Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Alternative cancer therapies

Socialist Organiser no. 461, 1 October 1990 · scan p. 14 · about 609 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

For some years, people involved in cancer medicine both patients and doctors, have felt frustration at the slow progress being made in treating and curing most cancers. In others, survival rates have improved. But in many cases, patients are given treatments of a drastic nature: powerful drugs that harm helathy tissue as well as cancerous; surgery that leaves the patient feeling mutilated _ and they still die!

Of course, attempts are being made to reduce the side effects of the drugs or to reduce the scale of the surgery. Unfortunately, despite (some would say perhaps because of) these efforts, death rates fromthe major killers, lung, breast, colon and cervical cancers, continue to remain at high levels.

It was a dissatisfaction with the conventional approach to cancer, the feeling of being a helpless victim where the treatment seemed often worse than the disease, that led to such alternative treatments as were pioneered at the Bristol Cancer Help Centre.

The centre, opened by Prince Charles in 1983, treats some 1500 patients a year with a variety of therapies which aim to heal the whole person'.

These therapies include touch, relaxation, counselling and 'visualisation'*. Patients are recommended to follow a vegetarian, if not vegan, diet of organically grown food.

Patients may visit for a day, a week or perhaps for much longer periods. Fees of up to f600 per week may be charged but many pay nothing at all.

Since there was little evidence to support the use of these therapies, the BCHC has been regarded with -suspicion, scorn and hostility by some in the medical profession. Others, like cancer specialist professor Karol Sikora of Hammersmith Hospital, have included elements of the BCHC approach in their treatments. BCHC has not tried to counterpose itself to conventional medicine and most of its patients receive usual cancer treatments of anti-cancer drugs or radiation.

Though some of the Bristol approaches seem a bit way out, there is certainly evidence of a strong psychic factor in getting cancer and surviving it. People who have suffered such life events as bereavement or divorce in the previous five years are about three times more likely to get cancer. Of those who have got breast cancer, more survive it who have a fighting attitude than who have an accepting, fatalistic attitude.

Sensitive to its lack of track record, the BCHC decided to commission a survey of its success in treating women with breast cancer. A team from the Institute of Cancer Kesearch, led by Professor Clair Chilvers of Nottingham University, compared the health of 334 women who first attended the BCHC between June 1986 and October 1987 with that of 461 women who attended three hospitals. All were under 70 at diagnosis and had a single breast tumour. All received conventional treatment, The health of the women was compared in June 1988 and the result of the comparison was quite sensational. Now, it might be expected that, at worst, the alternative approaches would have no effect. After all, the women were still getting conventional treatment. In fact, women who had attended BCHC were nearly three times more likely to have secondary cancers and nearly twice as likely to die.

There is no obvious explaination for this finding, though some have focussed on the diet recommended by the centre. Some doctors have suggested that the diet may not be providing enough nourishment though Bristol Royal Infirmary dieticians have praised it. Others have said that there is 'not a jot' of evidence that the diet could help and it has been likened to getting a lung cancer patient to give up smoking in

----- pull-quotes -----

Les Hearn's SCIENCE COLUMN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 461

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →