Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Picnics, privilege and revolution

Socialist Organiser no. 461, 1 October 1990 · scan p. 13 · about 522 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

"Milou in May' ouis Malle's film, Milou in May is lovely. The May is May '68, and Milou is an ageing winemaker, whose bossy mother has just died. With her death comes the need for the family to decide the future of the estate - the rambing old house, the vineyards, the land, with its beehives and trees and stream full of crayfish.

So the family gathers around bier, and the squabbles begin. Milou doesn't want to sell; he loves the house, he loves his life there. We can see why; it's idyllic.

But the others don't want to pay to keep the place up. They're practical minded bourgeoises; they'd rather sell, and put the money to work.

But then news of the strikes and the street battles in Paris starts filtering through, and something in the air suddenly changes. The news, which worries and frightens them at first, soon comes to seem like a liberation. Pretty soon they're all picnicking on the grass, overflowing with good will and brotherhood, planning to turn the estate into a self-managed co-op for everyone to enjoy. They've fallen in love with their own potential, with their better side.

May '68 comes to seem not just like a liberation for workers, but as a liberation for everybody, a way of ending their isolation and their selfishness, their obsession with grabbing as much as they can for themselves, and a way of helping them to a more shared, more generous way of life. It's a flowering.

But then, the worries set in. Will they, as the middle class, as the enemy, be victimised by the new regime? They start to panic. Finally, they abandon the house and flee, terrified that they'll be caught and punished for their privileges.

When news finally reaches them of the defeat of the movement, they stumble out of their hiding place, dazed and uncomprehending; they can't believe they've survived.

Despite their relief, something has been lost. With the crushing of the revolution, the world seems meaner, their hopes have contracted; gone is the feeling of brotherhood that briefly buoyed them up. They're back to being individuals, isolated, on their own.

Malle has captured many things in the film, not least the sight of the bourgeoisie enjoying thier privileges - their music, their houses, their wine, the good life. They take their culture for granted; they wear it lightly, with ease. They're at home in the world.

But Malle also shows what a loss the defeat of the revolutionary hopes was - for everyone.

The family in Milou in May weren't the big bourgeoisie, like the capitalist factory owner and his wife who arrive to take panic stricken refuge with them. When the family stopped fighting each other in the brief flowering of comradeship inspired by the newscasts, they were happy. Life was better.

But not afterwards. After the fight they'd had, the capitalists wanted revenge. They wanted blood. They didn't just want the status quo back; they went on the offensive.

Watching Milou in May, it's not hard to see where the greedy, selfserving ideas of the Thatcher era came from.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 461

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →