Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

So much blood

Socialist Organiser no. 463, 23 October 1990 · scan p. 12 · about 975 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

TV Ackersley n appearance the strikingly handsome, haunted-looking woman might have been either an Israeli Jew or a Palestinian Arab.

In fact she was Israeli. One night Palestinian gunmen landed from the sea near the house where she lived with her husband and two small daughters.

Knowing they would be killed if they tell into the hands of the Palestinians, the family divided and hid, each parent taking one child.

The smaller went with the mother, too young to understand, but old enough to be terrified. The mother had to stifle the little girl's cries. They were not discovered.

The man and the older girl were captured, and taken down to the beach from which the raiders disembarked.

They shot the man cleanly through the head. Then - perhaps not considering her worth a bullet - they battered in the little girl's skull with repeated blows from the butt end of a revolver.

The other child died too. She was suffocated by her mother's desperate efforts to silence her and save both their lives. Only the poor woman with the haunted Israeli-Palestinian face was left.

The good things in Terror (Channel 4, Monday 16th: the first of a *three part analysis of modern terrorism'") were all like that - stark and raw encounters with the human reality of terrorism, both its victims and its perpetrators.

A Palestinian nurse, jailed for leaving a bomb in a crowded cinema (it didn't go off) was proud of it - a against the bonis enemy struggle *I did not experience fear, delight, grief. How can I regret what I did when I see my people killed every day? Why do you call what we did terrorism?"

In this case Palestinian terrorism has been the desperate, dehumanised weapon of the utterly defeated and crushed — of people slaughtered not only by the Israelis, but by the rulers of Jordan and Syria too. It has been the response of people treated with merciless savagery and indiscriminate terror by the Israeli state.

The prospects are not for things to get better: quite the opposite. "So much blood, a great river of blood", separates the Palestinian Arabs and the Israelis, as the woman whose husband and daughters died put it.

The most chilling and repulsive people in the programme's memorable parade of victims and militants were the educated Jewish and Muslim religious bigots. Articulate, logical — from crazed premises - and coherent, they mirfored each other in their dogmatic religious certainties and their inhuman chauvinism. Their influence is growing on both sides.

The bad thing about "Tèrror" was its gross bias. The facts of Israel's treatment of the defeated Palestinians over decades add up to a massive indictment of Israel. To put those facts in their proper historical context and geopolitical framework, and to avoid obvious distortion of the facts of history, is not to make the story less horrible. Those who want to indict Israel don't need to cheat. The makers of "Terror" did.

You wouldn't know from their account that in 1948 the Israelis were the victims of an armed Egyptian-Syrian-Jordanian invasion to destroy their state and drive them out. A large sea of Arab animosity and desire to destroy Israel - that is the context of Israel's savagery.

Worse, when the educated religious bigots were on camera, the Jew went on about the claimed Talmudic authority for his brand of rabidly chauvinist politics, and that was allowed to stand as explanation for Israel's behaviour to the Palestinians - rooting it in the fundamentals of Jewish religion, and not in what recent history and the present danger has done to the Jews. vations about the prospect of German reunification. The fact that he didn't (or rather, that if he did it was obviously overshadowed by his empathy with the German people and his joy at the end of the cold war) was typical of him.

Bernstein's politics were a reflection of his approach to music — he was a populist, but a serious and honest one. Like many American intellectuals and artists of his generation, occupied the political ground between the radical wing of the Democratic Party and outright socialism.

He was a firm supporter of the Civil Rights Movement, and opposed the war in Vietnam. But he was personally and politically committed to the Kennedys and their type of Democrat pseudo-radicalism. At his 65th birthday party, Bernstein even persuaded Teddy Kennedy (and Liz Taylor!) to wear nuclear disarmament armbands... But he showed genuine courage in the '60s, by "coming out" as a gay. His musical achievements are too numerous to list here. Suffice to say that unlike other "populists" who sought to break down the barriers between "serious" and "pop" music, Bernstein always maintained the highest artistic standards. West the American musical tradition an vorthy of placing beside the best Rogers, Hart, Hammerstein over pet hate howatte Cole Porter (though it Stephen Sondheim).

Certainly there is no compariso Bernstein's "popular Derween works and the nauseating pa churned out by, say, Mr Andre Lloyd Webber, or the pretentiou inanities of Mr Phillip Glass. Son: like Maria, America, Somewhere (There's a Place Fo Us) still stand up on their own, eve when performed by pop groups an stodgy dance bands.

And unlike some would-be eclec tics from the world of "serious music, Bernstein knew his stuf when he turned to other fields. Ask ed to produce a jazz album for CB in the mid-'50s, he displayed uner ing taste and judgment in hiring th of Buck Claytol. Colema Hawkins and Lawrence Brown. H even "depped" for pianist Na Price on a couple of numbers!

Bernstein had many faults: was vain and not always very brave He kept his head down during th McCarthy witch-hunts of the for instance. But he was not phoney. We are all the poorer fo his passing.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 463

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →