Socialism and democracy are indivisible
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-10-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
In 1985 a fringe meeting at Labour Party conference about Proportional Representation (PR) attracted about half a dozen people. By 1989 PR won one-third of the vote. But this year, against the leadership's advice, conference voted to examine the whole question.
There is now a widespread recognition that the "first past the post' system is grotesquely undemocratic. For example:
• In 1951 the Labour Party won 50% of the electorate, got more votes than the Tories - and yet lost!
• In October 1974 Labour won a mere 28% of the electorate and stayed in office until 1979. In February 1974 the Liberals won 6 million votes and yet only 14 seats.
• In 1983 the Alliance almost got more votes than labour - 7¾ million to 8½ million. As reward the Alliance got 23 seats and Labour 209.
• In 1989, at the Euro elections, the Greens received 2 million votes and no seats at all.
As things European become more known and more important there has been a growing awareness that other European countries do things differently in this as in many other things. People are also aware that not one of the newly emerging democracies of Eastern Europe has opted for the 'first past the post" system. As Jeff Rooker put it at conference: *they've had enough of dictatorships — elective or otherwise"
A second reason swing toward PR is the •Thatcher governments. With only a minority of votes cast in each of her three election victories, with a smaller share of the national vote than any of the other 17 heads of government in Western Europe, she has ruthlessly exploited the absence of checks to her parliamentary majority. That majority, delivered by a dodgy electoral system, has licensed every hated measure from the Poll Tax to the dismantling of the National Health Service. This brute fact has fuelled the growing movement not just for PR but for a thorough democratisation of the ancient, walled off, and undemocratic machinery of British government.
• gainst PR Roy Hattersley advances A two arguments. First, that PR means that "no party would ever achieve an overall parliamentary majority". Second that the existing system provides "strong government' or, as Gavin Laird put it, "Roy's elective dictatorship" Both arguments are a disgrace. If it is impossible for a socialist party to win over 50% of HE POLITICAL FRONT Alan Johnson the popular vote - what pessimism! - then we might as well pack up and go home anyway, because socialism will be either the movement of the immense majority in the interests of the immense majority or it will be It cannot by its nature be imposed from above whether by tanks or parliamentary majorities which represent actual minorities. It can only be created from below by the self-activity and creativity of millions of working people as they resist the old and build the That is also why the "strong government" argument is so ridiculous. The existing government machine in Britain, growing up as it has alongside capitalism, is 'strong' for certain purposes and certain interests. It is strong for enforcing the priorities of capital, for shielding the power and privilege of the wealthy, for locking people up, etc. But it is not an instrument which we can simply wield for our own very different purposes. For encroaching on the power and privilege of the wealthy, for empowering working people it would not be strong. It would not be strong for socialism, but would be its implacable enemy.
The standard left-wing objection to PRoften voiced by Peter Hain - is that the link between voter and accountable MP would be broken. But surely Hain romanticises the links that exist or could exist out of all recognition?
MPs are less useful than local councillors or welfare rights workers for most of the issues which send constituents to their surgeries in the first place, administrative jurisdiction.
A quarter only hold surgeries monthly. 1 in 10 only visit their constituencies monthly. A survey in the 1970s revealed that 1 in 2 voters could not name their MP and only 1 in 4 could name a single thing they had done in Parliament. For MPs elected once in five years from constituencies of 60,000 people on average it is difficult to take this argument seriously:
ven in straight electoral terms it is possible that Labour could do better under PR. Labour gets 1½ million votes in the Home Counties, south coast and South West, but only two seats. In a PR system it would get not only more seats but a lot more votes as it would not be squeezed as a 'third party' • Once you unpack the decline in the Labour vote since 1951 the 'first past the post' system can be shown to be itself a significant factor.
In 'unwinnable' seats Labour's vote has declined from 33% to 7%. In "safe' seats Labour's vote has declined from 79% to 56%. In marginal seats Labour's vote has gone down only eight points over the same period, from 49% to 41%.
Socialism and democracy are indivisible. Socialists should unreservedly support a new and fairer electoral system.
Quotes of the week Clare Short: "Neil is a democrat Neil Kinnock: 'I'm more interest than resolutions
Scan page 11
Liverpool Council: erpool Council: Socialist Organiser No.462 October 12 1990 page 11