'Forward to Socialism? STALINISM
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-10-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
rkers rally in Johannesburg in protest at an attempted Communist Party takeover of their union and in defence of the elected leadership. "Phantsi" By Robert Fine, author Apartheid' Ason Africa is that of leading mong the bad news coming out of 'trade unionists in COSATU having joined the South African Communist PartyIn itself this comes as no surprise, since leading COSATU officials like Sydney Mufumadi - who came out of the UDF — aligned General and Allied Workers Union and oversaw the attempt to carve up the left leadership of CCAWUSA (the Commercial and Catering Union) - were strongly suspected of being party members. What is more unexpected is the SACP's recruitment of trade unionists associated with the old FOSATU tradition and previously identified with a more democratic and anti-Stalinist socialism.
The best known of these is Moses Mayekiso, the current general-secretary of NUMSA, the large and traditionally left metal union, said that he has "long' been a member of the SACP. His version is that he was already thinking of joining when he was in England in 1986, a time when he consorted mainly with left groups. He joined on his return to South Africa.
Since he was detained for three years immediately on his return, he must have either joined the party in gaol or on his release, late in 1989. The surprise is compounded by the fact that the Free Mayekiso' campaign over here was led by the left and strongly opposed by the Anti-Apartheid Movement with its links to the ANC-SACTU-SACP nexus.
Mayekiso's membership was not a one-off wonder. There are other ex-FOSATU recruits: Chris Dlamini, originally a shop steward in the Sweet Food Union and then president of FOSATU in 1982, a time when criticism of FOSATU as 'workerist' reached a peak; Alec Erwin, one of the 'intellectual' founders of the new unions in the 1970s and education secretary in FOSATU; and John Gomomo, who was the lieutenant of Freddie Sauls (considered to be an arch 'workerist") in the FOSATU Automobile Union.
All these top COSATU officials are now labelled part of the 'internal leadership' of the SACP. Trips to Russia are included in the package.
ta time when the old Communist • Parties around the world are either in decline or a state of collapse, how is it that the SACP — a particularly loyal servant of Moscow ever since the late 1920s -should now be extending its grip in the South African labour movement?
The first answer is that there must be a collective folly at work among otherwise independent and militant trade unionists. This is true but it explains nothing. It is important to understand, not simply to denounce. We should certainly recognise the right of trade unionists to join the party of their choice, even if we deplore the choice.
What then are the factors? First, the SACP itself has verbally disavowed Stalinism. The theme was set in a paper by party boss Joe Slovo called 'Has Socialism failed?'. Ever faithful to Moscow, Slovo is now a confirmGlossary COSATU: Congress of South African Trade Unions, milion-strong trade union federation founded in 1985, including large miners and metalworkers' unions. Closely aligned with Nelson Mandela's African National Congress (ANCI FOSATU: Federation of South African Trade Uniors, largest single component of COSATU. in the early '80s FOSATU was independent of the ANC and labelled workerist. Its spokespersons talked of the need to build an independent warkers' political movement, and were suspicious of broad multi-class alliances SACTU: South African Congress of Trade Unions. Dominant union federation among black workers in the 1950s. Very closely aligned to the ANC. It collapsed after the ANC's disastrous turn to 'armed struggle' in the early 1960s. UDE: United Democratic Font, open, legal mass organisati which provided the above ground focus for the ANC in the 4,000 shop and distribution workers rally in Johannesburg roughly and politely translated means 'down with: ed Gorbachevite.
He glosses over the Stalinist history of the SACP, assures his readers that 'the spirit of democracy' finds expression both in the party and in the relations between the party and 'fraternal political forces' , appeals to the traditions of independent trade unionism by declaring that 'no political party should interfere with such independence, and affirms the need for a mass, democratic workers' party alongside the ANC.
Since then, other party afficionados like Jeremy Cronin have argued that the SACP was only 'mildly Stalinist' since to the best of his knowledge it did not physically eliminate its political opponents.
Second, the line of the independent trade unionists seems to be summed up by a recent NUMSA bulletin. It calls for a democratic, broad-based socialist party which enjoys the support of a large section of the working class' . It admits that the SACP does not 'currently have all these credentials' but assures us (but where's the evidence?) of 'clear indications of a willingness to transform itself'. The image is that of the SACP becoming 'the effective catalyst for unifying the left' The 'skeletons' in the SACP cupboard are aired: its support for Stalinism over the years; its support for suppression in Hungary, Czechoslovakia, Poland, Afghanistan, etc. (but no mention of Ethiopia); its dogmatic insistence on the theory of colonialism of a special type; its sectarian attitude to critics; its purges and authoritarian attitudes; and not least its attempt to stop the growth of socialism in the unions.
But all this is in the past. The new Communist Party must abandon 'vanguardism' become open and broad-based, democratic and accountable, and respect the independence of the unions. The bulletin is confident that Slovo and most of the leaders have already endorsed many of these principles"
The task as the NUMSA bulletin sees it is to convert or push aside a few old Communist dinosaurs who remain addicted to dictats and encourage individual socialists within the unions (but not the unions themselves) to make joining the party their "first option'. This is characterised not as an 'entryist' position — 'which advocates joining a political party with the aim of transforming it or destroying it on the basis of some hidden agenda decided by a secret clique' -but as an agenda for transferring trade union democracy to the party.
NUMSA now declares its support for the ANC-SACP-COSATU alliance and for the establishment of an Alliance Forum between them as an organisational base for negotiations with the government.
Readers of SO may wonder whether this love affair with the SACP is a case of stunning naivete or a rationalisation for having given in to the very real pressures placed on trade unionists to toe the party line or be damned as a 'counter-revolutionary' Doubtless a bit of both. In my view, a large part of the problem is the traditional tendency of the old FOSATU unionists to reduce political questions to organisational procedures.
"he same naivete was present in convinced that they could dominate the new COSATU by virtue of their stronger organisational base in the unions. What happened was that they were overtaken by politics, or rather by a party line within the unions which had a definite political line and access to power within the liberation movement.
Another image of how the SACP operates in the unions has been recently offered in an article by Jan Theron on the take-over of the Food Union (FAWU) by a faction associated with the SACP (he did not know whether they were actually SACP members).
Any leadership, he points out, can claim to be building workers' control and democracy, but 'where there is no workers' control and democracy there will be no-one to contradict them'. In FAWU, he argues, these fine names have been the cover for Stalinist forms of top-down nomination.
Without entering into the details of his step-by-step account, Theron says that the faction used its power on the NEC of the union and its support from within COSATU to purge any branch officials and shopstewards who opposed it, slander them as "counter-revolutionary' and 'enemies of the people' and close down branches which refused to accept these decisions. Jan Theron himself has been illegally denied re-entry into the union after taking a sabbatical leave to write.
The key problem as Theron sees it is to reassert control from below. To this end a Campaign for Democracy in FAWU has been formed with his support. He writes:
"The experience of the Campaign for Democracy shows that it will not be easy to safeguard democracy, given the authoritarian political culture still prevailing. Indeed, the viciousness of the attacks on the Campaign seem in part to be because it is trying to operate as an open faction. Yet what alternative is there for workers who are looking for democracy in their union? What alternative is there if unions are to continue to contribute to an alternative political culture and if workers' control and democracy are to be more than a slogan?... Unity from the bottom up cannot be built in a culture of fear where there is no workers' control and democracy... Workers, look what is happening to your organisation and take control." In evaluating the growing influence of the SACP among union organisers, officials and the new breed of full-time shop stewards, one can understand their preference for being 'in" rather than 'out' of the new order which they have fought so hard for; one can also see why they should deceive themselves and others that such is the path to socialism. But despite its gains, the political position of the SACP remains precarious. I have the impression that many of the new recruits are holding the door ajar for a later retreat.
Buoy moveme nt In the history of the liberation movement, nothing could be more erroneous than the image of black people as an undifferentiated mass united by a single political consciousness in their oppositon to apartheid. The history of class struggle has been one of debate and dissent, sharp breaks and abrupt turns, competing political organisations and traditions, ad hoc alliances and unpredicted outcomes. We should avoid the temptation to flatten artificially this rocky landscape by drawing a one-dimensional picture of a singular movement, hegemonised by this or that party, for ever advancing with the support of the people to the final goal of liberation. Between the political myth and the real history lies not just a chasm but everything that makes the liberation movement in South Africa so wonderfully rich. From Bob Fine's forward to "Beyond Apartheid" Available from most bookshops
----- pull-quotes -----
PARTHEI and the liberatio