Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

What the

Socialist Organiser no. 463, 23 October 1990 · scan pp. 8–10 · about 2,986 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

The Kurds are one of the gest oppressed nations on earth: over 25 million people, occupying an area about as big as France, divided between Turkey (14 million Kurds), Syria (one million), the USSR (a few), Iran (8 million) and Iraq (4 million). Michel Morel reviews the a titudes of five Kurdish nationalist parties to the Gulf N now", says Ahmad, o-one can want a war of the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan in Iraq, "because there will be thousands of civilian deaths.

*But can Saddam be dealt with without war? If so, no-one is against it, but personally I don't believe it. Sanctions will not budge the dictator.

"We are ready to collaborate with the devil to get rid of Saddam'"

In Iraqi Kurdistan there is nothing left. Thousands of villages have been razed; one and a half million Kurds live in camps surrounded by police. No people, says Ahmad, except perhaps the Jewish people, has suffered as much as the Kurdish people. There is no family that has not had at least two children tortured or killed.

*The invasion of Kuwait is an opportunity for the Kurdish people. Once Saddam Hussein is overthrown, all possibilities are open". "Sadam Hus addam Hussein will dangerous in five years' time if he is allowed to get away with it", says Bayar, a representative of the Democratic Party of Iraqi Kurdistan.

*The DPK is a peaceful party which situates itself between socialism and communism, but we defend the rights of the Kurdish people; we have not chosen to take up arms, but we have been forced *There are only two ways to get rid of Saddam Hussein. Overthrow the regime from within, or deal with the problem by military interventon. The second possibility cannot "e rejected"

But Bayar is against the permanent presence of foreign troops in the region, and says he has no illusions about the imperialist powers. The Kurdish people are in the front line of the victims of imperialism.

real wall no better than the one which came down last year in Berlin -separates the Kurds of Iraq and of Turkey.

There are thirty kilometres of no man's land, where the villages have been razed, the trees chopped down, and the sources of water blocked up. Troops have orders to shoot anything that moves.

Azad Hoguir, an official of the National Liberation Front of Turkish Kurdistan, condemns Saddam's expansionism and the invasion of Kuwait. But he believes the imperialists are using that as an excuse, and their intervention has nothing to do with enforcing international law.

*When Baghdad showered Kurdistan with chemical weapons in recent years, there was no protest. And the problems of the region will not be resolved now by military intervention. On that level, the policy of the imperialists will be no better than that of the Iraqi regime"

Only the progressive forces of the region can contribute to resolving the Palestinian question, the Lebanese dilemma, or the Kurdish problem, says Azad Hoguir. Unfortunately they are too weak, and do not offer an alternative to the existing governments.

Consequently the mass protesti movements in Jordan, in Egypt, in Syria and in Palestine against the foreign troops in the Gulf in fact fall in with the policy of Saddam Hussein. "Nevertheless they do express a legitimate anti-imperialiste sentiment, and they must be sup ported"

The occupation of Kuwait maycreate favourable opportunities for the struggle of the Kurdish people. If Saddam falls, for example, the intifada in Turkish Kurdistan led by the militants of the Nationa Liberation Front can be supported by the Kurds of Iraq.

In Turkey, the Front supports themovement against military intervention, in the same way as it supportsand participates in the demonstrations organised in Europe. 'TheTurkish state is preparing for war. It is going to take advantage of the landing of the Western armies to strengthen its links with the West, -to get new credits, and to justify its: own fascist-state policy in Kurdistan"

In April, there were decrees cen suring the press and banninga strikes. About two hundred and fif ty villages have been destroyed, burned down; fighters, men women, and children have bee assassinated, and the people of th area deported.

On 23 August, Turkey sent a letter to the Council of Europe sayin that these decrees "could entail derogation from the obligations of the European Convention o Human Rights" since Turkey wa at war in "south-eastern Anatolia The word Kurdistan is banned.

The Ankara dictatorship uses th same methods against the Kurdi people as Saddam Hussein, agai whom it sends its troops alongsi the imperialist armies. It still cove the Mosul region, in Iraqi Ku distan, with its oilfields yielding

Scan page 9

Islamic reaction urds think top-quality oil.

According to Abdullah, A an official of the Kurdish Workers' Association in France, there is no justification for Iraq's invasion of Kuwait.

"Saddam Hussein must be forced to withdraw from Kuwait by economic sanctions. Otherwise his regime will be strengthened. But as far as I know, the UN has not approved the sending of troops to the region. The US jumped the gun"

He stresses the hypocrisy of the Western countries which financed and armed Saddam's regime for years, and supported it in its war against Iran. With torture and hangings, Saddam Hussein has brutally crushed all the democratic forces in Iraq. Against the Kurdish people he uses war, genocide, destruction of villages, and deportations.

"You can neither be on his side, nor support the policy of the United States" • Abdullah tavours negotiations to resolve the conflicts in the region, for armed confrontation has never solved anything.

Hussein However, those who talk about negotiated solutions completely ignore the Kurdish question - including the UN, "which is, after all, surprising" , since it advocates the ight of peoples to self-determination"

The Kurds of Iran have waged war against the Teheran government for ten years now.

Five thousand peshmergas (guerrilla fighters] have died in the struggle, and 50,000 civilians have been killed. Iranian Kurdistan is the last bastion of liberty in the Islamic Republic. But the media puts up a wall of silence.

"The European public has not had the right to know about the struggle of the Kurdish people" says Azad, an official of the Democratic Party of Iranian Kurdistan.

*In principle, we are against any annexation, but look, how can the world mobilise for an emir's family?

"If they really wanted to defend human rights, there are 25 million Kurds, and we are the prime victims of Saddam's policies. The current rapprochement between Iran and Iraq worries us.

"The West is making a huge mistake" Its hatred for Irag is leading it to normalise relations with Iran. It will thus allow the Teheran regime to do what it likes against the Kurds. "The West is willing to forget all the regime's crimes, the political prisoners, the massacred oppositionists" Maybe Teheran will fight Saddam. But it is, says Azad, the worst regime in the region - even worse today than it was ten years ago.

The massive build-up of Western troops "is a very dangerous game. All the peoples of the region will INTERNATION pay the price. War will absolute ruin of Iraq"

And getting rid of Saddam is not the answer. "It is personalising a political problem which will not be removed by getting rid of the individual. And we cannot even imagine the consequences which would result from a concerted attack against the Islamic Republic of Iran. After such a war, Muslim fundamentalism would grow everywhere, like mushrooms, in the ruins".

The KDPI has not participated in the recent peace demonstrations. "For us, condemnation of the war must be linked to the solution of the Kurdish question. If the demonstrations pose the question of international negotiations to resolve the problems of the Gulf, then we will support them"

This survey shows that there is not one uniform Kurdish response to the Gulf crisis, but different strategies and tactics coming from different countries and different parties.

The two main Iraqi organisations are the only ones not to rule out supporting a war. Their long confrontation with butcher Saddam's regime probably explains this attitude.

We pointed out to them that they underestimated two inevitable consequences of war. Its repercussions in the region are completely incalculable, and there is every chance that the Kurds will pay the same price, physically and politically, as other peoples of the Middle East.

And all the more so because the Turkish state, which contributes to the armada against Saddam Hussein - and Iran too - will come out of it strengthened, and their policies of bloody repression of the Kurdish people will be strengthened as well.

The conversations should in any case convince us ot one thing: in Europe, our mobilisation against the war must also declare and support the right to existence of the Kurdish people, a people against whom all the states involved in the crisis are in league.

Abridged and translated from French socialist weekly Rouge. in Algeria In Algeria, the Islamic Salvation Front has recently swept the board in local government elections. We were there during the elections and just before., The support for the Islamic Salvation Front was quite widespread - mainly, as far as I could see, from the young, from the middle classes, from people generally in the north and in the cities. At the universities, the bookshops were full of Islamic books. Those staying with the National Liberation Front (which has ruled a one-party state since independence in 1962) seemed to be mainly the old, and people in the desert areas of the south.

We were not able to talk to any women separately about their political views. When we asked women about politics, they deferred immediately to the men.

The growing support for the Islamic Salvation Front seems to go hand in hand with more people going to the mosque. Two young men we spoke to told us about an Islamic Salvation Front election meeting in their town square. It was huge, crowded meeting. They both told us that at the end of the meeting people had seen Allah written in the sky. One of them said he had seen it himself, the other was a bit more sceptical.

The Islamic Salvation Front supporters we spoke to did not seem to see Iran, or anywhere else as a model. Much more they were saying, "We'll find our own way with Allah's help".

They felt shut out from everything else. Socialism - Or what they've been told was nothing. They call gie National socialism - has them mollng• Liberation Front bureaucrats, the fat cats. One of the ISF supporters we spoke to lives in a household where eight adults and five children share three small rooms. That's not unusual in Algeria. He showed us Socialist Organiser No 463 23 October 1990 Page huge, beautiful villas on the hill overlooking the town, and told us: *Those are what the government people have as their second homes. That's socialism in Algeria"

beggars on the streets you see in Morocco or Egypt. Many areas are very poor, but in Algiers particularly you can also see a lot of money around. I saw women in Algiers wearing expensive, Frenchcut suits going down to the floor -not traditional clothing, but a sort of modern version of fundamentalist clothing.

In the casbah there are shops with hardly anything in them, but not far from there is a whole street of jewellery shops.

But the revolution against the French is still very alive, even for young people. And they see it as rejecting capitalism. People also talked about Fortress Europe and 1992. They feel shut out of everything, and that's why they see Islam as the only way forward.

The Islamic reaction seems to be stronger and more bitter in Algiers than elsewhere. In Algiers I was refused admittance to hotels, presumably because I was an infidel woman. All the women disappeared at night, and trying to find something to eat was really difficult. I have rarely encountered so much antagonism. Even though I was with a man, when we walked into any cafe there was a wave of hostility. It was horrible.

Outside Algiers, even in other cities, we had no trouble, and we were greeted with traditional Arab hospitality, invited into people's homes. And in the desert, people were not particularly concerned about the election. They have not been much touched by Algeria's failed attempt at industrialisation and by the population explosion in the north.

But in Algiers and the north, the failure of the National Liberation Front's attempt at 'socialism' and at industrialisation is bringing a very bitter reaction.

Scan page 10

Sean Matgamna There is a well-known expression in Irish politics for the swings of public opinion which follow the latest horrible deed of the British Army, the Protestant paramilitaries, or the Provisional IRA — "the politics of the last atrocity"

It means reacting with raw natural feeling to the immediate impact of an event, and forgetting about the overall picture.

In response to the terrible slaughter in Jerusalem by Israeli police of Palestinian demonstrators armed only with stones, the feelings of socialists, or even decent liberals, will line them up with the Palestinians. And it really doesn't matter if the organisers of the ugly Palestinian assault on Jews at prayer did it deliberately to create a "diversion" on behalf of Saddam Hussein, which is what the Israeli government claims.

The Palestinians are entitled to use what allies they can find. (The wisdom of allying with Saddam Hussein is another matter). They are entitled even to use suicide tactics if it will further their people's liberation.

The Israeli government doesn't seem to realise what a picture it paints of itself and its policies when it accuses gunless demonstrators of deliberately "provoking" the Israeli police to shoot them down. It matters, but not fundamentally, that those shot down were part of a murderous mob lobbing stones at praying Jews: Jerusalem is in the grip of an ongoing rivalry between ultrareligious fanatics of Islam and Judaism, and the Jews seem to be the aggressors. The Palestinians, now, are the victims, Temple Mount and we side with them.

But when all that is said, raw feeling is not enough. As if to prove that the politics of the last atrocity are not enough, came last Sunday's (21st) rampage in Jerusalem by a 19 year old Palestinian shouting "Allah Akhbar" ("God is great") and wielding a bayonet with which he killed three people and wounded others, including a 13 year old boy. He was seemingly one of the growing current of Muslim fundamentalists, Islamic Jihad, the bearers of a "holy war" to make Islam dominant in the whole area, including One of those bayonetted to death was an armed Israeli policeman who shot the Palestinian in both legs and might have killed him had he disregarded orders not to shoot to kill.

Such an act, by a half-crazed member of a beaten and oppressed people, is not the strict equivalent of what the Israeli police did at Temple Mount. It does show up the awful background.

There are vast numbers of Palestinians who have sympathy with such actions. The Israelis pursue a policy of savage retribution which is as indefensible as it is counterproductive. In Palestine the Jewish and Arab peoples have related to each other like that PERSPECTIVE for many decades. The first large-scale violence between Jews and Arabs was sparked by clashes very like the recent clashes at Temple Mount, 71 years ago.

The notion that these two peoples can immediately solve their conflict by agreeing to live as common citizens in a "secular democratic state" is bizarre. Yet it is still probably the most common view on the left.

It is just not possible! For the left, the idea functions as a framework which allows support to be given to Arab chauvinists and Muslim bigots committed to the destruction of Israel: it is Israel's intransigence, so the reasoning goes, which stops such a united and harmonious secular democratic state coming into being, and so it is just that Israel should be destroyed.

Events like last weekend's killings prove that it is not just Israel that makes the "secular democratic state" inconceivable. The Palestinian Arabs do not support Saddam Hussein hoping that he will win and impose equal citizenship between Jews and Arabs in Palestine!

The Israelis, like the Palestinians, have a right to their own state. It will be a tragedy if the Temple Mount massacre - via the "politics of the last atrocity" - reinforces the widespread, though not always explicitly formulated, belief on the left that support the destruction of Israel.

The politics of the last atrocity blind the left to the real lesson for Israel of what is happening in the Middle East now.

War, as Lenin said long ago, strips away peacetime frauds and pretences, revealing things and people for what they really are. The mere preparation for war in the Gulf has done that in the case of Israel. The left which for decades has both demonised Israel and seen it as no more than a tool of Western imperialism should look at what's going on and learn from it. i an Are and the lone low it is no longer only the honest Palestinian Arabs, and the long-time left-wing critics of Israel's remorseless savagery towards them, who denounce Israel. The mainstream press, and even mainstream bourgeois politicians, now do much the same.

For these long-time supporters of Israel, everything is now subordinate to the needs of keeping their Arab allies against Iraq in line. Everything is subordinate to the looming war for cheap oil.

The killing of the 21 Palestinians at Temple Mount threatens that alliance by making

----- pull-quotes -----

A lot of inequality is visible in the cities, though there aren't the

AGAINST THE TIDE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 463

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →