Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A how and w

Socialist Organiser no. 463, 23 October 1990 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 726 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Books B J Siddon reviews Toxic Shock' by Sara Paretsky (Penguin £3.99)

If, like me, you are a sucker for crime novels, you should go to your nearest bookshop and buy this book at once. The same is true if you like feminist fiction, but are terrified of buying yet another badly written, badly plotted 'story' which reminds you of a bad day in a student union without the excitement.

Sara Paretsky's detective (Vic Warshawski) does not use all the right-on language, nor is she horribly 'supportive' or sickeningly political. Equally she does not leap tall buildings with a single bound. Like all the best pleasure-giving fictional detectives she is skilled, but human.

Warshawski does not describe her female clients as having 'good' legs and she moans about having to war high heels and a suit to impress people. She does not patronise the working class or stereotype working class individuals but at the same time she does not idolise working class communities.

Because the left politics and feminism are understated they are effective. You can get on with the story, confident that there won't be downright stupidly offensior throw-away sexist, racist or remarks to put you out of sympathy with the protagonist.

"Toxic Shock' is about the cover-up of industrial pollution,, and particularly the effect of a • new chemical on employees health. But the book also deals with child abuse, and it does it very well, with howls of outrage from Warshawski, and self-justifying silence from those who let the abuse go on.

Like Ross MacDonald, Sara Paretsky follows a mystery back into the past, finding the truth along the way, bit by bit. "Toxic Shock' is not a 'whodunnit' , more of a 'how and why'. But the mystery is mysterious and you do want to find the answers.

There is violence too, and not all. of it from the bad guys. Warshawski, like Lew Archer, Spenser or the Continental Op uses violence where it's necessary and in defence of herself and her clients or friends. Unlike those (male) detectives, she does not feel the need to have pangs of guilt about it afterwards. Her violence does not/ need to be justified by the author to make her human or sympathetic -Warshawski is obviously both. She is not callous, just rational.

I have said many good things about this book, and I could say many more. It's not Ross Macdonald but its not a bad substitute. Lew Archer would be very comfortable with Vic Warshawski and what finer praise could there be? also get too much of Bonnie Bedelia as his insecure wife Barbara; a little bit of her goes a long way.

The central character, Carolyn, Is missing. We get the old tantalising glimpse, but nothing more. She never exists for us as a woman; we only see her through the eyes of the men who slept with her, the men who couldn't understand her.

She's reduced to one dimension - the sex bomb no man could hang on to.

Yet the book was about her as much as Rusty Sabich's efforts to clear his name. The book reveals both what he found out about her, and why he was obsessed with her.

But the film ignores all that -her abused past that led her to take up the cudgels for the victims of rape and violence, her marriage, her son — in favour of dopey scenes with Sabich and his wife and son.

This tips the balance in a way the book never did. We felt we knew Carolyn, and that we knew what was lost when she died. In the film, there's none of that, just a lingering, offensive moralism that says "She asked for it - she got what she deserved".

Ironically, Carolyn is the only character never 'presumed innocent'. In this movie, a woman who sleeps around is guilty from the start.

The film reduces • to clumsy shorthand what took long pages to spell out, then, most mistakenly of all, spells out the enigmatic ending in a disastrous scene that belongs on the cutting room floor.

For all that, I enjoyed seeing it.

Having read the book | filled incomprehensible bits in the movie.

It could have been a better movie.

but it's not a disaster

Scan page 14

Socialist Organiser No 463 23 October 1990 Page 14

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 463

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →