Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Party policy

Socialist Organiser no. 462, 12 October 1990 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,910 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

actice it in our own party? Yesterday we debated and pported the restoration of civil erties eroded by Thatcher. We ked about the Birmingham 6. Comrades, at least the rmingham 6 saw and heard the poked police evidence. Socialist ganiser did not see the evidence at was presented to the NEC. How can we persuade people that are serious about civil liberties d justice if we don't practice it in r own party?

PPCs have come to this rostrum ying all week that this or that solution will help us win the next neral election and help us win our ats. As a PPC I tell you this solution, this action by the NEC, Ill not help us win the next ection. If we want to be taken riously as a lair, open and mocratic party we should support is emergency resolution.

in Johnson, Birmingham illy Oak CLP Comrades, this Labour Party sets itself up to be quite rightly the party of e people. But people are not atic, they change and grow. And if the Labour Party is to rvive it must change and grow o. And indeed it does this. The Labour Party of today is not e same Labour Party that we ted for or supported 10 years o, or even five years ago. But for this change to happen in a althy and constructive way we ed debate, a real debate in which views are expressed, even those ews to which we may be totally posed. Indeed, 1 do not support e viewpoint of Socialist ganiser, but I do support their ht to print it.

It is not freedom of speech that is Tony Tony Clarke, replying NEC Cion to uphold the rules of lonference, the NEC decisthis party is reported for all members of the party, and especially delegates, to read on page 18.

And when you read that you will see the difference between what the NEC decided and some of the mythology that's already come out from the very limited debate we've had this morning.

We considered a report from our Director of Organisation that contains sufficient evidence that Socialist Organiser is an organised group of members within the party, which, as stated in the report, has its programme, has its principles of policy for distinctive and separate propaganda, and possesses branches within the party for this purpose.

That's the report you have in front of you and that's what the NEC considered. Having considered the report, and having considered the evidence - and I want to stress a point; every piece of evidence in the portfolio given to every single member of the NEC was published by, at various levels, Socialist Organiser: and I say various levels because we're not talking about the right to publish a newspaper, we're talking about the right of a separate party to organise within our party, and that's the issue.

The report, and I would emphasise, did not deal with "individuals' it dealt with a structure. It showed the programme of Socialist Organiser. It was not an isolated incident. It was a comprehensive document that contained various numbers of items which - if some of my comrades would keep quiet l'll tell them what it was.

The report showed that Socialist Organiser has an Executive Further Education, There was also the decision to produce the supporters' cards for use in FE colleges.

We saw ourselves - without any shadow of doubt - the reporting of a discussion where they wanted to set up regional committees.

We saw the record of group committee meetings, references to EC members, a group described as a caucus needed - this caucus needed - listen, because you wanted to know why we made our decision. Listen and I'll tell you. We saw a record which described the caucus.

They needed regular meetings to discuss how to influence Labour Party policy. Conference, as I said earlier, the NEC were not considering a one-off situation. Alright, you don't like it. But when someone tells you the truth, have the courtesy to listen.

Conterence, a cnurch without a roof is still a church, but a church without walls is a place where you get trampled on. We're not in the business of being trampled on by outsiders.

The mover actually said that the candidate in Wallasey got this huge amount of votes. I tell you what, conference, they wouldn't have got a bagful of votes if they'd have stood under the banner of Socialist Organiser. They stood under a Labour Party banner.

If you want to throw your rules away, and it's something which you won't, you know what the answer will be, we'd be like these rag, tag and bobtails who we want to see run under their own banner.

Conference, sany - individual knows that they get the right of natural justice in this party. We're dealing with a party within a party which is contradicting the clause 1 referred to in our constitution.

In your own interests, not in the interests of any people on the NEC or anybody else, uphold the NEC report and reject this emergency motion.

This record of the debate has been slightly cut for reasons of space. If you would like a full record please contact Socialist Organiser,

Scan page 10

"The emancipation of the proletariat not a labour of small account and of little men; only he who can keep his heart strong and his will sharp as a sword when the general disillusionme is at its worst can be regarded as a fighter for the working class or called Antonio Gramsci, 24 September 1920 revolutionary".

Italy, Autumn, 1920. The powerful workers' revolt that had shaken the country for two years - the "Red two years' was over.

The workers of Turin - who had occupied the factories behind an armei cordon of Red guards - were in retreat. The national union officials called off the action and settled for small concessions. The rank and file Socialism and F were disoriented.

Within two years, Mussolini was lead his 'March on Rome'. By 1926 Gramsci, the greatest thinker of the Italian Marxist movement, was in gad He died soon after his release in 193 The fascist prosecutor at his trial declared "We must stop this brain functioning for 20 years!" Gramsci's ideas live on, THE CULTURAL FRO Books Janet Burstall reviews 'A Secret Country by John Pilger, Jonathan Cape, 1989.

hady secrets of Australian history and society are the topic of Pilger's book. He wants us to recognise the problems and issues that many would rather forget.

He aptly quotes Czech novelist Milan Kundera: "The struggle of people against power is the struggle of memory against forgetting"

Pilger is on the side of the underdog, and he is angry with Bob Hawke and the Australian Labor Party for siding with a group of the wealthy at the expense of the less well off. He is certainly prepared to confront Hawke with some harsh questions, and in the chapter on Mates, to throw the spotlight on Hawke's connections with the bosses. The Mates form a powerful network, including senior Labor politicians, CIA officials, media magnates, property developers, transport bosses, public officials and other wealthy charlatans.

Pilger laments that so few journalists in Australia have confronted Hawke and the Treasurer, Paul Keating, with questions about how their policies have benefited the wealthy. He attributes this at least in part to the way the Mates control the media - both commercial and The best chapters of the book are "A whispering in our hearts' about progress, and lack of it, towards justice for Aborigines; Heroes unsung' about migrant labour and multiculturalism; (The coup' about the role of secret police, particularly the CIA, in the sacking of the Whitlam Labor government in 1975; and "Mates' , about the wealthiest and most powerful few, and their links with members of the Labor government.

The strength of the book is represented in these chapters. They show Australia as a class society that doesn't match up to the myth that everyone is more or less equally well off here. They also give a picture of how the ruling class rules, through its network of ownership, connections with government and the state apparatus.

The weakness of the book is that Pilger seems to have a romantic idea of what it means to be Australian, and that everyone used to be more or less equal until Bob Hawke came along and messed up both the ALP and the distribution of wealth and power. Until then the problem was that Australia wasn't truly independent enough of Britain and the USA.

Pilger cites approvingly the records of previous Labor leaders, ignoring some terrible anti-working class actions. Jack Lang, New South Wales Premier in the Great Depression, is seen as fighting for independence by refusing to pay interest on a loan from the Bank of England. But what of his campaign against the socialisation units in the Labor Party? Ben Chifley, PM during World War II, "embodied the ethos and mythology of Australianism...fair-minded man who believed that a system of 'them' and 'us' was an absurdity." But what of Chifley using troops against striking miners?

In arguing that Australia is not truly independent, Pilger does reveal the very close co-operation of Australia with the British and US governments, secret police, military operators and investments. But Pilger suggests that this is a betrayal of Austria national interests, rather than a mutually beneficial pursuit of the interests of the capitalist class of all these countries. He seems to believe that independence from US and British policies can be achieved by commitment to Australian interests, whatever they might be.

Australian troops sent to join forces with the US in Vietnam is seen as Australians fighting another country's (the US) war. Pilger doesn't see the invasion of Vietnam as a policy of the ruling classes of the US and Australia in the interests of the workers of neither country. Pilger tells how Prime Minister Menzies made a secret request to the South Vietnamese puppet regime to ask for Australian troops, and when it was not forthcoming, he lied to Parliament. But he sees the significance of this being Menzies' slavishness to the US, rather than a zeal to 'fight communism' Two instances that we can join him in condemning are the British atomic bomb explosions at Maralinga int he 1950s, and the CIA involvement in the sacking of the Whitlam government. But Pilger does not discuss Australian capital's international expansion, and Australian military presence in the South East Asia and Pacific region. He just complains that Murdoch has given up Australian citizenship to become an American, as though this is a betrayal.

The romantic nationalism of the book is expressed in irritating journalese at points. For example in the chapter on Mates, most of the Mates are called by nicknames which are not all common currency in Australia. There are frequent hyperbolic claims that Australia is the first, last, only, best or worst in the world on a number of scores which lack credibility.

The nationalism is tempered by a sense of justice and solidarity with the underdog the world over. He does appeal for a sense of internationalism, even though his understanding of Australia is nationalist.

----- pull-quotes -----

hange needs eal debate eal

e secret network that runs Australia Those who do not learn from history are likely to repeat it

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 462

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →