Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Cinematic guerilla

Socialist Organiser no. 461, 1 October 1990 · scan p. 12 · about 1,851 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Ken Loach's new film, "Hidden Agenda", , caused a furore at the Cannes Film Festival. He talked to Tim Thomas about that film and the rest of his work.

met Ken Loach in an editing room. A small screen showed workers walking backwards and forwards very rapidly to and from a building site.

Ken and the editor were discussing where to put the voices. It was a long discussion, and there were many backwards and forwards movements.

When they had finally made a decision, Ken and I sat opposite each other across the cutting table. Ken had armed himself with two or three Lion Bars for the interview (in terms of tittle-tattle, I can vouch for him being a chocaholic). Below us, out the window, the crowds were going home down Oxford Street.

I decided to start with a blockbuster question. "As a director, what do you feel are your best achievements and greatest disappointments over the last twenty five years?"

Ken winced - "Oh God!"

He is just like they say he is - immensely self-effacing and all too ready to ascribe his film-making to the collective endeavour of the team.

The film he most enjoyed making was A Miner's Story. It took four days. It was an "unpretentious little film" made in August '84 and attempting, by way of the songs and conversations of the miners, to give a picture of the kind of culture that grew up during the strike. He and the film crew went all over the mining areas in that short space of time.

he disappointing moments? These were the ideas he and those who wrote for him had, but could not translate into the medium of film.

I asked him about some of the filmic influences that had fashioned his particular style. Straight off he referred to the Czech film-makers of the '60s, especially Forman who started out making one of the most touching comedies of that decade, Blonde In Love, and wound up corrupted by Hollywood - that's my opinion and not necessarily Ken's), Jiri Menzel (Closely Observed Trains), and Olmi's Tree of Wooden Clogs. He liked the humour of those films, but most of all he liked the way they directed their actors.

He started as an actor, and I think this has had more of an influence on him than he cares to admit. He moved from acting to become a film director for the BBC.

He likes films that employ nonprofessionals, mentioning particularly Bresson in this respect, "though Bresson is too cold for me. He attacks the Hollywood system ("never had much attraction for me"'). "It exploits by overemphasising effects like music. The films take on a pushy, febrile quality". "Film probably has a minimal effect on the political situation. I just want to raise some questions, contribute to the pool of opposition and perhaps make people angry"

Ken is a little chary about discussing future projects. He is just completing Riff-Raff, about a bunch of building workers in London. It was written by a building worker, Bill Jesse, and it is what he was watching on the editing screen. "I thought it was time for a bit of fun"

Another possibility is a film called Who Framed Arthur Scargill? (a story that needs "a political context"). Ken's idea is that the new Labour Party thrives on left phantoms and Aunt Sallies. "It needs Scargill, Socialist Organiser, etc. to prove to the average Daily Mail reader that it is not like them"

Ken Loach But these films are only ideas in his head. "There's nothing definite". "So the rumour that you and Jim Allen are planning a film on the Spanish Civil War is just a rumour?" He laughs. "Can I mention it?" "Yes, you can mention it, but don't elaborate on it"

I asked him what, beyond the overtly political in his films, were the other important ingredients. He was, he said, concerned with trying to capture the quality of life of people and of working relations especially. *There is a real crack between people who work" , and it was important to show it, to record it.

A mass of American films romanticising violence and unconcerned with the realities of everyday working people come to my mind as he emphasises "the crack between people who work". These American movies are increasingly the staple diet of the British cinema. The working class is denied images of its own culture, and instead is asked to glory in the absurd adventures of superstars like Bruce Willis. Loach says that these days, "working relations are invariably coarsened or else ignored on film"

Again and again he stresses that film is a collective endeavour. He is an actor's director in many respects. All people can act, he says, and the danger of the professional actor is that he might lose the vital inner resource of feeling freshly about the situation he's placed in. Ordinary people do not do this.

He had seen Michael Caine giving his celebrated seminar on film acting. He felt it had all been unnecessary.

"People don't need to know that" • They just have to believe they are where they are, and the director has to provide the "sym"There is a real crack a real between people between people who work" and it Wa important to she record it." pathetic observation"

It all sounds so simple and so pleas rable. The purpose of film is simple too - getting the audience to identify with the joys and struggles of the characters they are watching. But also, of course, to achieve a grasp of the issues we all share that lie behind those joys and struggles. And this is where Loach's socialist convictions come into play.

Derek Malcolm, reviewing Hidden Agenda in the Guardian after its screening at the Cannes Film Festival (it won the Jury prize) said, comparing Hidden Agenda with Kes, that "argument without art is useless in the Well, he thought Malcolm's review was "bullshit", full of value judgments and fighting clear of any political interpretation. "Art and politics are not at all incompatible... there was no less thought given to sequence, narrative, light in Hidden Agenda than there was in Kes"

The majority of British film critics did not have much taste for argument. They preferred political inferences to uncompromising statements. He's heated on this point. "Art is the conscious deployment of certain factors in film-making: light, rhythm, acting. We took no more short cuts with Hidden Agenda because it was political"

In Hidden Agenda a career policeman not unlike Stalker (who appears now to be a disc jockey on Radio Two) is sent for the same reason and uncovers not simply verification of shoot-to-kill but a much more disturbing conspiracy: that the disinformation and black propaganda employed against the IRA had also been used, during the '70s, against Heath and Wilson.

A right-wing Tory government is installed. Will Kerrigan (the Stalker figure) continue his investigation and arrest Nevin the Neave figure), or will he, in the end, back down and keep his trap shut?

Ken is well known as a supporter of "Time to Go!" Socialist Organiser also backs 'Time to Go!" but is mindful of the bloody and negative effects of a prolonged civil war which would end up further from a united socialist Ireland than we are now.

Ken agrees that "there won't before or after British withdrawal", but "there will certainly be no peace with British state intervention" "The Irish have to solve this problem. Only they can forge a new He himself, he said, is "practically a pacifist". This took me by surprise, bearing in mind the kind of forces he and Allen describe in the film. How can we win peacefully against such authority?

"Perhaps that came out a bit glibly", There was a difference between wars of liberation and wars of repression. "So your pacifism is not like the Quakers?" "No, no. But he is opposed to the death penalty on principle.

He wasn't going to defend the IRA, in fact if pushed he would condemn the killings. On the other hand he wasn't going to pontificate.

Hidden Agenda is not really about the Irish situation at all. It is about something basic to the idea of the state.

Loach describes the Ireland of Hidden Agenda as "a location" — a place from where to begin to tell the story of the conspiracy to get Thatcher to head the Tories and eventually become leader of the government. The streets could be made safe for capitalism by the spread of lies and black propaganda. It began with lies about the Republicans and ended with garbage about Heath's sexuality and Wilson being a KGB agent.

When Kerrigan, the career policeman, finally ends up face to face with Alec Nevin. Nevin tells him, in reply to a question about spreading lies, "All politics is a conspiracy". This, says Ken, is a "recurring theme in Jim Allen's work". Allen wrote the screenplay for Hidden Agenda. They have worked together on several films: Days of Hope, The Big Flame, Rank and File. Throughout their assocation there has been an overriding formal quality in their work best described as Marxist, where ideas are the expression of class position. Ideas and class become the chief motivating factors in the plot.

The workers have their solidarity, the ruling class can counter this with manipulative skills picked up from the long history of Empire and the dextrous subjugation of peoples. But the conspiracies were not and are not gentle affairs: violence, mercilessness and exploitation are their stock-in-trade. but he has to learn that he is doing it errigan might only be doing his job, at the behest of forces who will stop at nothing to maintain their control.

What of Ken's general political views? He is optimistic about the changes in Eastern Europe and not at all charmed by Gorbachev.

Gorbachev is just a different kind of Stalinist. The West has benefitted greatly from him. When he comes over here he never provides us with even a hint of a socialist analysis of Britain"

I asked him about the left here. "It's been in a parlous state for some time. It began when Benn failed in his bid for the deputy leadership and was compounded by the defeat of the miners. The purpose now should be to keep the ideas alive, but you can't do that without making some sort of war against the Kinnockites"

Under the circumstances of defeat there is bound to be a degree of egoism, pettiness and factionalism - "but factionalism also has a positive side. In the end something good and thoughtful will emerge".

Ken took me downstairs and let me out into Oxford Street. He was nibbling his final bar of chocolate — a delicate figure, discreet, receptive and generous.

He doesn't know when we'll all be able to see Hidden Agenda, various things have held up the distribution. He waved goodbye and turned to walk back to the editing room and those construction workers jerkily walking backwards to the site.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 461

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →