A hidden massacre of revenge
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-10-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Losses: An investigation in the mass deaths of Germal PoWs at the hands of the French and the Americans after World War 2", by James Bacque. Bor as somebody once put it: arbarism is contagious The who fights dragons becomes a dragon.
Mr Bacque's book contends that at the end of the Second World War, the French and American victors killed as many as one million -German prisoners of war by neglect and starvation. It was done, he says, deliberately, or as near as makes no difference to deliberately. It is, he says, one of the great dark unrevealed secrets of the Second World War.
At war's end in May 1945, five million Germans surrendered to the Americans. Nobody wanted to surrender to the Russians, whose routine ill-treatment of Germans was widely known.
By January the tollowing year, 800,000 had died of starvation and neglect in camps that had come to resemble the Nazi Dachau or Belsen. The Germans had been kept through the winter on starvation rations and in open compounds, with only burrows they dug in the ground to give them shelter,Bacque makes detailed allegations that Red Cross food convoys were turned away and Red Cross inspections of the camps refused, despite the stipulations of the Geneva Convention.
The French took, or had transferred to their keeping Americans, nearly one million prisoners. By November 1945, a quarter of a million had disappeared from French records. The French blamed this on the condition the prisoners were in when they came from the Americans.
Bacque explains the half century of silence by historians through a number of factors. There was, of course, general chaos in Europe, and widespread hunger and starvation. The families of the victims often knew nothing about their location, or thought they were in Russian hands. Vast numbers of prisoners were dragooned into the Stalinist empire as slave labourers, and some of them were still reappearing as late as the mid-'50s.
So nobody knew who would prorest. Besides, immediately after the war the Germans were too beaten down. Occupied Germany was under military law. US journalists on the scene were military-licensed war correspondents, quite complicit. And the victors tend to write historyBacque is weakest in explaining why what he alleges happened.
Critics of Bacque argue that th evidence he cites is accounted for b initial miscounting of the prisoners and make other far-fetched and un convincing suggestions.
CONT know. That German were grossly ill-treated is a fact o history, whatever the truth of Bac que's allegations. There was tremendous wave of chauvinist pro paganda against thei.
Pseudo-learned theories, akin t the Nazis' own race theory, wer propounded to explain of the Hunnish Germans", and s And then the horrors of the Na concentration and death camp were revealed, and in a world over ed with horrors people still had di ficulty Delevne the truth treatment and even the murder o Germans would have come natur ly to a lot of those responsible fo the rows The only question scale of the e0210 Or PoW what Bacque says it was, and was deliberate.
Scan page 13
alist Organiser No 463 23 October 1990 Page
----- pull-quotes -----
Books Ron Vandy reviews "Other