionary battle for regional control.

IGANISER Address ...

Paid: E16 for a year E3 for 10 issues E5 for Workers' Liberty Total.

Return to SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

DO YOU.

THINK ITS

TIME TO INVADE IRAQ?

out of E1116. Borne

THINK

SO.

IT'S TIME | TO GO IN.

SO has quite rightly called for US and Britain out of the Gulf, Iraq out of Kuwait. However, editorials have gone from that to speculation to justify a position of defending Iraq if wai breaks out. Speculation and scenarios have replaced and obscured concrete analysis.

There is no evidence that the aim of the US and Britain is to conquer and subjugate Iraq. The Economist magazine, cited in SO 459 as such evidence, asserts only *the need to cripple Mr Hussein's ability to be a more efficient aggressor next time". It believes that a Subscribe to Saci a list Ongenisemen speciah matre:

Tuesday 23 October. Bambatha's Children: play about the 1906 Poli Tax revolt in South Africa, performed in aid of the Sarmcol workers. 7.30, ACNA Centre, Hungerhill Road, Nottingham. £3 waged, £1.50 unwaged Wednesday 24 October. "Poll Tax: don't pay, don't collect!" Student demonstration. Assem ble noon, Woodhouse Moor, Leeds. Details from West Yorks Area NUS: 0532 452312.

Wednesday 24 October. Fighting anti semitism. 8pm, Ilford Synagogue. Speakers: Ray Hill and Graeme Atkın son (Searchlight).

Wednesday 24 October. No war in the Gulf! Meeting hosted by Man chester Area National Union of Students, with speakers including Tony Benn. 7.30, Renold Building. UMIST.

WE PUT IN THE BOYCOTT, WE DEPLOYED OUR TROOPS. DON'T FORGET THIS IS FOR OUR WAY OF LIFE!

WE STATED OUR CONDITIONS, WE GOT NO RESPONSE, INSTANT IT'S BEEN GRATIFICATION? WEEKS ALREADY!

TRE NEXT GLOBAL MADMAN IS QUE ANY DAY: 159 "clear cut victory" would involve "the downfall of Saddam Hussein" - but "let the line be drawn there... The West cannot guarantee a benign ruler; can only remove a malign one. It has no interest in imposing a government on Iraqis" (Economist, 6 Oct.)

Defeats for the Iraqi army may well lead to the fall of Saddam Hussein. The role of socialists in Iraq would be to utilise the crisis, to capitalise on the defeats, to mobilise workers to hasten his downfall. The main enemy for Iragi workers also at home.

According to SO 457, *The US intervention is more like 19th century colonialism than the imperialism of free trade which characterised the '50s, '60s and '70s" . Such a possibility cannot be ruled out, but to view it as inevitable is ridiculous.

The ghost of Vietnam still haunts the US corridors of power. Financial crisis is causing problems for the US's present involvement, never mind a long-term role as colonial master.

US imperialism may well change tack. But before socialists conclude that fundamental change has taken place, concrete evidence is required.

Saddam Hussein is using pan-Arab demagogy to try to widen his support, but it would be a mistake to view him as the champion of a fight by the Arab masses against US imperialism. He is using Arab nationalist rhetoric to mobilise support for his landgrab and his bid for regional power.

Socialists oppose both these aims, and so in this context Arab nationalism is not playing a progressive role.

The conflict is over regional power and control of oil. For workers on either side — the main enemy is at home.

Tony Dorman, Manchester.

----- pull-quotes -----

WRITEBACK DearS.O.. Tou've done it agour! Your reamt artile on the Write 10 SO, PU Box

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 463

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →