Who pays for their party?
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-10-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Is the Tory Party bought and paid for? That was the question raised by the recent Panorama study Who pays for the party?' Of course there is no public auction. Nobody says *We have a life peerage for sale today. Can we start at €30,000 please?" But there is remarkable trade all the same. One of the Prime Minister's first actions in 1979 was to announce she was restoring the system of political honours. Since then she has clocked up the fastest honours rate of any Prime Minister since Lloyd George, who was also as bent as a nine bob note. By 1988 eleven industrialists were elevated to the House of Lords and 82 given knighthoods.
The companies of these men contributed almost £8 million to Tory Party coffers. Three quarters of the industrialists honoured by Thatcher were directors of companies that made hefty contributions. So arise, Sir Paul Girolami, chairman of Glaxo Holdings, and thank you again for the £255,000 you have donated to the cause since 1979. It really does work as crudely as that.
Of the top 110 companies of the last decade, 50% donated to the Tory Party and 50% did not. Directors from the half that did donate got two thirds of the honours. And of course those who render their services in other ways are not forgotten either. So arise Sir Larry Lamb (Sun), Sir John Junor (Sunday Express), Sir David English (Daily Mail) and so on. Of course there are other forms of currency besides peerages. The donating company or individual can expect a healthy return on their investment - for that is what it is - in other ways.
It was alleged by the Panorama Alan Johnson programme that the brewing industry used its financial leverage over the Tory Party to block legislation. The industry gives £120,000 per year. The biggest donor is the Allied Lyons group which alone this year gave €90,000.
In 1989 the Monopolies and Mergers Commision recomended that the monopoly of the top six brewets be broken up, that they be limited to owning only 2,000 pubs and that independent and real ales should be allowed into pubs more easily. Lord Young declared his support and said the proposals would 'set the pub free'. But then, in the words of Allied Lyons Chairman, Sir (of course) Derrick Holden-Brown: "We made strong representations and the DTI listened to our arguments" ment published its proposals it had more hey did indeed. When the governFor less caved in to the brewers, who denied their threat to reduce or delay donations had any bearing on the decision. In Parliament Bryan Gould attacked "A government bought and sold by its major financial backers"
Not only favours are for sale to the wealthy in return for cash. The register of 'extra parliamentary activity' shows that many MPs are too. In 1986 a survey by Labour Research showed:
• one in three non-government MPs were directors, with over half of all Conservative MPs now on company boards;
• one in four of all MPs and two-fifths of Conservative MPs are consultants for commercial organisations.
• 31 MPs - all but one Conservative -are directors or consultants to PR/Lobby firms.
Ministers have to wait until they give up their portfolios and Daimlers before taking up directorships. Thus they do it with a vengeance, usually with the very companies they have just privatised while in office -Tebbit and Telecom, Young and Cable and Wireless etc.
As Gordon Brown expressed it, this is indeed the government's very own Restart scheme for ministers - 'Action for Jobs: Matching the Ministers without Companies to the Companies without Ministers' There is a revolving door between govern= ment and boardroom. Through it pass MPs, civil servants, favoured businessmen, political advisors. And as they do, say many people, the horse trading goes on. Peerages for cash. Amendments dropped or reinstated. Confidential information from a Select Committee. Directorships.. Consultancies. Retainers. Palms are greased and mutal favours exchanged. Arthur Daley, I think, would use the expression 'nice little earner".
No doubt the Select Committee on members' interests is working hard to clean the MPs act up. More power to its chairman, I say, Sir Geoffrey John Smith. I'm sure he is right on top of the matter... when he isn't pursuing his interests in London Weekend Television (Holdings) Ltd, Brands Hatch Leisure plc, Tatlor Laden Ltd, Glengate Holdings Ltd, MDA (Benelux) SA, Eagle Star Group, and Phillips Business Systems. things difficult at home for America's "moderate" Arab allies. And it is a godsend for Saddam Hussein.
Those who haven't done anything in decades for the Palestinian Arabs get busy spouting indignation, and their press starts churning out atrocity propaganda against Israel. Are they outraged by the killing on Temple Mount? Like hell they are! America's new ally Syria presided over the routine butchering of a few hundred people in Lebanon, the week before last. Nobody noticed. They are concerned with politics, not the "politics of the last atrocity"
How does this all fit into the dominant left-wing picture of Israel as the irreplaceable tool of the Western imperialist bloc?
Imperialism does not "depend" on Israel it has Arab allies. It secures its interests through its Arab allies, from the Gult and Saudi feudalists to the Egyptian bourgeoisie. Israel is now a liability, not a reliable ally.
Thus the hypocritical and orchestrated outcry about the 21 dead from people whose real concern is to smooth their way to the tens and hundreds of thousands of dead at the end of the war they work towards.
On the other side of the relationship, Israel has understandable fears that the US is now arming its future opponents, Saudi Arabia for example. For the basic relation of forces puts the right to exist of Israel - surrounded by vastly larger hostile Arab and Islamic states - under threat.
The left should resist the politics of the last atrocity". The left should face the fact that its politics on this question amount to demonising Israel as a "bad nation" and taking sides with Arab revanchists and even Islamic chauvinists.
The solution to the Jewish-Arab conflict is to advocate self-determination for both peoples — the withdrawal of Israe 1 from the West Bank and Gaza and the crea tien of an independent Palestinian state.
Two nations, two states! Israel West Bank and Gaza!
Scan page 11
Socialist Organiser 163 23 October 1990 Page 11
----- pull-quotes -----
CHE-POLITICAL FRONT