Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The film-maker as colonialist

Socialist Organiser no. 462, 12 October 1990 · scan p. 11 · about 629 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Belinda White Weaver r Hunter, ilm-making on a grand scale is mini-colonialism. Rapacious movie crews take over a place, use it, waste it, bend it to their will, then abandon it to move on to the next project.

They're drawn to the picturesque, the unspoiled, but their presence in a place wrecks the very thing that tempted them there. They ride roughshod over other races, other cultures; they move through like a hurricane, wreaking irreparable damage.

White Hunter, Black Heart is less about the disastrous effects of filmmaking than about one filmmaker's obsession with shooting an elephant, but it can stand in for the other. John Wilson (played by Clint Eastwood, and based on the real life director John Huston) has the same search-and-destroy attitude to his hunting as he has to the film he is about to make, The African Queen.

Africa is there to serve him, to feed his obsessions. He has a lordly attitude towards the country and the people there; they exist to provide him with the experience he wants.

Though he lectures a woman about anti-semitism and gets into a fight with a racist hotel manager, Wilson/Huston is hardly right on.

"Africa is there to serve him, to feed his obsessions. He has a lordly attitud towards the count and the people there."

He ignores everything but his own wishes and desires, even when it puts both his hunting companions and his film crew at risk.

The film crew which reconstructs the 'authentic' Congo village in the later part of the film is just the logical extension of Wilson's attitudes. He cares nothing for the African people, for their traditions, their lives; they're never there to be used White Hunter, Black Heart never really gets started, so it's hard to know if Eastwood was trying to show the destructive nature of filmmaking generally or just trying to put one man's obsession on screen.

Either way, it doesn't add up to much. The fault is partly in the casting. Eastwood is not an actor who invites you into his private thoughts; he's too closed off from the audience. He doesn't communicate.

If we're to watch and identify with someone's obsession, we need to be drawn into it; it has to have a kind of logic for us in the audience, or we're left out of things. That's what happens in White Hunter, Black Heart. We know Wilson/ Huston wants to kill an elephant, but why does he want to? How does it link into his supposed selfdestructiveness?

After a while, do we really care? I don't think so. Like Wilson's much put upon producer, we want Wilson to stop messing around too; we want to see The African Queen made. There's more of a story in that.

Clint Eastwood may simply be too familiar to us to seem credible in the role. We've seen him too often as a tightly-wound loner to find him credible as a larger-thanlife, fast-talking, Irish-American charmer. John Huston was that type, and he had a magical voice, a real tale spinner's voice. Eastwood seems smaller than life. He doesn't inhabit the role.

The film is structured almost as a thriller, with a kind of countdown - will Wilson kill the elephant before filming starts, or will he miss his deadline, and wreck the movie?

But this is a flop as a plot device. We already know the answer to that - Huston settled down, the film got made - so the tension is fake. It doesn't add up to anything.

And at the end, we're still outside Hue, it semi he is sadne and wisery but we still don't know him or feel for him. We're still outside looking in. And from there, there isn't a lot to see.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 462

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →